Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Countryside Ranger Services (National Strategic Framework) (PE1678)

Thursday 26 September 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 10:15–11:30 Petitions 77 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

77 contributions
Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Our next continued petition is PE1678, on a national strategic framework for countryside ranger services, which was lodged by Robert Reid on behalf of the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association.

At our previous consideration of the petition in April 2019, the committee agreed to take oral evidence in a round-table meeting to explore the role of countryside rangers, why the role is important, what the challenges are to sustainability of the ranger service and the possibility of there being a working group to examine issues in detail.

I welcome you all to the committee. We will go around the table with introductions, starting with me. I am the MSP for Caithness, Sutherland and Ross and I am the committee’s convener today.

Martin Gray Historic Environment Scotland
link

I am a ranger and visitor services manager for Historic Environment Scotland.

Jim Downie Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority
link

I am a ranger manager for Loch Lomond and the Trossachs national park.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

I am the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association’s archive specialist. Laughter.

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

I am deputy director of Scottish Natural Heritage.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

I am chair of the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Also at the table are the official reporters and the valuable clerks, who provide the committee with background support. This is a round-table evidence session, so I will very much welcome flowing discussion and exchanges of views. Feel free to engage directly with each other, but do so through the chair, please. If you catch either my eye, or the eye of one of the clerks, we will bring you in when we can. As you have seen, you do not need to press the buttons on your consoles if you wish to speak—our very capable sound engineer will do that for us.

In its submission, Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority said:

“Without a clear understanding and appreciation across the public sector of the value of ranger services, the profession faces a challenging and uncertain future.”

In that light, could we hear an outline of the benefits of the ranger service?

Jim Downie Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority
link

Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority has a large ranger service. We currently have about 22 permanent rangers who are joined by 40 or so seasonal rangers, depending on budgets, across the year. The authority certainly sees the ranger service as being integral to the work that we do. Rangers are passionate about the outdoors and about the environment: we provide environmental protection, and we provide visitors with a warm welcome and information on, assistance with and interpretation of the special qualities of the national park.

We provide outdoor learning opportunities for schools and other visiting groups. That can make a real difference to curriculum work. Many visiting geography students get real first-hand experience of the work that we do to balance the needs of all the different people in the national park, from landowners to recreational visitors. We use things such as the John Muir awards in order to reach harder-to-reach groups and people who might not otherwise visit a national park. Such frameworks help us to bring people in.

We have expertise in access, path maintenance and enforcement. The role of a ranger is wide, which is one of the real benefits of the ranger service. We have officers who are specialists, but the ranger service is able to turn its hand to many different things. Rangers are also out in communities and so provide a point of contact.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I declare an interest, in that a friend of mine is a ranger down near Middlesbrough, in Guisborough.

Jim Downie mentioned the environment: outdoor learning is a big passion of mine. Many of the submissions highlight the important work that rangers do, especially in respect of health and wellbeing, yet ranger numbers are declining. Can you shed a wee bit of light on why that might be?

Jim Downie Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority
link

I was describing rangers’ position within the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority. We are probably slightly different from local authority, charitable organisation or private ranger services. The authority values the ranger service very highly within the organisation, and we resource it accordingly. We point a fair bit of resource at the ranger service to maintain it and ensure that it exists. I am not sure that that is the case across all bodies.

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

There is a range of reasons why ranger numbers are declining. There is inevitable pressure on public bodies’ budgets, which we see across the piece in national agencies such as SNH and local authorities, which obviously have a key role in supporting ranger services.

Another dimension that is probably worth recognising is that ranger services are offered in a multitude of ways. Some local authorities focus on health and wellbeing, for example, so rather than have a traditional dedicated ranger service, they offer health walks, and focus more on specialisms so that they have biodiversity officers or access officers. They do many things that rangers do, but the focus is slightly different.

A range of people offer services that are similar to what rangers do, but there has definitely been evolution towards there being less of what we think of as core ranger services—which we recognise as being really valuable and, in fact, critical in national parks and country parks to which we welcome people—to offer a more bespoke ranger service. It is quite a complex picture.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

You have hit the nail on the head of where we are likely to go with the discussion in terms of stresses and strains on public funding. I do not want to put words in your mouth, but it looks like ranger services are an easy target when it comes to public funding. Public bodies are having to come up with creative ways in which they can deliver services. Where do you sit on that? Are there ways in which you can deliver the service more creatively?

