I thank the members who have supported the motion and helped to bring the debate to the chamber. Saying “save our hospital” is one of those perennial but powerful tools in the political toolkit that strikes at the heart of communities as an emotive subject, because hospitals are places of worry, sorrow and joy, illness and recovery, and life and death—things that are the essence of politics and public policy.
I accept that change is sometimes difficult to accept, understand or even communicate. Patient safety is, of course, paramount, but it should not be used as a smokescreen to make unpopular changes that are the by-product of systemic problems of resource, finance or governance.
There is nobody in Inverclyde, Renfrewshire, North Ayrshire or Argyll who does not have an Inverclyde royal hospital story to share. It is a truly ominous building, and it has sat at the heart of our community since the year before I was born.
I was a youth volunteer at the hospital radio station in my teens. I had a weekly show there, the highlight of which was a Christmas Day request show. I am not sure that we had many listeners, but I recall that, one year, the phone rang in the studio—I nearly fell off my chair.
It seems serendipitous that, one day, that same hospital would serve as a place of care and love for many of my friends and family. Some of them walked proudly back out of its front door, others, sadly, did not. I have spent many a night in the intensive care unit family room, sleeping on its uncomfortable floor, with kind nurses bringing me cups of sugary tea. We do not always remember the names of folk in those situations, but we never forget their faces.
The strength of feeling locally to protect the intensive care unit in the interests of all patients who need it, for as long as they need it, is not just palpable but entirely justified. On 1 October this year, shocked staff were told that level 3 ICU patients would be moved to Glasgow. That type of care had been under threat for much longer than that, because, in December last year, the Government confirmed in writing that its two funded level 3 care beds were already at risk, and said that challenges and risks existed that might impact the unit’s on-going sustainability. Guess what those challenges and risks were. It will come as no surprise to members that they involved workplace issues and skills shortages. That was a year ago. It is there in black and white.
Following that, Covid came along, and temporary changes were made to patient pathways. People get that—I get that. Inverclyde was hit hard by Covid, with the death rate twice the national average. People understand the need for temporary changes in response to a temporary health emergency. However, what they do not appreciate is that fact being used as a cover to make permanent changes. The rumours were not just rumours. Before the very eyes of staff, patients were being stabilised in Inverclyde and moved to Glasgow.
In response to reports of those substantive changes, the Greenock Telegraph launched an online petition, which has received more than 11,000 signatures. Protecting the ICU in Inverclyde has united Inverclyde. It has brought together residents, staff and politicians of all political colours. Local businesses have got on board, too—McGill’s Buses printed the campaign message on the back of its bus tickets.
Political parties also condemned the move. One local Scottish National Party councillor said:
“It is a disgraceful decision in the midst of a global pandemic.”
I do not disagree. Another councillor said:
“Local people need to speak loudly by sending a clear message to our political leaders in Holyrood.”
Normally, those local people would be in the gallery behind us, but I know that they are watching online, so I will address them directly: you have spoken loudly, and I hope that your message is crystal clear to our political leaders today.
Of course, the national health service board responded quickly, saying that the ICU is not closing. However, it admitted that level 3 patients are indeed being transferred to the Queen Elizabeth hospital in Glasgow. That mantra was repeated by the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport, and we might hear it again today. A change has been made under the proviso of Covid, with no guarantee of reversion to pre-pandemic pathways. That is the guarantee that we seek today.
We know that the NHS is operating in unusual times. Until March 2021, at least, it will be operating under a state of emergency. However, presumably, that means that, post-Covid, we can expect pre-Covid conditions of care.
Inverclyde ICU has proven its value. It currently admits around 1,450 patients a year, but this new pathway will move at least 100 of those patients to Glasgow. That is not just a number; it represents 100 people and 100 families who are already in despair and are in their darkest moments but who will have the added stress of worrying about how to make that journey from Greenock to Glasgow, often twice daily. As I know far too well, that is a long distance when things go wrong in the middle of the night.
It is simply disingenuous to claim that there is nothing to see here, that nothing has changed and that this situation is just a case of poor communication. It is not. The fact remains that, historically, level 3 care patients were not just stabilised in Greenock, but were treated there, too. It remains a fact that patients who required intrusive ventilation were given that there and that people received multidisciplinary support there. I know that because, like thousands of others, I have seen it with my own eyes.
We have been offered a jargon-filled briefing in defence of the change. The beds are there and the staff are there, so the ICU must still be there. That is fine but, if that is so, why are patients being put into ambulances and transferred to Glasgow when, this time last year, they were not? If that does not constitute a major change, what does? It cannot be an ICU by name alone.
If the issue is resource, that is a legacy for which this Government must take responsibility. There are gaps in consultancy, anaesthetics and middle-grade nurses, and the use of locums is rocketing. The unit has been chronically underresourced for years, and services have been chipped away: the ear, nose and throat unit, the out-of-hours general practitioner service, the orthopaedic unit, the physical disability rehabilitation unit, the maternity unit—the list goes on and on. Those are not “perceived” threats—they are actual threats.
In closing, here are some questions for the Government and the health board, on behalf of the people back in Inverclyde. In the middle of the pandemic, why on earth are we reducing, rather than beefing up, ICU care in our local hospital? Why has Inverclyde been put into restrictions because of fears about ICU bed capacity in Glasgow, when we have a hospital right on our doorstep? Why are there no guarantees that the temporary changes are indeed temporary? What is the long-term plan and vision for the hospital over the next five or 10 years? How can we have confidence that the hospital will lie at the heart of providing cradle-to-grave healthcare for the people whom it serves?
It is time to end the obfuscation. We should give the hospital what it needs, give the staff the reassurances that they deserve and give the people of Inverclyde some respect by providing some much-needed honesty in the debate, because they all deserve nothing less.
18:11