Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Health Protection (Coronavirus) (Restrictions) (Scotland) Amendment (No 10) Regulations 2020 (SSI 2020/236)

Thursday 20 August 2020 COVID-19 Committee About 10:45–11:15 Subordinate legislation 29 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

29 contributions
Murdo Fraser Con The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

For our second evidence session today we are joined by Michael Russell, Cabinet Secretary for the Constitution, Europe and External Affairs, who will give evidence on two sets of amending regulations that amend the Health Protection (Coronavirus) (Restrictions) (Scotland) Regulations 2020. Mr Russell is accompanied by two Scottish Government officials: Luke McBratney, the lead for transition, constitution and rights; and Rebecca Whyte, the Health Protection (Coronavirus) (Restrictions) (Scotland) Regulations co-ordinator. I invite the cabinet secretary to make a short opening statement.

Michael Russell SNP The Cabinet Secretary for the Constitution, Europe and External Affairs · Argyll and Bute
link

Thank you for the invitation to appear before the committee today—I think it is the eighth occasion on which I have come before this committee. Today, I want to discuss two further sets of amending regulations that amend the Health Protection (Coronavirus) (Restrictions) (Scotland) Regulations 2020, more commonly known as the lockdown regulations.

On 30 July, the Scottish Government gave an indication of the order in which we would carefully and gradually seek to implement further changes in phase 3 of the route map. The First Minister announced the outcome of the sixth review of the restrictions and requirements set out in the principal regulations on 30 July. The outcome of that review and the assessment of the evidence was that it was not yet appropriate to move to phase 4 of the route map in easing lockdown. A further review is taking place today, and the First Minister has already expressed caution about how we will proceed, based on the most recent data. She will of course say more about that in Parliament in the next hour or so.

The amending regulations that we are discussing today give effect to aspects of phase 3 of easing lockdown. They also strengthen the rules and mitigations that we have in place to keep the virus under control. The Scottish Government made amending regulations by way of the made affirmative procedure on 31 July and 7 August. Those regulations entered into force on various different dates and the plenary vote will take place in due course.

11:00

The amending regulations make a number of adjustments to the principal regulations: they adjust areas where the decision to implement further aspects of phase 3 necessitates a change to the restrictions on businesses and individuals. The regulations have allowed community centres to reopen and they remove the legal requirement on schools to maintain social distancing. The regulations also make provision for additional measures that are necessary to limit the spread of the virus. That includes extending the locations in which a face covering must be worn and giving the Scottish ministers a power to issue guidance on measures that should be taken in order to minimise the risk of the incidence and spread of the virus.

As set out in the updated route map, there are some proposed changes to phase 3 for which we have not set or confirmed a date when they will come into force. Our expectation from the start of phase 3 was that this phase might last considerably more than three weeks. We are already in week 6 of phase 3. It is not yet clear when we will be able to step forward to phase 4. We are keeping that under regular review.

The next review date for the regulations is today and a further review is planned for 10 September. As I said, the First Minister will provide an update later today and set out the findings of today’s review. I am sure that the committee will understand, frustrating though it may be, that it would not be appropriate for me to pre-empt anything that the First Minister might announce later today during the plenary meeting.

I hope that those comments are helpful to the committee. I am happy to take questions.

Murdo Fraser Con The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you, cabinet secretary. I remind you, as ever, that when answering questions you should take a breath before you start speaking. If you wish to bring in your officials at any point please indicate that and give us their names, to allow our broadcasting colleagues to turn on microphones at the appropriate point.

I will start with a question on face coverings. At a previous committee meeting, Graham Simpson raised concerns about the number 7 regulations. He stated that, at that time, it was unclear where face masks were required or not required to be worn, particularly in relation to shops that contain a post office or facilities that involve money transfers. I know that the number 10 regulations amend the principal regulations that apply to retail environments with the effect that face coverings are now mandatory in a wider range of public spaces, including places of worship, crematoriums, community centres, post offices, takeaways, banks and other financial institutions. Can you say whether you are expecting any further amendments on the wearing of face coverings?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

There are no such amendments at the present time. Mr Simpson raised several points that have been clarified by these regulations. I will ask Rebecca Whyte to talk specifically about banks and post offices. You are right, convener, that the regulations define quite clearly where face coverings should be worn. That includes a whole range of places that Mr Simpson might not have thought of, such as aquariums, indoor zoos and visitor farms. The list also includes banks, building societies and credit unions.