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

There are things that we can do. SNH supports a small number of ranger services—we have been supporting services that we know find it difficult to access other funding. We have been trying to make clear the direction of travel in respect of our funding, so that we give people warning and an indication of where things will be in the coming years.

We have also been trying to ensure that the pain is shared, if you like, so that ranger services can work together to look for alternative sources of funding. That is not easy, as we absolutely acknowledge, but we have been surprised by how creative the ranger services have been.

An interesting current example is the Mull and Iona ranger service, where we currently support two posts but had indicated that the number was likely to go down to one. We have had some follow-up discussions because the service was finding that challenging. It now has a range of funding offers and bids and discussions under way, but the service knows that they will not come through until next year. We have been able to extend our funding for another year to help the service with that transition and to encourage and support its funding efforts.

It is interesting that ranger services are looking to other visitor activities from which streams of donation money come in. Ranger services are also starting to charge for what they provide: that is becoming quite common and is fairly well accepted by the public.

Ranger services are also having discussions with deer management groups, and are asking deer management groups to have discussions with estates. They are considering using bronze, silver or gold levies, or at association. Different models are appropriate in different ways. Our approach has been to try to support that transition.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

I will highlight a funding anomaly that exists within the services. Agencies like Historic Environment Scotland, Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority, and Forestry and Land Scotland get their funding directly from the Government. Local authorities, through block grants and because of their fiscal autonomy, work in a very different landscape.

The SCRA’s survey looked at ranger numbers and job losses over the past 10 years: 50 per cent of job losses were in local authority areas. Local authority funding for rangers was, previously, ring fenced and service delivery was monitored by SNH. All that has gone, and along with it SNH’s ability to maintain a national overview.

There has been, from my point of view, a very disproportionate effect on local authorities and the communities that they serve. That has been an unintended consequence, and it has had serious implications for substantial urban populations, for social inclusion and, as we have mentioned, for the health and wellbeing of vulnerable communities. Therefore, I feel that the current funding model is not fit for purpose and would like it to be reviewed.

10:45

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I know from having been a councillor that local authorities sometimes do not appreciate the Government telling them that money must be ring-fenced for a particular sector. Have you had any conversations with chief executives of local authorities to see whether ring fencing is something that they would welcome?

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

We went down the road of speaking to the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities because there is such variety among councils, as has been described. Chief executives are also not always aware of some of the treasures that they have.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

That is the subject of my next question. Do local authorities understand fully and appreciate the benefits that come from a ranger service?

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

No, although they enjoy the publicity from the good news stories that rangers generate. They are having to make some very tough financial decisions, however.

Ranger numbers are small: we heard about Mull and Iona, where a 50 per cent cut in ranger numbers takes them from two to one. That is reflected across Scotland. Rangers are small in number, so a cut of only one post might be 20 per cent of a team, or a cut of a couple of posts might be half the team, but the workload does not change.

Over the past few years—let us say decades—we have raised customers’ expectations. We have developed sites that rely on staffing presence, so now, when more and more people are visiting the countryside and when the health agenda is rising to the top, we really need to invest in ranger services.

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

I absolutely agree with George Potts that local authorities do not always recognise the value of rangers. Sometimes we do not appreciate something until it is gone, which is unfortunate. Recently, we have had—this has been welcomed and was very much stimulated by the petition and the discussions by the Public Petitions Committee—much more effective engagement with COSLA. It invited us to put a paper to its environment and economy committee, which it welcomed. I think that we have managed to raise the profile of ranger services.

We have also been working with the Scottish Government. A contribution to the block grant was previously SNH’s money to distribute for rangers. We explored that and realised that the money was not categorised in the settlement. I am not sure that I fully understand transfer of money to local authorities, but funding is now labelled as being for biodiversity and rangers, so that it is absolutely clear to local authorities that the money should be directed towards support for access to the countryside. We are hopeful that that will be beneficial.

