I welcome the opportunity to respond to the debate, on behalf of the cabinet secretary, for the Scottish Government. I recognise the strong feeling about aircraft noise that exists among residents and communities that are affected by it, which we have heard about, and among members across the chamber. I recognise, too, the long-standing interest that Gil Paterson has in the issue. I sincerely congratulate him on securing time for the debate, which will be important to his constituents and those of other members.
Until Kevin Stewart, who I was sitting next to, pointed it out to me, I had not appreciated that Mr Paterson had done a pilot project, which, if Mr Stewart is correct, was carried out at Mr Paterson’s own expense. That is definitely going above and beyond the call of duty for members, but it adds further strength to the commitment that Mr Paterson has shown in trying to resolve the issue for his constituents.
I start by referring to the WHO report. The assessment of noise and noise annoyance is a complex process and, as we have heard, different noise sources affect people in different ways. The issue of the extent of health effects that are associated with noise is an on-going area of research, and the WHO report makes an important contribution to our knowledge on the issue. As Rona Mackay, Angus MacDonald, Gil Paterson and others have said, the thresholds that the WHO report has established—45 decibels by day and 40 decibels at night—are very informative. However, it is worth mentioning that, in addition to aircraft noise, the report covers a number of other issues that are associated with road traffic, rail, wind turbines and leisure noise.
Although we might consider the impact of different noise sources in isolation, we must remember that their interaction is also important. At any given point, individuals and wider communities are likely to be exposed to noise from multiple sources simultaneously. Any efforts to mitigate the impact of noise should take that context into account.
As Jeremy Balfour alluded to, part of the reason for our debating the issue is the on-going success of Scotland’s airports. As a number of members have referenced, last week, Edinburgh airport announced its busiest May on record, and in 2017 Glasgow airport had its busiest ever year. Of course, the Scottish Government takes that into account in its targets on and actions to address climate change, the impact of which I know that members are concerned about managing.
Scotland now has direct air services to many parts of the world that we did not have before—including those to the middle east, a range of destinations in North America and numerous cities across Europe—on which we rely for doing business or taking our families on holiday. Edinburgh airport’s newly launched service to Boston, which the Scottish Government assisted it in securing, further enhances Scotland’s route network and eliminates unnecessary connecting flights to hub airports. However, that does not diminish the concern that I know that members have about noise. As I have said, although I recognise the need to place downward pressure on the environmental impacts of aircraft activities, we should not lose sight of the fact that the continuing success of Scotland’s airports brings with it significant economic benefits to an airport’s local area, its wider region and Scotland as a whole.
However, I have been listening closely to the debate and I very much respect the views of members across the chamber who are concerned about emissions. I hope that we can all agree that, with the success that comes from growing airport activity, airports have a wider responsibility to consider the communities around them—in particular, those directly impacted by their activities. Gil Paterson, Rona Mackay, Neil Findlay, Jeremy Balfour and Mark Ruskell all said that they expect airports to act responsibly and to take into account their impact on the community.
It is important to remember that there is already a regime in place to mitigate the impact of noise from airports, with every major airport required to have measures in place to do that. The Environmental Noise (Scotland) Regulations 2006 require major airports to produce a strategic noise map and a noise action plan setting out how they plan to mitigate the impact of noise from the airport. There is a requirement under the regulations for an airport to use all reasonable endeavours to take the actions set out in its action plan.
It is important to stress that the action plans are required to be updated at least every five years. Glasgow airport updated its plan last year to cover the period 2018 to 2023. As I understand it, Glasgow airport’s plan was produced on the basis of extensive feedback gathered during a 13-week public consultation between January and April 2018. That represented an opportunity for the public to have their say on what the airport is doing to mitigate noise specifically.
Given the concerns of Mr Paterson and others, it is worth highlighting that Glasgow airport is taking further measures under its noise action plan to mitigate noise for residents. Those measures include developing a noise insulation policy to mitigate noise for residents who are most affected by aircraft noise—clearly, the move by the UK Government will aid those efforts—and incentivising the use of quieter aircraft through differential landing charges. Mr Findlay is, however, right to indicate that, in future, electric planes may well play a role in helping to reduce aircraft noise. Indeed, they are already being trialled in Norway so, as he said, they are not perhaps as far away from being used commercially as people may think.
The measures also include encouraging aircraft to adopt continuous descent operations, which involve aircraft maintaining a steady state of approach, which in turn reduces noise; and developing an airspace change proposal, which will allow aircraft to fly more accurately along departure routes, minimising the number of people affected by aircraft noise.
It should be noted that the regulations do not just cover airports; they also cover major roads and railways as well as major urban areas. That recognises the need to address—as previously stated—the fact that noise comes from multiple sources. However, colleagues are right that the airports should take action where they can do so.
The exchanges between Mr Findlay and Mr Balfour touched on the point, which Mr Ruskell made, too, that they are conscious that changes in flight paths can mean that although some communities become less impacted by aircraft noise, others see aircraft noise increase.
Although, as a number of colleagues have said, airspace change is a reserved matter that is the responsibility of UK ministers and the UK Parliament, and the Scottish Government has no direct, formal role in the process, we have emphasised previously the need for airports to properly consult local communities on their proposals. Mr Findlay made clear that he is very concerned about making sure that that happens and that those consultations are genuine. Indeed, I make the point again today that we expect that to happen.
At present, large parts of our airspace are crowded and inefficient. That is clearly bad for passengers, but it is also bad for the environment and for the wider economy. It is perhaps obvious, but I should restate it, that using our airspace more efficiently can lessen the need for things such as aircraft stacking, thereby making journeys quicker and using less fuel—meaning a cut in emissions and, I hope, less noise over the communities closest to airports.
It is important that the necessary changes are made to the use of our airspace to accommodate future growth in a sustainable way. It is also essential, however, that airports consult local communities effectively and take account of the responses to that consultation before deciding which options to pursue as part of an airspace change process.
Finally, the mitigation of the impact of noise from an airport must be balanced against the benefits that an airport brings in terms of economic growth, employment and so forth. The 2006 regulations impose requirements on airport operators to take action in relation to noise. I was greatly heartened to hear about the impact of individual measures that can be taken and my colleague Kevin Stewart was keen to emphasise that he will be looking at protection against noise in his review of building standards.