Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Prescribed Drug Dependence and Withdrawal (PE1651)

Wednesday 24 March 2021 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30 Petitions 10 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next continued petition is PE1651, which was lodged by Marion Brown on behalf of Recovery and Renewal. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to take action to appropriately recognise and effectively support individuals who are affected and harmed by prescribed drug dependence and withdrawal.

Since the committee’s most recent consideration of the petition, submissions have been received from the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport, Beverley Thorpe Thomson, Ann Kelly, Barry Haslam and Dr Peter Gordon. Three submissions have also been received from the petitioner.

The cabinet secretary advises that a short-life working group on prescription medicine dependence and withdrawal was established to take forward consideration of the petition and to make recommendations, and that draft recommendations were approved by her in December 2020. The Scottish Government intends to publish those draft recommendations as a consultation this month. Further correspondence that the committee has received from the Scottish Government this week confirms that the consultation is now open and that responses will be collected until 4 June.

The cabinet secretary advises that she is keen to hear views from a wide range of interested members of the public and officials, and that two virtual sessions will be run during the period for which the consultation is open.

I welcome Jackie Baillie, who is attending the meeting for our consideration of the petition. I invite her to comment, after which I will ask committee members to reflect on what I consider to be significant progress by the Scottish Government on the issue.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I thank the convener and the committee for allowing me to speak. As someone who has previously attended meetings of the committee, I was definitely not going to miss its final meeting of the session.

I would like to record my personal thanks to the convener for her service to the Parliament for the past 22 years. It seems like yesterday when we were both starting out in 1999. She has had a very distinguished political career. Good luck to Johann Lamont.

I ask the committee to keep the petition open and to include it in its legacy paper, although I know that that might not be the committee’s instinct. I have been contacted by the petitioner, Marion Brown, and Ann Kelly, who is a constituent of mine. The reason for my asking the committee to keep the petition open is that the petitioners and their supporters have continuing concerns. In particular, they have concerns about the short-life working group that the Scottish Government set up to look at prescription medicine dependence. Even though they articulated those concerns directly to the working group, they felt that they had not been acknowledged or taken on board. They made the point to me that it has taken four years to get to this point, so they are nervous about continued progress.

There are concerns about the process, which, as I said, the petitioners have raised with the leadership. They also note that the language and emphasis of the Scottish Government and its advisers continue to be very much along the lines of the default position being to prescribe antidepressants without giving much explanation of the potential consequences of withdrawal. There does not seem to be awareness of the long-term problems that could be caused. They again made the point about the lack of practical support for people who are experiencing withdrawal—those issues have not been resolved.

As with the first petition, we will have a new cabinet secretary for health whatever the outcome of the election and we need to ensure that mental health stays very firmly near the top of the agenda. Continuing the petition would help with framing that, but, more importantly, it would mean that the petitioners do not need to start again with a problem that remains current and still needs to be addressed comprehensively by the Scottish Government.

I welcome the recommendations from the short-life working group, but I do not think that we are at the end of the process; it has just begun. Therefore, I would be enormously grateful if the committee would consider continuing the petition into the next session of Parliament.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank Jackie Baillie for her kind words. It is always useful to start nicely if you are going to make a case for a petition to be continued. I will be interested to hear what committee members feel about it.

I should underline something that is true for all petitions. There is a pressure to move petitions on because other petitioners are in a queue waiting to come in. It is a matter of balancing the rights of petitioners against the rights of new petitioners. That is the pressure that is operating and it becomes more intense as we get towards the end of a session. It is not a reflection of the significance of the individual petitions, but a kind of balanced judgement.

For what it is worth, even though the petitioners are concerned about the process, significant achievements have been made—the fact that the working group was established and has produced recommendations, which are out for consultation. If I thought that there was nowhere for the petitioners to go, I would be more concerned, but it is clear that it would be a question of saying that they should engage with the consultation and highlight their concerns and issues around it to make it a live consultation, rather than a tick-box exercise. There would be greater force to a new petition, if they are disappointed, having engaged actively with the process.

The Scottish Government is looking at the issue, as the petitioners wanted, even though there are flaws with the process. It is not a closed book to them, but something that they can engage with. Therefore, the judgment is whether the committee can add anything by holding on. The force of a new petition that said, “We engaged with this in good faith and nothing happened”, would be very powerful. I emphasise to the petitioners that none of that is in any way a reflection of the seriousness with which we take their concerns about an area that they have highlighted to the committee over a period of time, which had probably not been given sufficient focus in the past.