The other new move that we have made is also on work with the Scottish Government. We had found it difficult to monitor and get good information on ranger services across Scotland. The Scottish Government is required to get information on access provision as part of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003. It does that routinely, so we have agreed that it will include questions about ranger services and provision across the local authority network. We hope that that will allow us to monitor provision then question, or follow up on, where we think changes have been unhelpful.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Eileen, you mentioned that Mull and Iona had considered charging for services. Do you think that charging might become the norm across the sector?

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

I am sure that other people can answer as well. The position is variable, but a number of services charge. We were talking about this just prior to coming in here. There seems to be an increasing recognition among the public that it is appropriate that they should pay. We do not see that charging is leading to any decline in the number of people taking up the services. It would not necessarily be applicable everywhere, particularly when we are trying to encourage people who otherwise would not access the countryside, but it is certainly being looked at increasingly in high-profile locations, and it seems to be working.

Martin Gray Historic Environment Scotland
link

It is obvious that a number of services that were previously either grant funded or funded by their councils or organisations are now being asked to supplement their income. To be blunt, they are being asked to find other ways to sustain their budgets. Having worked in rangering all my life, I am aware that services immediately around us—for example, in East Lothian and, in Edinburgh, the Pentland Hills ranger service, which is just over the back from where we are now—have been looking to car parking charges and charges for events.

Our organisation charges for certain but not all of our events. As Eileen Stuart says, that is to demonstrate parity and allow access to events but also to recognise that some events cost us money and we need to supplement their funding. Some events are more expensive than others to run. This goes back to the funding model that was being talked about as to how ranger services are being augmented, but it also clearly demonstrates the pressures that services are being put under.

Jim Downie Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority
link

That is absolutely right. There are examples of where services are charging and it is working well. Forestry and Land Scotland and the RSPB are charging for guided walks. However, we have to remember that, when it comes to inclusion and the many people who cannot afford to come out and enjoy these places, we have to provide opportunities that are free at the point of sale. It is a balance between those things. There are organisations that are charging for events and services such as guided walks and the public are taking that on board.

Martin Gray Historic Environment Scotland
link

It is important to say that it is about placing value. I will give you a very small example. I manage Holyrood park, where a number of our guided walks are put out to the public. We can have 20 or 30 people phone up to say that they want to come on a guided walk and then only five of them turn up on the day. Putting a levy on the service places a value on what we are delivering to some degree. At the same time, we do not want to discourage people who are less able to afford to do that or less able to get outside. We have to strike a balance.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I will bring the petitioner in now.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

The 32 registered country parks are where the park system for Scotland was born. From those, we moved on to regional parks and then special parks, which are now national parks. The whole point is that a lot of those country parks had to be located in urban areas to make access easy and give people the opportunity to enjoy the countryside. For rangers, people’s enjoyment of the countryside is the ultimate, as well as the other functions that they do. At the end of the day, there are many people I have dealt with in my career who just could not afford to pay because of social problems. Although raising money is important, if they had to pay, a lot of people would be excluded from being involved in rangering and the fundamentals that the cradle of rangering set out in 1972.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

In my area is Loch Lomond and the Trossachs national park, which I know very well; I live in Helensburgh. I agree entirely with the convener. Having been a councillor in Argyll and Bute Council, I do not believe that councillors knew enough about how the national park and the ranger service operated. I would welcome more being done to promote that to the 32 councils, particularly in areas where there are parks. There has always been a little bit of a discussion, shall we say, between the councils and the national park authorities.

One of the issues is planning. In my old area of Argyll and Bute, the national park stretches from the Trossachs practically down to Dunoon and Holy Loch, which is a massive area. There are three councils involved: West Dunbartonshire, Stirling and Argyll and Bute. I think that more needs to be done from that point of view, so I agree with the convener on that point.

SNH has produced an outline of a refreshed “Rangers in Scotland” national statement, which has been circulated to the ranger development partnership members for initial comments. How does the new statement differ from the current one?

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

That is a very good question. What we have tried to do in the new statement that is in development—we are waiting for feedback and we will be exploring it further at the next meeting of the ranger development partnership—is recognise the slightly different context. Ranger services are provided in a range of ways and perhaps not exclusively in the dedicated ranger services that many of us who are rangers have known. We have to recognise that the picture of provision and people’s experience of the outdoors and nature is changing and that their desires and needs are changing. We have tried to reflect that.