There was an issue because there was a difference between the regulations north and south of the border. Rebecca Whyte can say a word or two about banks and post offices to indicate the detail that we have to go into and the process of negotiation with stakeholders that is involved in such matters.

Rebecca Whyte Scottish Government
link

On the issues that Mr Simpson raised at the last meeting, after that meeting Mr Russell wrote to Mr Simpson setting out more detail about the position at that point and explaining that we were looking at whether changes to that position would be appropriate. To give a little bit more background, when the restrictions on shops were initially developed, our policy colleagues engaged with the financial services sector around the possibility of face coverings in those settings and there were some concerns about the practicality of such measures in relation to security issues and identifying people who come into banks. Subsequently, the UK Government made its own regulations and it concluded that the balance of evidence was such that face coverings should be worn in banks and financial services settings.

Given that many of the businesses in that category operate both north and south of the border, that created some new evidence to consider in relation to the balance of restrictions, so our policy colleagues engaged with the sector again and concluded that the evidence that was emerging about the operation of the policy in other areas meant that it would be appropriate to make the change to regulations that we are introducing, which makes face coverings mandatory in financial settings.

I hope that that gives you a little more detail about the background to the amendments to the regulations and explains the engagement with the sector and our learning from the experiences as the policy on face coverings is operationalised in different areas, which has helped to clarify where the balance of different factors indicates that face coverings should be worn.

Murdo Fraser Con The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I see that Ross Greer wants to ask a supplementary, but I have one more question before I bring him in. I have had representations from constituents and those who work in the retail sector to say that they prefer wearing face visors rather than face coverings. Can you clarify what the regulations state about what a face covering needs to be?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Interestingly, there is now a very clear view on that. The regulations require that someone who wears a visor should also wear a face mask. SAGE—the scientific advisory group for emergencies—discussed that on 23 July, and it also discussed the role of visors in the context of the role of aerosol transmission, which is the issue. The group concluded that visors alone offer inadequate protection, in particular for staff in close-working sectors such as hairdressing, and advised that the guidance should be updated to include the wearing of face coverings.

I will quote Jason Leitch on the matter, because he made the point publicly. He said:

“The scientific advice is that face shields do not provide adequate protection against small viral droplets ... which can escape from the bottom of a face shield and land on surfaces or stay in the air for periods of time. They can provide some protection for the wearer against large droplet exposure including, for example, splashing in a health care setting. But they are unlikely to provide any protection for the wearer against small aerosols. You can wear a face shield if you choose to, however you must wear a face covering underneath.”

Murdo Fraser Con The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you—that clarification is helpful. I will bring in Ross Greer.

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

Staying on that specific point, folk who work in retail environments and employers of retail staff have raised questions with me about needing exact clarity around the requirements to wear a face covering in those settings.

Proposed new regulation 6B(3) clarifies the exemptions from the requirement to wear a face covering. From my reading of subparagraph (d), staff are exempt as long as they are not within 2m of other individuals. Does that essentially mean that staff who are moving around the shop floor are not required to wear a face covering as long as they are not within 2m of customers or another member of staff for any long period of time?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I suggest that Rebecca Whyte addresses that question. Ross Greer raises a very good point, which is raised regularly by people who see shop staff not wearing face coverings. We need to be very clear about it.

Rebecca Whyte Scottish Government
link

That provision sets out some situations in which an employee, a volunteer or another person who is effectively working in the setting does not have to wear a face covering. Mr Greer is right that the exemption applies if a distance of 2m is maintained between the person and members of the public; the requirement to maintain distance does not apply in respect of other employees, so a face covering would not have to be worn in that case.

There are additional circumstances that mean that an employee would not have to wear a face covering. For example, where there is a partition or screen between the employee and members of the public, the employee is exempt from wearing a face covering. In settings where staff members are exempt, the guidance suggests that if they feel that they would like to wear a face covering or that it would be appropriate to do so, they are not prevented from doing so; it is just that they are legally exempt from having to do so.

Murdo Fraser Con The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Does Ross Greer want to come back in?

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

Yes, thanks. I just needed the microphone turned back on.

