I thank those members who supported the motion in my name, including David Stewart, Rhoda Grant and Neil Findlay from Labour, Mike Rumbles from the Liberal Democrats and John Finnie from the Greens. I am, however, sad that no member of the Scottish National Party signed the motion.
I welcome all those who have travelled from the Highlands to listen to the debate. Some of those who are sitting in the public gallery are members of the whistleblowing group, and I would like to thank them for everything that they have done.
Only last week, an MSP asked me whether I really believed that bullying is an issue. The simple answer is yes—not physical bullying but psychological bullying, which is often worse. Some suffered in silence and some resigned, but until the whistleblowers spoke out, they had nowhere to turn.
I have received requests for help from not only victims but parents who were worried about their children, and wives and husbands who were worried about their partners. I have heard many heartbreaking stories about why people could not face the next day at work because of bullying. One person was not sure that they could face life at all. After 12 years in the Army, I am not faint hearted, but to be rung on a Friday night by a parent distraught about their child, a national health service employee who was contemplating suicide, was not easy.
That was just the tip of the iceberg. Once the whistle was blown, 140 bullying victim testimonies were collated by the GMB trade union, shedding light on the deeply harrowing experiences of a wide variety of NHS Highland staff. Despite my calls and those of many others, the Scottish Government dithered about whether to launch an investigation. When it did so, and John Sturrock QC published his report, the report confirmed what many knew already: there was indeed “fear and intimidation” of staff, many of whom had
“suffered significant and serious harm”.
In my years of professional experience, I have never read such a damning report. In the weeks and months since the report was published, many NHS Highland employees have contacted me. Most were relieved that the culture of bullying had finally been recognised. However, some felt that the report did not deal with their situation. Those are the ones I call the managed out—they were managed out of their jobs by bullying, and they feel that the Sturrock report has not addressed their mistreatment. They should not feel marginalised as part of the process, and I call on the Scottish Government to fully investigate their situation.
It is clear that the Sturrock report, rather than being the last step, is the first step towards changing the culture of NHS Highland. I welcome the reconciliatory approach that has been taken by the new chair and chief executive of NHS Highland. They are driving forward a new culture of respect, and the health board is slowly rebuilding.
However, NHS Highland is not alone in needing to change. In the wake of the Sturrock report, the Scottish Government must also change how it operates. In October last year, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport announced that she would appoint a whistleblowing champion for each health board. I welcome that action, but it has taken until the summer of this year for applications to open. That is too long.
We know what happens when there is not a robust system. As one non-executive director stated in the Sturrock report:
“The issue of a bullying culture was first raised with the auditors, Audit Chair and Board Chair in late 2016.”
They went on to say that the Scottish Government
“knew about it”
but
“Nothing was done.”
In fact, the Government seemed to be blind to the warning signals. Perhaps the biggest red flag was in 2017, when four non-executive members of the NHS Highland board resigned.
When some of the board’s non-executive directors expressed a lack of confidence in the chair and the chief executive, it became clear that something was being done to prop up a failing management team. In response to the non-executives’ claims, the executive members of the board wrote to their colleagues stating their unreserved support for the chair and the chief executive. Not only does that show the dysfunction of the board back in 2017, but it raises serious questions about why the Scottish Government was not watching. Why did it have to take four senior clinicians to exhaust every avenue before their only option was to blow the whistle? Many people are asking why, if the Scottish Government knew about the bullying, it did nothing. Many staff members, both former and current, would like an answer to that question. I believe that they deserve it, which is why I support the whistleblowers’ calls for a further investigation to be launched into why no action was taken in 2016 and to find out what was going on in the board.
Too many loyal and hardworking NHS staff have been mistreated and had their careers ruined as a result of being bullied in NHS Highland. I welcome the Sturrock report, but we need to be clear that the report is just the beginning of a process and not the end. I support the actions of the new chair and chief executive in following through on Sturrock’s recommendations, but Sturrock’s report did not answer every concern. As I mentioned, NHS Highland cannot move on until former employees who were managed out have had their mistreatment addressed.
We still need to have the full and frank debate on the Sturrock report that the cabinet secretary promised in this session of Parliament. We need to make sure that this appalling and sorry state of affairs never, ever happens again. I finish with a plea: let us have that debate, which would be part of the healing process, and let us ensure that whistleblowers are appointed to every board as soon as possible.