The question whether and how additional days of polling should be arranged is difficult and that is reflected in the amendments that have been lodged. As with most aspects of the bill, many complex questions arise as to how we ensure the smooth running of the election, whatever the conditions on polling day.
As the committee heard at stage 1, those who run elections need to know the date of the poll well in advance, so that they can plan and issue clear communications; crucially, that allows them to book venues and recruit staff. A late decision to switch to multiple days of polling could appear an understandable reaction to a sudden surge in the virus, but it would be expensive and, worse, confusing for voters.
It seems likely that physical distancing will still be a feature of our lives in May. That could mean that it will take longer to cast each vote, which could result in small queues at polling stations, although postal vote uptake would alleviate that. Therefore, at face value, there is something to be said for the approach of Mr Sarwar’s amendment 24 in committing today to a second day of polling.
However, throughout the process, we have worked closely with our electoral community. In my stage 1 evidence, I indicated that I had asked Malcolm Burr, the convener of the Electoral Management Board for Scotland, to consider in detail the question of multiple days of polling. He delivered his assessment last week, concluding that only one day should be required. Mr Burr’s advice is careful and considered and reflects experience and analysis of, and reflection on, the by-elections held this autumn. It also takes account of the vast experience of returning officers in running Scottish Parliament elections and their plans for the number of polling stations in May 2021. In parallel with the legislative process, considerable work is being done at a local level on the practical challenges and the measures that will be in play for the election.
We have been balancing our approach between uncertainty about virus conditions and the requirements for planning, and I remain convinced that the flexible approach in the bill is the right one and that opting for rigidity now might result in the need for more legislation in the spring. I hear what Mr Sarwar says about the probing nature of his amendment and that he is looking to promote a discussion about the merits of taking more than one day to stage an election. I am not unsympathetic to that, but I feel that now is not the time to experiment with new approaches to voting and that there are enough uncertainties around elections in the current climate. Between that position and, more importantly, the advice that we have received from electoral professionals, our approach is the right one.
We have the advice of electoral professionals, but I want to retain the flexibility in the bill. We do not know what might happen in the next couple of months, so it is important that we have that power, just in case it is needed. However, I listened to the concerns expressed at stage 1 regarding the breadth of the power of the Scottish ministers to provide for polling over additional days. Amendments 10 and 11 narrow the exercise of that power. Amendment 10 relates to the power of ministers to provide for polling on additional days, and it prevents use of the power without a recommendation by the convener of the Electoral Management Board for Scotland. Again, I stress that it is about listening to electoral professionals and being guided by them, but with the Parliament having the final say.
The effect is that ministers may decide whether to provide for polling to take place on one or more specified days only if polling on those days is recommended to ministers by the convener of the Electoral Management Board for Scotland. The requirement to consult the persons and bodies listed in section 8(5) before laying draft regulations remains as an additional safeguard. That will allow ministers the flexibility to respond swiftly, but only if electoral administrators feel that there is a need.
Amendment 11 adjusts section 8(2), to clarify which days may be specified as additional polling days. In any recommendation made to ministers, the convener of the EMB may specify as additional polling days only those days that are consecutive to the day of the poll, unless they consider that there is reason to depart from that presumption, and, in any event, they may specify only one of the eight days falling immediately after the day of the poll.
Amendments 12 and 14 make the delegated power to provide for polling over multiple days subject to the affirmative procedure, going further than the recommendation of the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee in its stage 1 report. As I made clear to the committee, this is a contingency power, but, on reflection, we agree with the DPLR Committee that, if that power were to be used, its significance is such that parliamentary scrutiny would be appropriate.
Amendment 13 requires ministers to lay before the Parliament a statement of the reasons in support of the change, including information on the responses received from the Presiding Officer, the Electoral Commission, the convener of the EMB and the chief medical officer.
Adam Tomkins’s amendment 15 also seeks to limit the discretion of ministers in this area. As the Government amendments do, it seeks to apply the affirmative procedure. However, it also applies a number of other restrictions along the lines of those that we discussed in relation to group 4 and an all-postal election. As I said then, it seems excessive to grant a power of veto to each of the Presiding Officer, the Electoral Commission and the EMB convener. The Government’s amendments are much more in accord with the committee’s call for enhanced parliamentary scrutiny of a decision to opt for multiple days of polling. They place the initiation of a change to the days of polling in the hands of the convener of the EMB, but they also enhance parliamentary scrutiny of any change. They are to be preferred to amendment 15. That said, I see no difficulty in restricting the use of section 8 to circumstances where the Scottish ministers consider it necessary for reasons relating to the coronavirus. If Mr Tomkins does not press his amendment 15, I propose to prepare a stage 3 amendment on that point along the lines of Mr Findlay’s amendment 22, which we discussed earlier.
10:45
To avoid any doubt, I repeat that, at present, neither I nor the electoral administrators expect the use of the power to be necessary, but the bill is designed for worst-case scenarios. Consequently, I contend that, in those circumstances, further restriction beyond that set out in the Government amendments is not needed and nor should we commit to a second polling day at this time.
I therefore invite Mr Sarwar and Mr Tomkins not to press their amendments in the group; if they do so, I invite the committee not to support them. I ask the committee to support the amendments in the group in my name.