Thank you for the opportunity to introduce this draft instrument. The central objective of the draft rules is to ensure a proper opportunity to participate for the brothers and sisters, and all those with similar relationships, of children coming before hearings. That especially applies where decisions could be made that will affect their contacts and relationships with the child who is subject to the hearing.
The draft instrument makes detailed provision for siblings around prior notification, invitation to attend and rights to make representations, to be accompanied or represented by another person and to be informed about the outcome of the hearing as it relates to their interests. That will allow a broader and more inclusive approach to be taken to siblings’ involvement in children’s hearings.
The rules follow the decision of the United Kingdom Supreme Court in the cases of ABC and XY last year. As the committee is aware, those cases considered siblings’ participative rights in children’s hearings. The Supreme Court’s decision recognised that the legislative scheme behind children’s hearings is compatible with children’s article 8 rights, but we all want Scotland’s childcare system to move from compliance towards excellence. The Government therefore lodged amendments to what became the Children (Scotland) Act 2020 to enable the changes to happen. The reform will also enable Scotland to honour important aspects of the independent care review promise on siblings.
The draft instrument refines aspects of children’s hearings procedure in important additional areas. It mainstreams the electronic authentication of signatures and introduces more flexibility in electronic participation. Both those measures were important features in last April’s emergency Coronavirus (Scotland) Act 2020. There is a shared appetite to hold on to those innovations for the benefit of families, decision makers and professionals.
The draft instrument empowers decision makers to exclude from hearings people whose conduct is dangerous, intimidating or disruptive. Exclusion may be necessary to obtain the views of a relevant person in, for example, a domestic abuse situation.
The draft instrument enables earlier sharing of independent reports and assessments among professionals. That is aimed at promoting better preparation and more informed and productive discussions at hearings.
I am happy to take questions from members.