That was very useful, Rebecca, and thank you. Just to clarify this situation by comparing it to the one in schools, the guidance that has been provided for school staff is relatively clear in that staff are strongly encouraged to wear a face covering if they are within 2m of pupils for more than 15 minutes, so a length of time is set out there. Obviously, in most retail settings, staff members are unlikely to be with a single customer for more than 15 minutes or a prolonged period of time. However, is there any comparable specific guidance for retail? Obviously, a lot of staff in retail will move around the shop floor regularly and could, in the space of a minute, come within 2m of multiple customers but only for a split second each time. I am getting questions on those aspects from folk who work in retail, because they are not quite sure exactly what they are being told to do. Broadly, they think that they are being told that they do not have to wear a face covering, but they see that there is specific guidance, though not regulation, for teachers that sets out that time limit in relation to the 2m distance. Is there anything comparable for retail staff?

Rebecca Whyte Scottish Government
link

Yes, there is specific retail guidance that picks up a number of issues in the regulations in more detail. If it would be okay with you, I can take your question away, look for the specific bit of the regulations that covers that issue and prepare a written response.

Clare Adamson SNP The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Thank you. Ross, if you have another question on a different topic, just ask it now, please.

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

Grand. My question is broadly in the same area and covers somewhat the convener’s question on face shields and Mr Russell’s answer to it. The quality impact assessment notes that face shields are excluded from the definition of face coverings for the sensible reason, as outlined by the cabinet secretary, that they do not provide equivalent protection. However, concerns have been raised around accessibility and ability to communicate because of the lack of availability of clear face coverings for the mouth and nose. The National Deaf Children’s Society has been calling for people to wear clear face masks to facilitate communication. Has the Government given consideration to advocating the use of clear face masks in settings where people are interacting, such as retail and education settings? Further, has the Government given consideration to supplying clear face masks in, for example, education settings, so that those who work in front-line public services are able to communicate with people who have communication barriers?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I am happy to consider that and respond to the committee on it. I do not think that there has been consideration of whether clear face masks should be supplied, but I acknowledge the point about them. Ross Greer will know that, in the guidance and discussions for education, there has been consideration of the impact of face coverings for learners with additional support needs, for those with any level of hearing loss and for learners acquiring English who rely on visual clues. All those matters are in the education sphere and have been carefully considered.

I have constituents with severe hearing problems and communication problems who have asked for exemptions to be applied on wearing face masks, and there are exemptions for communication purposes. However, it is worth considering again whether a suitable compromise can be found through using transparent face masks—I have seen some with simply a transparent area. I undertake to write to the member and committee on that.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. I want to pick up on the number 9 regulations about school education settings and the wearing of face coverings. I represent the Central Scotland region, where we have had a number of cases in Lanarkshire recently involving school-age pupils confirmed to have Covid, some of whom had been back in the school environment and some of whom had not, which has raised concerns. However, the guidance has a lot of weak language, with schools being told that, if they wish to encourage pupils to wear face coverings, they can do so, and that, if concerns grow about the prevalence of the virus, wearing face coverings can again be encouraged. However, I have had feedback locally, as have colleagues in their regions and constituencies, about young people feeling that they do not want to be the only one in the class or school who is wearing a face covering.

11:15

Sadly, I read in the media this week that a constituent of mine in Hamilton had been bullied online, and his mum went to the papers anonymously to tell that story. We have all been young—we know what it is like to want to fit in and do what looks like the popular thing. Right now, in the school environment, it does not look like wearing face coverings is popular or mainstream. Does the cabinet secretary also feel nervous about the current guidelines? Rather than wait until we see more prevalence, should we be doing more to mainstream and normalise the wearing of face coverings in the school environment?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

As we have done with face coverings in general, we have to look at that issue in the light of the developing science and views. That happened with face coverings and I think that it is happening here. However, the guidance is clear, and there are schools that correctly take the view that, should the prevalence of the virus increase in any part of Scotland—in Ms Lennon’s and other areas, there has been evidence of an increase—schools might wish to encourage the wearing of face coverings among adults and older young people in particular. “Might” is permissive but I suspect that wise schools will wish to encourage it. To pick a school out, Bannerman high school is taking that approach, which is in line with existing guidance. In addition, as the Deputy First Minister said earlier in the week, we are keeping the issue of face coverings under close review. The advisory subgroup, which met on Tuesday, is drawing on advice and feedback from all the partners, including in schools, to make sure that the advice is right. It will go on doing so and it will also examine the international consensus, to make sure that it understands what is happening elsewhere.