We think that ranger services have a core role and value and we need to protect them and secure their future, but we also think that the future approach should be to support skill sharing, development and the professional nature of ranger skills. That has to be at the core, so that we get the same level of provision and the same skills and knowledge across all the different providers. That is very much what we see as the direction of travel and we support the use of branding and logos to recognise that identity and raise the profile. I would not have said that it is radical, but it is about recognising the changing nature of the world and making the most of that new model.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I am happy with that. As I say, it is about getting the message out. It is good to see that you have applied some of the lessons learned in your new statement.

I can give an example of where I find the ranger service very valuable. In my patch is the village of Luss, where we have an enormous problem with tourism—the tourism is great, but the problem is the number of people: 750,000 a year. More than 9 million people go from Balloch up to the top of Loch Lomond on the A82 and so on, so there are some issues coming out on that. We are trying to engage with the rangers. I am looking at the idea of using special constables to help with community policing in the area because, unfortunately, we have an issue that we are needing to address in byelaws and regulations. We have wild camping and guys who are under age getting a box of beer from Morrisons or Asda in Dumbarton or wherever and then drinking it. That is a bit of an issue. Rangers are very important in working with us on that, so it is great to hear what you are going to do.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning, everybody. The petitioner, Bob Reid, has constantly called for the Scottish Government to convene a limited-life independent expert group to review the key issues and propose ways forward for a sustainable delivery of a national ranger service. What are your views on that?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

A national ranger service has been a dream of a lot of people, going back to the conception of the ranger services in Scotland. It happens elsewhere in the world and I think that it would bring advantages. It goes back to the point that local authorities now have to hopefully provide the ranger service by an agreement. My concern is who polices it. Another aspect is that some local authorities do not fulfil their requirements in legislation, not necessarily in countryside but in other areas. That would be my concern. A national ranger service is a model worth looking at. I think that it would be welcome to a lot of rangers, but how do you put that national service into place when a high proportion of ranger employers are local authorities? Do you take them out of it? There is a need to take a good look at that in a review.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Can I draw your attention to the contents of the Glover report, which looks at designated landscapes in England? It was issued just last week. You may have read in the press that all children are to have a night under the stars or that there is to be a 1,000-ranger workforce in England—that type of thing. Those were elements of that report, which is very comprehensive and makes some bold recommendations on the future of designated landscapes such as national parks.

11:00

One proposal that is of relevance in this meeting is proposal 13:

“A ranger service in all our national landscapes, part of a national family.”

Glover recommends a ranger service with both a national identity and a single unifying vision. He asks for a workforce of 1,000 professional rangers to serve England’s designated landscapes and he cites a social return on investment of £7 for each £1 spent. It will not be lost on you that we in Scotland are in danger of losing the very thing that England aspires to. Eileen Stuart has explored other models of ranger delivery, but the key element and the key area that we would like to protect is the professionalism. We have a strong brand with the badge. We have a national network, although it is fragile at the moment. We have a national identity, which we are struggling to maintain. SCRA is pushing to maintain that. There has been very significant investment of public money over four or five decades now. We have built a model that is looked at across the world as one that is worth copying. Glover has made a huge number of recommendations in relation to designated landscapes, but at the very heart of what he is asking for is a professional ranger service.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It seems to me that Scotland is in and of itself probably our greatest asset. If we are going to achieve the potential of that asset and ensure that it is fully enjoyed and realised, a professional ranger service will be integral and key to that delivery. It is to the benefit of us all. It sounds to me as if it may need an education and marketing campaign on the benefits of a ranger service to the people who pay the wages. The anomaly is that, from the evidence that we are hearing, the people whose responsibility it is to pay for and deliver the ranger service do not recognise what they have.

If we are going to have outcomes and if we are going to focus on solutions around the issues that we have discussed today, what can we do practically? What is achievable to make sure that the potential of that big asset—Scotland—is realised?

