I thank every member who signed the motion and those who will speak in the debate. I also thank Laura Jones of RNIB Scotland for her excellent work in producing the report, “Communication Failure? Review of the accessibility of health information for blind and partially sighted people in Scotland”. For the purposes of the debate, I will refer to it as “the report”. Some members of RNIB Scotland are in the gallery this evening: I am glad that they are here.
I have convened the cross-party group on visual impairment since my re-election in 2011. The cross-party group has discussed a wide variety of issues and has written to the Scottish and United Kingdom Governments, as well as to local authorities and, previously, to European parliamentarians. Our cross-party group has never been shy about attempting to find a solution to an issue or about thanking public bodies for their progress. For example, we recently wrote to the City of Edinburgh Council to thank it for banning A-boards from the streets of our capital. Any activity that the cross-party group has undertaken has been about making Scotland more accessible and fairer for people who are blind or partially sighted.
On 17 February, RNIB Scotland hosted an event in Glasgow on publication of its report. The room was full, and contained people who are blind or partially sighted and it contained health professionals. During my contribution that day, I said that I would seek to obtain a members’ business debate, because the issue needs first to be acknowledged and then to be addressed. I will provide a few suggestions that would help, because that is the correct manner in which to take further the findings of the excellent report
First, I will touch on some of the report’s findings. The report is the second such report that RNIB Scotland has published on the subject. In 2010, it produced the report, “Accessibility of health information for blind and partially sighted people”, which found a lack of recognition within the health service of the specific additional needs of blind and partially sighted people. The report showed that blind and partially sighted people did not experience the same patient confidentiality as sighted people experienced, because they were often forced to rely on others to give details of appointments, diagnoses and patient advice.
The Patient Rights (Scotland) Act 2011 and its accompanying “Your health, your rights: The Charter of Patient Rights and Responsibilities” set out that people
“can expect to be given information about your care and treatment in a format or language that meets your needs”.
Therefore, the new report, which has been published a decade later, should have shown major improvements.
RNIB Scotland’s report highlights four key findings and seven key recommendations. The first key finding is that patient confidentiality is being breached; the second is that
“Individuals are being put at risk”;
the third is that
“Some individuals were told that they could cope without an accessible format”
of their information; and the fourth is that some people
“did not feel ‘worthy enough’ to make requests and/or complain to their health service.”
I am sure that every one of us in the chamber will be disappointed by those findings and would like to thank the people who took part in the research.
The helpful briefing from Royal Blind has provided the following quotation:
“People with sight loss who access our services have complained about receiving self-testing kits (e.g. for bowel cancer) that are not visual impairment-friendly. This breaches patient confidentiality, as individuals must rely on carers or relatives to assist them with tests that should be taken in private.”
The briefing goes on to say that
“We have had feedback that private companies—such as telecommunication companies or utilities providers—are often better at accessible formatting by default than healthcare providers.”
Clearly, no matter how we look at the situation, every patient is of equal value and every patient not only deserves but should expect information to be available to them.
I welcome the report’s recommendations, and acknowledge that some of them are being delivered in part. Although that is welcome, it proves that there is still more to do, and that all health boards need to up their game. A more consistent approach across all health boards would be extremely useful.
I return to suggestions, as I said I would. I am aware that the report has been sent to every health board. I personally handed over copies—including CD and Braille versions—to NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde on the afternoon of the report’s publication.
I congratulate the health boards that engaged with the research for the report. However, I am disappointed that five did not. That might well have been an oversight; nonetheless, blind and partially sighted patients deserve better.
My first suggestion is to encourage health boards to engage with RNIB Scotland—even at this stage—to inform them of how they communicate with blind and partially sighted patients.
Secondly, I consider that a short-term working group including the NHS and the wider patient health communication sector would be advantageous. I am sure that that would provide an opportunity for the health boards to understand fully the challenges that blind and partially sighted patients face. The group need not have a cast of thousands, but it should be focused and have key staff involved. It could include health boards that did not engage and boards that did.
Thirdly, it might be worth NHS boards considering contracting in communication services from any one or some of the organisations that can provide information in Braille. A number of organisations can do that. The work could even be undertaken on a trial basis to determine how effective—or otherwise—it is.
Ultimately, every patient wants to obtain correct and proper information in a timely fashion. Obtaining little or no information is unacceptable in this day and age.
Younger blind and partially sighted people are increasingly using smart phones because accessible technology is in-built. However, for some older people, Braille would be the first form of communication that they would use. The population as a whole growing older, and the blind and partially sighted community will be very much part of that community. There are 170,000 such patients in Scotland who require better information about their healthcare. I am sure that solutions can be found using the range of available technologies—at very little cost—to enable 170,000 people take more accurate decisions about their healthcare.
Once again, I thank everyone who has helped to make the debate possible. I again thank Laura Jones of RNIB Scotland for producing an important report. It clearly highlights that our NHS, although it undertakes lifesaving and world-leading research, and constantly challenges itself as new medicines, technologies and illnesses develop, still needs to address some more fundamental issues.
I hope that all NHS boards read the report, understand the issues, listen to today’s debate, engage with external organisations that might be able to assist, and see this as an opportunity to deliver improved outcomes for Scotland’s 170,000 blind or partially sighted people.
18:03