I welcome the opportunity to have this debate, even at this inauspicious time, after a long day. I am particularly grateful to those members who have stayed behind to debate what is an extremely important matter for so many people in my constituency, across Scotland and across the United Kingdom.
I record my thanks to members who supported the motion to allow the debate to take place. That would be members of the Scottish National Party, the Labour Party and the Greens, and Mark McDonald. One has to wonder about the lack of support from the Lib Dems or indeed the Tories, considering that the last line of the motion, which states that universal credit has been a
“vital safety net for nearly half a million people across Scotland”,
is a direct quote from the Tories’ leader, Douglas Ross. That is another example of the empty words of their Westminster-based leader meaning nothing to the Tories in this chamber.
It would appear that even the House of Lords supports the terms of my motion. Just last week, the Economic Affairs Committee recommended that the UK Government commit to making permanent the £1,040 per year increase to the standard allowance, which is set to end in spring 2021. Furthermore, the committee said:
“The Government should ensure that those on legacy benefits receive an uplift comparable to that of Universal Credit.”
It is worth noting that there is widespread public support for making the uplift permanent. New polling from the Health Foundation and Ipsos MORI shows that the move is supported by 59 per cent of the public, whereas only 20 per cent oppose it. That builds on the strong public support for the uplift as part of the response to the pandemic, which 74 per cent of people supported.
The £20 per week increase to universal credit, introduced in response to the coronavirus pandemic, has been hailed as a lifeline by a coalition of more than 50 organisations and charities, including the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, Shelter, Oxfam, MacMillan Cancer Support and Barnardo’s, which have all urged the chancellor to make the increase permanent.
The increase is a lifeline to more than 470,000 people in Scotland, which includes 5,379 people in Clackmannanshire and 6,850 people in Stirling who are currently claiming universal credit. There has been a staggering 80 per cent increase in the number of claimants since March.
When the increase was announced, the Chancellor of the Exchequer said that he wanted to “strengthen the safety net”. To withdraw it in March 2021, when, it can be argued, the economic impact of the pandemic will be hitting many people hard, would be a cruel and terrible thing that would inflict suffering on the number of people that we have talked about—according to the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, the number is around 16 million across the UK. Those people are all from households who are struggling to keep their heads above water in these difficult times.
New modelling from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation shows that 6.2 million families will see an overnight loss of £1,040 next year, and around half a million more people, including 200,000 children, will be pulled into poverty. That will happen at a time when UNICEF has launched a domestic emergency response in the UK for the first time in its more than 70-year history, to help feed children hit by the Covid-19 crisis. It is clear that now is the time to strengthen the welfare safety net and not to weaken it.
Despite repeated calls to expand the £20 weekly increase, it remains unavailable to claimants of legacy benefits, which has in effect created a two-tier social security system that is affecting around 2 million people. Of course, those on legacy benefits are often carers, disabled or suffering from ill health. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s recent report “The financial impact of COVID-19 on disabled people and their carers” is a sobering reminder of the additional costs that disabled people face. For example, of the people who said in September 2020 that their finances had been affected by the pandemic, 24.6 per cent of disabled people reported having less money available to spend on food, compared to 12.2 per cent of non-disabled people.
In May, the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Thérèse Coffey, told MPs that
“it is far more straightforward and ... quick”
to implement the uplift for universal credit and tax credit claimants, because those systems are digital. She claimed:
“It would take quite some time to change the legacy benefits system—I am talking about several months—with the process we have.”—[Official Report, House of Commons, 4 May 2020; Vol 675, c 425.]
It has now been nine months, and in Scotland we have seen our local authorities adapt and develop their systems within weeks to pay millions of pounds in new and additional grants and support. There is no reasonable excuse for the Government not to extend the additional £20 payment to those on legacy benefits. It should do so immediately, and it should backdate those payments. It is unthinkable not to cast the strengthened safety net to cover that group too.
In times of crisis, it is the job of Government to support and protect those who need it. Throughout the pandemic, millions of people have found themselves caught up in its economic fall-out, which will last way beyond March next year. In fact, I would go as far as to say that those of us who can remember the 1980s will recognise that the uplift is a real investment. For a large number of people, the effect of this relatively small increase will be paid back many times if we can avoid repeating the problem of too many people experiencing the excruciating poverty that was a legacy of the 1980s.
Evidence tells us that increasing the income of people on low incomes stimulates spending in the economy, as they spend it on household necessities and bills and are far less likely to have the ability to save than those on higher incomes. They will buy food, pay rent and pay for their energy costs; they will not buy a yacht in the Caribbean. All that helps the economy: it goes straight back into the economy. The uplift provides a double boost. It enables families to keep their heads above water, and it puts money into the economy at the time when it is needed most.
The Tories have spent 10 years systematically and brutally dismantling the safety net of the welfare system, with their austerity agenda. It is time for them to start rebuilding that safety net, so that it can help people when they need it, now and in future. We can start by making the universal credit increase permanent and extending it to legacy benefits.
19:45