Jim Downie Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority
link

I was just thinking about George Potts’s point. One of the great strengths of a ranger is the range of duties that sits inside the job—working with landowners, promoting access, protecting the environment, patrolling, being involved in education and interpretation. All those things are very important. The knowledge is not at an expert technical level as such, but rangers have a good knowledge of lots of different parts of the job. That is one of the great strengths. If we go down specific roads such as access officer or biodiversity officer, that is good. It can feed into a professional ranger service that has a broad portfolio of skills, and that is where rangers are at their best. They see opportunities in communities and empower communities to work for themselves and deliver the outcomes that the Scottish Government is looking for.

That is one of the keys. If local authorities or people who are employing rangers do not know what they are doing, it is easy to forget the important part that they play. If there is an agreed set of outputs across the board that we are looking to deliver, the ranger service in Scotland is in a much stronger place to say, “We are going to deliver.” SNH’s agreement in the past was about ensuring a welcome to the countryside and mediation between public use and other rural land use. Those are common across all ranger services. If we report on that together and we present that, it makes a much stronger case for us, and that is one of the things that are missing.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

When Jim Downie was talking about the range of services that rangers can supply, it occurred to me that many of the petitions that we have had in my time on the committee, which is not that long, have pertained to the countryside, such as those on the culling of mountain hares, raptors and the management of grouse moors, and those things relate to the role that a ranger plays as an interface between the public and landowners. It seems to me that we are not selling the ranger service in the way we should. It goes back to what I said earlier about education and marketing. Collectively, the ranger service has to set that out. I do not know who does that and whose responsibility it would be to raise all these issues. It seems to me that rangers have a big part to play in a lot of the work that we are doing in the committee.

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

This has been a useful and interesting discussion. It is right to say that because people do not necessarily understand and recognise what rangers do it is harder for us to make the case for the funding. It is a chicken-and-egg situation. I think that we are all very much agreed that it is important that we raise the profile and recognition of what rangers do and what they can offer.

It struck me in the discussion that there are three things that we are working on that should help. The idea of a national service with everybody having the same employer does not seem to be a model that sits comfortably in Scotland. Even within Cairngorms national park, a single service has not been created; instead the range of services that are provided by both public bodies and landowners and so on have been branded. What rangers do and should have in common is the single, unified vision and clarity of purpose. The professionalism and the identity of rangers absolutely have to be at the heart, so that people are recognise that common identity and help to reinforce the value. That then makes the case for further funding.

There are some interesting ideas on funding that are definitely worth exploring. What SNH sees is that the refined, refreshed statement provides a platform for all of us. It is a shared role to promote and highlight the value of rangers. We have had some productive discussions with the Minister for Rural Affairs and the Natural Environment, and we hope that she will provide the foreword to the statement and help us to raise the profile. We will probably be contacting MSPs and others to see whether they will support that.

We have an opportunity now if we can get that up and running and set it in train. As things evolve, particularly on the funding side, one of the potential opportunities is around the tourist tax—we do not call it that; it is the visitor levy. Highland Council is consulting on that and other local authorities are looking at it. It seems an obvious place to seek funds. Tourists are bringing very useful economic benefits, but they are also having an impact, so the levy would be a logical source of funding to support the rangers and the welcome that we want to see in the countryside. Those are just some thoughts.

Martin Gray Historic Environment Scotland
link

I will reiterate some of what Jim Downie said but add a little example from my organisation, and I will touch on some of Brian Whittle’s points. My organisation went through a period of losing ranger teams. However, after a considerable amount of work with our line management and our current director and chief executive, all now understand what we are trying to achieve with our ranger teams and are very supportive. As a result, we have brought in more permanent and seasonal staff to support our sites at Holyrood and up in Orkney. The increase in visitors to the countryside and tourists to sites has led us to put rangers on site, because they are seen as a key way of delivering to the public.

The diversity of role is there. As an organisation, we now support the idea of rangers when we give advice to others. The Kilmartin glen museum is looking at its funding models and what it is going to do, and we have suggested that a ranger might be part of the way for it to deliver for the community and engage with land managers. The trust at Callanish standing stones is another organisation that is considering how it might fund what it does on its site. Again, we have suggested that a community ranger or somebody of that ilk could be beneficial. As Brian Whittle said, it is about getting the message to the higher decision makers that rangers are great and setting out what they can deliver. Basically, it is about saying, “You need to fund it.”

