Emissions trading is a devolved function—what is in effect covered by the ETS is devolved. A carbon emissions tax would be Treasury led, which would immediately remove from us any real engagement in that regard.
What is being proposed, on the face of it, is a reserved carbon emissions tax as a fall-back to a UK ETS in the event that an agreement to link to the European Union ETS is not reached. Committee members will know how incredibly technical this whole area is.
A Treasury consultation on a carbon emissions tax has been going on and will finish at the end of September. We are in the middle of a consultation on a carbon emissions tax at the same time as we are developing a UK ETS.
I have to say that, at UK Government level, there has been resistance to clarifying the Government’s preference for either a stand-alone UK ETS or a carbon emissions tax. Two Whitehall departments are involved: the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy is responsible for climate change policy and, therefore, ETS; Her Majesty’s Treasury is also involved.
As recently as 4 August, I wrote to the Treasury to repeat my strong objection to a tax, on the basis that all accountability to the Scottish Parliament would be lost. Frankly, that would contravene the higher-level principles that were agreed at the joint ministerial committee that Mike Russell attends and is involved in.
A number of things are going on. The Government and officials have spent a vast about of time working on the proposal. We spent quite a bit of the previous session talking about common frameworks, and what we are discussing is one of the very important ones. Members need to be aware that, at the last minute, that work could, in effect, be put at naught by a decision to have the Treasury step in and impose a carbon emissions tax. All the work that we have done, all the negotiation that has taken place backwards and forwards, all the meetings and so on will have been put at nothing.
At the moment, the UK Government is running almost a twin-track approach. On the one hand, one department is processing the common framework but, on the other hand, the Treasury is consulting on and proposing something that runs absolutely counter to that framework. All that I can do in that position is to do my job in respect of Scottish interests, in good faith, with the Whitehall department that is processing the development of the policy. However, I know that, running counter to that, there is an entirely different approach. That is discourteous, and we have been put in an invidious position.
Let us not forget that it is not just about my time or the officials’ time; it is also about the amount of time that the Parliament, through the committee, has spent looking at the issue. I would be curious to know whether the committee has had any contact from the Treasury about its proposal for a carbon emissions tax—I bet that it has not.