To ask the Scottish Government how many gender recognition certificates it expects to be issued under its proposed system of self-declaration, and how this compares with the current system. (S5O-03951)
Official Report · Chamber
Gender Recognition Certificates
Portfolio Question Time Social Security and Older People
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP 3
- Joan McAlpine SNP 2
- Alex Cole-Hamilton LD 1
The record
6 contributions
Based on international evidence, we expect around 250 applications per year in Scotland under the proposed new system for obtaining legal gender recognition. The current United Kingdom gender recognition panel does not produce statistics on applicants from Scotland, but we estimate that around 30 people per year who were born or adopted in Scotland obtain legal gender recognition at the moment.
The Government says that its proposals will not diminish the rights of women. However, its own draft equality impact assessment evidences that by citing research from the University of Bristol that criticises single-sex spaces and the exemptions under the Equality Act 2010. It suggests that, for a woman, catching sight of a male body in a changing room should be no more distressing than seeing another woman with a mastectomy.
Does the Government regret citing that research, and does the cabinet secretary agree that the comparison is insulting to breast cancer survivors?
The impact assessment that the member refers to is a draft impact assessment. I would encourage members and members of the public to feed in their responses to the consultation, on both the contents of the draft bill and the draft impact assessment. The research that has been referred to was included because of a reference within the work to show that there is no increased risk of women being attacked in single-sex spaces by trans women. That is why that report was included.
Other parts of the research, specifically the section that the member refers to, are not something that the Government would support—nor do we support any changes to the exemptions in the 2010 act.
link
Does the cabinet secretary agree that international evidence suggests that where a strict custodial sentence has been applied for a false declaration on a gender recognition certificate, that has reduced or eradicated any risk that the system will be misused?
I would agree with Mr Cole-Hamilton’s assertion. There is great and understandable concern among members of the public, particularly women, that there would be an increased risk to women because of the changes to gender recognition that the Government is proposing. That is why, in the consultation on the draft bill, I have specifically outlined that there is no diminution of women’s rights under our proposals and that the exemptions under the 2010 act still stand. There are strict penalties for anyone who abuses the current system, which would be strengthened under our proposed system.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 8 Jan 2020 →- Palliative and End-of-life Care (Research Projections) Members’ business · 20
- Social Security and Older People Questions · 1
- Gender Recognition Certificates Questions · 6
- Women Against State Pension Inequality Campaign Questions · 4
- Carers Allowance (Qualifying Criteria) Questions · 4
- Carers Allowance (Earnings Threshold) Questions · 9
- Child Poverty (North Ayrshire) Questions · 6
- Older People (Loneliness) Questions · 7
- Motability Scheme Questions · 6
- Scottish Child Payment (Backdating Period) Questions · 4
- Finance, Economy and Fair Work Questions · 1
- Digital Growth Fund Questions · 4
- Digital Economy Budget Questions · 7
- United Kingdom and Scottish Budgets (Timing) Questions · 9
- United Kingdom Government Spending Pledges (Barnett Consequentials) Questions · 4
- Block Grant Settlement (Timing) Questions · 8
- Business Rates (Devolution of Powers to Local Government) Questions · 6
- Procurement Policy (Zero-hours Contracts) Questions · 4
- Short-term Lets Statement · 31
- European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill Bill debate · 38
- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
- Women, Peace and Security Members’ business · 10
- Correction Procedure · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.