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

There is a lot of expertise and experience round the table. How often do you get together to promote the vision of the ranger service and to push for funding? It seems like a lot of great work is going on in different areas such as the Cairngorms and Trossachs, but how often do you all come together to promote that vision of what the ranger service does?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

SCRA plays a role in that and it has meetings with employers. I believe that there has not been one for some time, but there is that opportunity. There used to be a good system by which the employers got together regularly to spend a day discussing the issues. For whatever reason, that has fallen by the wayside.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Does that lead back to the suggestion of an expert group? Is that maybe a way forward, Mr Potts?

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

It would certainly help, and it would provide a focus. The variety of work that you have heard about covers many of the national priorities, including health and wellbeing and social inclusion. An expert group needs to reflect that range of work. Just round this table, we have people working all the way from Orkney right down to deepest darkest Balloch. We work right across Scotland in a variety of settings.

Can I come back to Eileen Stuart’s point about SNH’s role?

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Of course.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

All my working life, I have worked in partnership, first with the Countryside Commission for Scotland and then with SNH. I have reported to them and agreed work programmes with them, and we have had funding. In the latter years, the funding has been a tiny percentage of my budget, but I have still been able to report 100 per cent of my outcomes to SNH.

In recent years, we have seen SNH actively disengaging from ranger services. The SNH written submission shows that there is perhaps a couple of years of funding for some of the few services that are still involved. The word “ranger” does not now appear in SNH’s corporate plan and, if we have a wee trawl on the website, we do not find the word “ranger” there, either. That has been a very worrying trend.

We need SNH and that partnership. SNH sits at the table with the Government and it can help to influence priorities and represent us at that big table. That is the partnership that I was used to. SNH can provide that focus, but it has been moving away from that. The services that SNH funds now are community-based ones. It has been funding those for several years, but that sector is still only 2 per cent of the total in Scotland. Does that reflect the influence of SNH on that sector, or is it that SNH is putting money into an area where there is no growth and no need for investment? That is a challenge for SNH. I realise that it has had rigorous budget constraints placed on it, but it is not offering value for money if it does not include in its approach the outcomes that rangers can deliver.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Maurice Corry has a supplementary.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

It is probably addressed to Bob Reid and it relates to the new statement, which I referred to when I was talking to Eileen Stuart. Could the ambition of the new statement be seriously affected by the cuts to ranger posts or do you have a plan B that could deliver the ambition with reduced personnel?

11:15

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

SCRA members are suffering because of the loss of jobs. In the beginning, that was basically about early retirement and people being let away and the jobs going unfilled. That was the start of the move down. We are now finding that rangers in Scotland are having mental health issues because of the increased pressure. Another issue is that a lot of services are being moved to single services with only one person, and there are health and safety issues related to that. On Sunday, I spoke to a young ranger who works in nature reserves in an urban area in Lanarkshire, and she has to take a volunteer with her so that she can feel safe in carrying out her job.

When rangers started up, we were all taken for national ranger training. That gave us the skills to work from the top of the mountain to the marine environment and whether it be in a village, a rural area, forests, town or cities. That is where the rangers are. Certain ranger services in cities have been told that, as a cut, transportation was to be taken away. That did not happen, but were the rangers in a city supposed to go on the bus to do their job? There are issues that need to be drilled into to understand what is really going on with rangers and to find out what local authorities are thinking and how they perceive the service. Everyone who has signed up to the petition cannot speak highly enough about ranger services, but we are continuing down the road to oblivion. Funding is going to other jobs that are basically ranger jobs, so what is wrong with using the title?

The Danish Government adopted the Scottish process, working with local authorities, but the local authorities in Denmark get substantial funding from the Government to provide a professional service. At the end of the day, it is budgeting that will have to resolve the issue, if it is ever going to be resolved.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

George Potts talked about more cohesive working with SNH. Could that help to fill the gap?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes. We have a working relationship, but it needs to go a bit further, possibly through a memorandum of understanding so that the two organisations work in tandem to resolve some of the issues.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I ask Eileen Stuart to outline some of the challenges that SNH is finding with delivering the ranger service.

