Our next continued petition is PE1627, which was lodged by Annette McKenzie. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to provide for consultation with and consent from a parent or guardian before medication to treat mental ill health is prescribed to a patient who is under 18 years of age.
The committee most recently considered the petition in June 2018, when it agreed to hold an inquiry into how young people access mental health services and treatments. During its consideration of the petition, the committee considered written and oral evidence from the petitioner and key stakeholders, including the Scottish Government, the Scottish Youth Parliament, the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland and the Royal College of General Practitioners.
The committee noted that there was strong support among key stakeholders for the idea that young people under the age of 18 should be able to give consent to treatment for themselves. However, the evidence highlighted the existence of serious concerns about the experiences of young people in seeking help for their mental health. The committee therefore agreed to hold its inquiry. The clerk’s note details the key milestones of our inquiry, which culminated in the publication of our final report on 24 July. Following its publication, the committee secured time for a chamber debate on the report’s conclusions and recommendations on 1 December 2020.
I think that we drew a lot from the petition and were all struck by the testimony of the petitioner, Annette McKenzie, on the tragic circumstances in which she lost her daughter. It was clear that there is a huge desire to support young people, but it was also clear that there are strong views on confidentiality for under-18s.
Nevertheless, our report says that the importance of looking for support from their family or somebody whom they can trust in respect of any treatment that they are having is the kind of issue that a practitioner would flag up to a young person. That does not resolve the issues for young people, which are on-going and will be even more important, given Covid. Our report recognised that.
The question is whether the committee can take any issue further. My view is that we have done a substantial amount of work. Although that will not in any way address the huge gap in Annette McKenzie’s life, we recognise the importance of what she has done in highlighting a range of issues relating to the challenges that young people face and the support that they can be offered not only in the educational setting—in schools, for example—but in the workplace, given that employers also have a responsibility.
What are members’ responses on the action that we might take now?
