In that case, convener, I will speak quickly.
Thank you for inviting me to speak to the draft order. We are seeking parliamentary approval to extend the presumption in question now that additional safeguards for protecting victims through the Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Act 2018 are in force, and as we committed to do in our programme for government.
The presumption is not a ban. We are not abolishing sentences of under 12 months, and the judiciary will continue to be able to impose custodial sentences where alternatives are not appropriate. Extending the presumption is not a silver bullet, but must be seen as part of a broader evidence-led, preventative approach.
The evidence is clear that short periods of imprisonment do not work. They disrupt the things that are most likely to help to reduce offending, such as family relationships, housing, employment and access to healthcare and support. People who are released from short custodial sentences of 12 months or less are reconvicted nearly twice as often as those who received a community payback order.
We have all heard community sentences being described as “soft justice”, but that is both misleading and damaging. In its written evidence to the committee, the Scottish Sentencing Council states that, in its view,
“community ... sentences are not a ‘soft option’, as is sometimes suggested.”
A recent Council of Europe report found that Scotland has the third highest correctional rate in Europe, at 548 people per 100,000, and committee members will know that we have the highest imprisonment rate in western Europe, with 150 people incarcerated per 100,000 of the population. Those are not statistics to be proud of, although we have taken bold action that has helped to cut crime by around a third over the past decade and to drive reconviction rates down to a 19-year low.
We need to get away from the view that justice is either hard or soft. Justice needs to be proportionate and fair and, above all, to be smart and evidence led. It needs to be tailored to the individual while ensuring the safety of victims, and it needs to provide the opportunity for rehabilitation while ensuring that those whose offending has harmed the community pay back for their crimes. We need community sentences in which sentencers, offenders, communities and victims have confidence, and that is why we have invested an additional £9.5 million in community justice services, bringing investment in community justice social work to over £100 million.
It is clear from the evidence that the committee has taken that there is strong support for extending the presumption provided that there are community-based interventions that are appropriate, resourced and effective.
During the committee’s evidence-taking sessions, the issue of remand has been raised in recognition of the fact that its impact can be similar to that of short custodial sentences. Prisoners who are on remand make up about 20 per cent of the prison population at any given time, and the figure for women is 25 per cent. The number of people who are held on remand is at its highest level for more than five years.
Last year, following the committee’s inquiry into the use of remand in Scotland, it made a number of recommendations and observed that, in summary cases, the conversion rate of remand to custodial sentences was relatively low. In responding to that report and in delivering our programme for government commitments on bail supervision, guidance and funding, we have taken action. However, we are open to considering on a cross-party basis further options that could help to respond to the high proportion of prisoners who are held on remand.
I hope that my opening statement has been helpful. I am happy to answer any questions on the proposed extension of the presumption against short sentences.