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

There are a number of things. I will come back to the expert group, but I will first say a little about our role and our relationship with rangers. Our role continues to be very supportive. We recognise the role of SCRA and the other employers and we actively work with all the individuals here.

Our external profile is not as high as it has been in the past. Part of the reason for that is that there is nothing in particular to tell. We hope that, when the new statement is finalised, along with it will come a communications plan about how we use the statement as a platform to engage and to promote the value of a ranger service. We would develop the two things in tandem.

With regard to engagement with rangers, the ranger development partnership is an active and valuable group. It involves the individuals who are round the table today and representation from COSLA. COSLA has not engaged so much in the past, but it is now signalling that it will be round the table and will be active. That is encouraging, but we need to ensure that it happens in practice. We also have a number of other bodies. That group has all the expertise that we need, so we may be able to do something with it. Having an independent chair of the group might fulfil the same purposes as having a new group. Inevitably, a new group would have almost the same people round the table, so we could do something with the existing group that would achieve the same thing.

We all recognise that we are living with a funding challenge and that we have to work together to try to find ways to address it. Bob Reid alluded to the fact that some people who were rangers are still in employment but are called something different, such as an access officer. We need to maximise and use the collective resource of professionals who engage with people and the outside world and we need to ensure that they are recognised as rangers, so that there is commonality and recognition. That would be beneficial. We might be able to encourage funders, such as the national health service or local authorities, that employ people who provide ranger services to put “ranger” in the job title. We know that there are sometimes rangers with other responsibilities, who we might call rangers plus, but we need to ensure that the term “ranger” is used so that they become part of the collective. That will mean that we can develop the pathway so that they have the same training and skills and work to the same vision.

A lot of work is under way, and the petition has been a useful catalyst for starting the ball rolling. There is obviously the will and the expertise round the table to take forward the matter.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

In recent years, organisations have become more dynamic in the way that they change their management structures, and managers across Scotland have inherited ranger services that they do not know what to do with. Previously, there was a reasonable career path for rangers. They would have been in a parks or recreation department—I worked for many years for the planning department—and there was manager representation of rangers in the headquarters. Now, for example, my service in Dundee is managed by somebody with a waste management background. Such managers do not have the background or understanding to take on board the big picture of the national network and the value of the national identity. For us as an association, that has made it difficult to get people to come on board. Bob Reid and I represent SCRA, but we are not representative. We are a pair of old duffers who should be retired.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

I am, yes. Laughter.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

It is a young person’s profession. It is an active career choice for young people and I would like them to have the opportunity to get into the profession. There is a job of work to be done to bring those new managers up to date with what rangers are, what they have to offer and how they individually contribute to the national network and national identity. In that way, we can maintain professional standards in Scotland.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I will follow up on the suggestion that there should be an expert group. The Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority submission outlines the benefits of a strategic framework for the park. Jim Downie, is there a network that can work strategically across the whole of Scotland? Do you agree that there should be an expert group?

Jim Downie Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority
link

As I said earlier, if ranger services across Scotland worked to a common goal that was set out for us—there is a commonality to our work, but a more concrete goal could be stated—ranger services would benefit.

A lot of what we have been talking about highlights the benefits of having a ranger service. Everybody who has been involved and who comments on the ranger service speaks highly of it. We understand that there are benefits to people being outdoors and we understand the benefits of the ranger service to that. However, as a service—for the national park, but also for Scotland—we need to be aligned with the priorities of Scotland. We can do a lot in delivering those priorities, from improving health and wellbeing to inclusion. Getting people out into nature is important for us all. A national framework, an agreement that we are all working to, is a really good idea and we would be happy to be involved in it.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Does anyone else have any additional comments or suggestions? Would Bob Reid like to reflect on the evidence?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

When the Countryside Commission for Scotland set up the ranger service, what is known as the final report of the Speyside project outlined what the ranger service would be. It has not changed much. Perhaps if we go back and look at that document, it might help to give some focus.