The current guidance is clear that face coverings are not required for most children, but for those who are clinically advised to wear them, it is essential. However, there might be circumstances in which they should be advised—and schools should advise them—to do so.

Mr Greer referred to the distancing issue; there are other issues but, as I mentioned to him, we also have to take account of people who have additional support needs or hearing loss or who are acquiring English. All of that has to be carefully considered, so it is not a simple matter. The member would probably criticise the Scottish Government if we were too didactic in our approach; with regard to the criticism that we are not being strong enough, I accept that we have to strike a balance between the two. We are trying to do so, but we should also make it clear to any child that, if they or their parent think that they should wear a face mask, they should do so. That is also true of any adult in a school. Not only can they not be stopped, they should be happy to discuss that and why they want to do so.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

In the interests of time, I have no further questions.

Beatrice Wishart LD Shetland Islands
link

My question follows the discussion of face coverings in schools. Does it not make sense to have face coverings on school transport? I know that that is being reviewed on an on-going basis but, after a week of schools returning, is there a conclusion ?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

No. Obviously, as soon as there is a conclusion, members will be informed of it. I make the same point to Beatrice Wishart that I have just made to Monica Lennon: if people want to wear masks, if they think that it is right to wear them or if they feel safer wearing them, they should wear them. There is no doubt about that.

Adam Tomkins Con Glasgow
link

My question is not about face coverings or masks, nor is it my usual question at the moment about gyms, although I still have not had what I regard as a satisfactory answer about that.

I will ask a question about outdoor exercise. Could the cabinet secretary or his officials explain to me what exactly the rules are at the moment in relation to outdoor exercise, in particular outdoor group exercise? As I understand it—I am not sure whether this is Government advice or industry advice—outdoor exercise in the form of boot camps and classes and so on is limited to a maximum of four households at any one time, but training for group or team sports does not appear to be limited to four households at any one time. Have I understood that correctly? If I have understood that correctly, is that Government advice or is it industry advice, and can the rationale behind it be explained? How can it be okay for group exercise to be in larger numbers when it is for team sports but be confined to a very small number of households at any one time when it comes to training camps, boot camps and the sorts of exercise that people want to do while gyms continue to be closed?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I will ask either Rebecca Whyte or—I am sorry, my mind has briefly disappeared—Luke McBratney to answer those questions. Luke will not forgive me for having forgotten his name, so I apologise to him. One of them should answer the question in the detail that Mr Tomkins wishes.

Murdo Fraser Con The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Just to help broadcasting, can someone put their hand up and volunteer? That would be very helpful. Rebecca will answer—Luke is obviously in the huff, cabinet secretary.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I really feel that I had a momentary brain fade—I am sorry.

Rebecca Whyte Scottish Government
link

In answer to Mr Tomkins’s question, the Scottish Government’s phase 3 staying safe and protecting others guidance sets out guidance for those who are undertaking outdoor personal training and for sports facilities. That sets out that there should be a maximum of four other households apart from the personal trainer or leader of the group doing the outdoor activity. That is based on the regulations and personal training gatherings come under gatherings for leisure purposes. Regulation 6A sets a limit of no more than five households that are not otherwise specified in that list and are outdoors. Mr Tomkins may wish to note that there is a separate gatherings provision for supervised outdoor recreation for people under 18 that covers team sports where the participants are under 18. As far as I understand it, individual sports associations are issuing their own guidance that sets out specific measures—for example, there is particular guidance about how cricket balls must be dealt with. As far as I understand it, those pieces of guidance from particular associations must set out that the household limit should be met, so there should not be a discrepancy on that front.

Murdo Fraser Con The Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I do not see any other members wanting to come in, so we will move on to item 5. Are members content that motions S5M-22426 and S5M-22421 are moved en bloc? I do not see any objection to that.

Motions moved,

That the COVID-19 Committee recommends that the Health Protection (Coronavirus) (Restrictions) (Scotland) Amendment (No 9) Regulations 2020 SSI2020/232 be approved.

That the COVID-19 Committee recommends that the Health Protection (Coronavirus) (Restrictions) (Scotland) Amendment (No 10) Regulations 2020 SSI 2020/236 be approved.—Michael Russell

Motions agreed to.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on these motions that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 4
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 54
  3. 10:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  4. 10:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 29
  5. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.