To look at the issue from the point of view of incentivisation is to look at it from the wrong side; we must look at it from the point of view of the client. Unless someone has a lot of money, they will not be able to raise a personal injury action.
At present, the insurance industry has told us that if you suffer a catastrophic personal injury, you will have no difficulty in finding a solicitor or a claims management company to take that claim forward because there will be a big damages payment and therefore the provider of the relevant services will get a big fee. At the other end of the scale, if someone is eligible for legal aid, they will be able to finance their personal injury claim through legal aid, although legal aid financing of such claims now is very rare.
The vast majority of personal injury claims are now being financed by success fee agreements—damages-based agreements. It is about what Sheriff Principal Taylor called the “excluded middle”—people who are not eligible for legal aid, who may not be able to raise an action. They need to have some other means of financing that action, and that is what the success fee agreement provides.
Sheriff Principal Taylor spent two and a half years coming up with the success fee caps and his view is that they represent a fully considered compromise. He had a policy advisory group to advise him, with representatives from the insurance industry, insurance lawyers and pursuer personal injury solicitors. The caps that they came up with are a fully considered compromise; they think that they are fair to everyone. It is intended that not only will the client get the vast majority of the damages that are claimed but the solicitor will get a reasonable return on the risk that they are taking.
You might be interested to know that one firm of solicitors told us that when it was raising a catastrophic personal injury case on behalf of a client, its outlay on the case was £175,000. In order to be able to exercise a person’s legal rights, the solicitor has to get a reasonable return on their outlay.
It is rare—in any jurisdiction in the world—for a pursuer to get 100 per cent of their damages, because they have to pay for their legal advice. Even though you will get your damages from the other side, according to the law, you still have to pay your lawyer. Therefore, you will not get 100 per cent of what you were awarded or what was agreed on in a settlement.