Over the years I have quoted our first president, Frank Fraser Darling, who was renowned worldwide. At the very first conference that we held, he said that, “You, as rangers, have the opportunity to develop what the Scottish ranger service will be.” We worked at that and that is what we did, from that point of view.

Rangers all have hope and look to the future. I think that by looking to the future and working cross party, in the sense of across all the organisations, matters can be resolved. Our members see the benefit of that and see that there is value and worth in working together.

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

We very much welcome the vision. The ranger statement must be a collective, cohesive document and we are working with partners so that the statement reflects everybody’s view and has an ambitious, high-profile role for rangers. The statement is out there for comment and I encourage everybody to look at it. We will look very closely at comments and work together. Most of us here are probably in the latter stage of our careers, so we need to make sure that young peoples’ voices and the future are reflected.

A memorandum of understanding is a very useful idea. It is something that we would encourage.

My final comment is about the independent group. One way of getting the ranger development partnership to have a slightly different identity, and perhaps more independence, would be also to have an independent chair. Perhaps SCRA or others have thoughts about that. We chair the group at the moment, but that is almost by default because nobody else has been keen to step into that role. We absolutely would welcome it if there was somebody else who had a higher profile or could bring a new perspective to the role. That would be worth thinking about.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

The heart of the petition is about a strategic approach to rangering and the ranger service. The statement that is being worked up by SNH has a timescale for completion of early 2020. Is there any way for the discussions that we are having about the petition to feed into that statement?

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

Yes, absolutely. The statement is evolving. We have been taking on board things that have emerged in this discussion and will continue to do so. We are very open and want the statement to be something that we feel reflects the views of rangers across Scotland.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

There is a meeting of the ranger development partnership on 11 November and the statement will be first and last on the agenda. We will take it forward from there.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I am reflecting on the mood of the Parliament. Yesterday, we passed the Climate Change (Scotland) Bill. For goodness’ sake, if the rangers cannot be part of that whole ethos and strategy, there is something completely wrong here. To me, we are pushing at an open door: I cannot imagine that anybody would speak against it.

Yes, the Parliament has a role in trying to raise the rangers’ profile and to make sure that the rangers have a framework to work within, but I will throw it back to you that it is the people in this room who have a serious responsibility to bring to us the strategy and vision that we can sell to the public and public services.

11:30

Everything that we have talked about fits very well with Government strategy that has been agreed across the chamber. So, I will throw it back to you. We can discuss this with Government and ask its views on the independent group, but I am pretty sure that there will be no problem or pushback. In my view, it will inevitably come back to the people in this room.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Does anyone else have any other comments or suggestions?

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

My final suggestion is a bit cheeky, but you are all here and offering your support. There is a sharing good practice event that we are jointly holding in December, in our Battleby office in Perth. It is particularly about rangers and their role in promoting health and mental health by encouraging people to access and gain the benefits of the outdoors. I assume that we would be very happy to extend an invitation to members; they might find the event a useful insight into the work of rangers.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Thank you for that. Do committee members have any other comments or suggestions?

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I would be interested in the Government’s view, especially on a short-life working group, to see how we could push and promote the ranger service.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I agree. David Torrance is absolutely right on both those points. I am happy with that.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

I thank the Public Petitions Committee for giving us such a fair hearing. The petition was lodged in December 2017 and here we are in September 2019. I have appreciated the opportunity to engage with the Parliament. Thank you for your support.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

I second that.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Thank you. We will agree to write to the Scottish Government on various points that we have heard in our evidence today.

I would also like to pick something up with COSLA. Even though COSLA provided a written submission in July and is happy to work with stakeholders to find solutions, I think that we need to probe a little bit more about the understanding within local authorities of the benefits of a ranger service, how they think the service should be funded and whether they think that ring-fencing funding is the right way to go about it.

If there are no other suggestions, I also ask SNH to reflect on the evidence that we have heard and to keep us updated as to progress on its side, if that would be okay.

Eileen Stuart Scottish Natural Heritage
link

Absolutely.

Gail Ross SNP The Deputy Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

It remains for me to thank you all for coming along, with special thanks to Bob Reid, the petitioner. Thank you.

Meeting closed at 11:33.

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 83
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 59
  3. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 77

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.