I very much agree with Jackie Baillie that, whatever comes out of Covid, in the new session there has to be a strategy to deal with issues around mental health and how those are dealt with. If, as the petitioners contend, there has been inappropriate use of prescriptions or drugs that are not then monitored closely, that is a huge area that will develop in the next period. The decision to close would not in any way undermine the significance of what has been said. As I said, I will be interested to hear what committee members think, but I emphasise and underline that, even if we close the petition, the issue is clearly not going away. There is a vehicle for it to be pursued and there are further options to come back to the Public Petitions Committee.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I thank the petitioner Marion Brown for bringing the petition to the committee. Progress has been made on it—not everything that the petitioner wants, but the short-life working group has made draft recommendations that are out for public consultation and the petitioner is able to feed into that consultation. I do not think that the committee can take it any further, but if there are specific issues that the petitioner is not happy with, that would be reflected better in a new petition in the new session of Parliament, which could highlight the issues and bring them forward to the committee.

Therefore, I am happy to close the petition under rule 15.7 of standing orders.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

It is a difficult one, but on balance I go with your thoughts, convener. We have achieved quite a bit with the petition. A consultation is going on and the petitioners can participate in it. Bearing in mind that the petitioners can always come back with a new petition if they are not satisfied with the results of the consultation process, on balance I am for closing the petition at this stage.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I concur with what has been said. The right thing to do is to let the consultation run its course. The petitioners and anyone else who has been following the petition can feed into the consultation. As I have said before, and as we all know, the issue is extremely important, and I am loth to let the petition go but, as it stands, we have taken it as far as we can. It is in part due to the tenacity of the petitioners that we have got to this stage, so I thank them very much. There is the option of bringing back the petition in the new session if the conclusions of the consultation are not what the petitioners expected. That will be the right time to bring back the petition. Given what is happening and the work that is going on, I am content for us to close the petition.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I, too, know Marion Brown from my work as a regional MSP—I have had several meetings with her. I understand Jackie Baillie’s point of view, and I know that she has had a lot to do with the petition, for which I thank her. I have concerns about the points that have been raised and about the long-term effects of prescribed drug dependence but, on balance, I feel that we have taken the petition as far as we reasonably can. At least we have achieved a consultation process, and that has to run its course. The petitioners can feed into that along with others who are concerned about the issue. After the public consultation, if Dr Brown or her team are unhappy with any points, they can lodge a new petition. We need to give the consultation process and the short-life working group a chance.

I concur with the issues that Dr Brown has raised with me in my time as a regional MSP, and I am concerned about the long-term effects. Nevertheless, I agree with my colleagues and with you, convener, that we should close the petition under rule 15.7 of standing orders, and on the basis that I have just set out.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am not sure whether Jackie Baillie wants to come back in, but there is a clear consensus on action. Is there anything that you want to flag up to us, Jackie?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Yes, convener. I know when not to flog a dead horse, but let me make a couple of observations that the committee might want to raise with the Scottish Government, either now or in future. It has taken four years for a short-life working group to report. I hope that the Government will consult quickly on the recommendations and will actually start to change things, because there is no doubt that a huge number of people are already dependent on antidepressants. As you rightly pointed out, convener, as we emerge from the pandemic, the scale of the problem will only increase, and people’s mental health will become a key consideration. I am grateful to the committee and I have no doubt that the petition might come back in the new session.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We recognise your comment about how long it has taken to get to this point. Clearly, for people who are in the middle of the system and who feel that folk are not listening to them or recognising the scale of the problems that they face, that is even more of a concern.

I suggest that, in closing the petition, we write to the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport to say that we recognise the force of the arguments that have been made, that we are encouraging the petitioners and others to engage fully with the consultation, that the issue is a matter of urgency for them and others, and that we certainly hope that the issue will be a focus of work in the future. Clearly, we do not know who the cabinet secretary will be after the election, as that is up in the air—it could be Jackie Baillie.

Nevertheless, it would be useful to underline that the committee is not simply saying, “Okay, you have done that work, move on.” It is a work in progress, and the committee’s role is in relation to where that progress appears to be stalled and another petition coming in would be helpful in pushing it on again.

10:30

We are agreeing to close the petition and we recognise that the short-life working group is consulting on its recommendations. We urge the petitioners to engage with that process and we recognise the scepticism about how that will be taken forward. In closing the petition we agree to write to the cabinet secretary to emphasise the concerns that people have highlighted.

We thank the petitioners for engaging thus far with the committee and recognising that it may be an issue that we want to come back to at a later stage. Their engagement with the consultation on recommendations is critical and their observations of the effectiveness of that consultation will be important. We thank the petitioners for all that they have done and continue to do to highlight these issues. I also thank Jackie Baillie, who I think will be here for another petition, so I will not say too many fond farewells yet.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 15
  3. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 24

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.