Thank you for having me again, convener. Before I answer your question, I acknowledge the reflective week that we are having. I feel that, across the UK, we should stop and take note for a moment of the 100,000 families who have lost loved ones. That affects me just as it affects you and everyone else in this fight, and it helps us to realise the purpose of the fight.
The answer to your question has a number of layers. I highlight that international travel and quarantine is not the only club in the bag. It has become the club in the bag in the past couple of days, but we should keep it in perspective. It will not be the way that we drive down present prevalence or the way that we find and isolate cases. However, as the numbers fall, it will become more important than ever to stop importing new cases.
We have proved twice in Scotland that the virus enters by coming across the border. The same is true of England, Spain and New Zealand. That is how the virus works—it needs people to move it, and that is what happens. We now know that, in July and August 2020, the virus was reimported into Scotland, having got to a low level.
There is a real policy challenge, which is slightly above my pay grade, about what to do about that. If we look around the world for examples of success in not importing the virus, we can see some successes, but they apply to unique geographies. Scotland is not one of those examples. Taiwan, New Zealand, Singapore, Australia and some other countries are examples. It could be argued that Finland and Norway, which are a bit closer to home, are examples of that to some extent.
Most of those countries have taken a strict approach on importing people and, therefore, importing the virus. Those decisions are really tricky and I do not envy the decision makers. The public health advice is relatively straightforward to say out loud: do not import any cases. We then get into a conversation about what that means.
The UK Government made an announcement yesterday, although the operational detail is still to be provided and we are not quite sure what it will look like. There was a four-nations call with the First Ministers of the devolved Administrations and Mr Gove, and the UK Government said that it was going to implement supported quarantine for high-risk countries. The First Minister and the Deputy First Minister both said yesterday—and I said in the advice that I gave at the podium—that that is the minimum that we believe is appropriate. The challenge is that people could dodge it by travelling via Amsterdam or taking some other route.
We have already banned travel from such places. Brazilian citizens cannot come to the UK just now—it is not allowed. A UK citizen who is coming home is allowed to come back from Brazil or from Portugal, but they would now have to quarantine in a quarantine hotel. However, that is relatively niche. It affects small numbers of people. What we need is a response to the much larger numbers of cases that are imported from around the world. The First Minister said that she would raise that in further negotiations across the UK countries.