PE1652, on abusive and threatening communication, was lodged by Irene Baillie. The petition was last considered in December 2018, when we invited the petitioner to comment on the final report of the independent review of hate crime legislation—the Bracadale review. Although the petitioner thinks that the report is “fantastic”, she is concerned that it does not cover the issues raised in her petition.
The Scottish Government has indicated that it is currently considering responses to its consultation on the Bracadale recommendations. It maintains its position that there are potentially
“a number of practical difficulties”
in relation to delivering what the petitioner is calling for, noting that some matters are reserved to Westminster. The Scottish Government also refers to on-going work on this issue, including the UK Government’s white paper on online harms and the Law Commission’s review of the law in England and Wales. It states that it
“will carefully consider any proposals”
to change the law in this area, where the relevant powers are devolved.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?

