Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Mental Health Support for Young People (Inquiry)

Thursday 21 March 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00–11:00 Petitions 69 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

69 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next evidence-taking session relates to the committee’s inquiry into mental health support for young people in Scotland. As members will know, the inquiry was launched in connection with PE1627, by Annette McKenzie, on consent for mental health treatment for people under 18 years of age. The committee wishes to understand where young people can seek help from at an early stage before they reach the point of crisis, the extent to which young people are aware of how they might support their peers, and how we can increase public awareness of what I think we have established is quite a complicated landscape.

At its meeting on 21 February 2019, the committee considered a thematic analysis of the responses to the call for evidence. We are very grateful to all those who responded and for the wide range of evidence that we received. From that evidence, it is clear that the Scottish Government is undertaking a wide range of work in the area of children and young people’s mental health services. To assist the committee in determining where it could focus its work in the inquiry, we have requested an update from the Minister for Mental Health on the progress of Scottish Government policies. The minister is here today to give evidence to the committee to that end. She is accompanied by her officials from the Scottish Government: Dr John Mitchell, senior medical adviser; Hugh McAloon, deputy director, children and young people’s mental health; Philip Raines, head, children and young people’s mental health delivery unit; and Lyndsay Wilson, senior policy lead, suicide prevention. Welcome.

I invite the minister to make a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Thank you very much, convener. I am happy to set out the Scottish Government’s approach to improving support for our nation’s mental health and to address any issues that the committee might raise.

I start by describing our vision and how it has shaped the work that we have set out. My vision for the mental health of children and young people, which was presented in the “Mental Health Strategy 2017-2027”, is about ensuring that children and young people

“get the right help at the right time, expect recovery, and fully enjoy their rights, free from discrimination and stigma.”

We know that in order to achieve that vision a decisive change is needed in the support for children and young people.

Audit Scotland’s report “Children and young people’s mental health” highlighted that there is often too great a focus on crisis and specialist services at the expense of early intervention and prevention. You will have seen the Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee’s recent report on that Audit Scotland report. We welcome that committee’s report and recommendations, just as we welcomed the report from Audit Scotland.

We are taking action in several areas. First, we acknowledge that performance in specialist services needs to improve. Although recent statistics show that improvement is happening, I am clear that we need to remain focused on driving sustainable and faster improvement, and steps are being taken to drive that change. We have invested £4 million in improving the capacity of child and adolescent mental health services by recruiting 80 additional staff; discussions are under way to support performance as part of the development of the annual operating plans of national health service boards; we are increasing resources to support improvement in health services in every part of Scotland; and, finally, I have established and chair a new strategic board for mental health to monitor and drive the necessary improvements.

Secondly, sustainable performance will be possible only if we drive wider system change. Our mental health strategy set out the key framework for achieving that; that has been backed by ambitious commitments to action and resources in the 2017 and 2018 programmes for government, and we are committing a quarter of a billion pounds to that work. We have set out our detailed plans in “Better Mental Health in Scotland”, which was published in December, and key to our approach is improving the capacity of not just our health services but all services that can support mental health. That is why we are making significant investments in the capacity of education to support children and young people.

Thirdly, we are looking to key independent groups to highlight where reform needs to go in future. The work of the children and young people’s mental health task force, chaired by Dr Dame Denise Coia, will be vital for the issues that we are discussing today. The task force will set out detailed recommendations to the Scottish Government and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities that will drive our future work. Similarly, the national leadership group for suicide prevention, chaired by Rose Fitzpatrick, will make recommendations on how we can be more effective in making suicide everybody’s business. Both groups set out their delivery plans last December. At the same time, we are undertaking major reviews of key mental health issues. For example, we have in the past month announced a major review of forensic mental health services as well as a wide-ranging review of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003.

Lastly, I highlight the critical importance of reducing the stigma around mental health issues and ensuring that young people are comfortable with speaking out if they experience poor mental health. Mental health is one of our key public health priorities, and we will work with the new public health Scotland body and other partners on how to drive that priority across all our work.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you, minister. A focus of the committee’s interest is the early interventions that can be made in a young person’s life and the support that they can draw on, and I note that a number of the announcements made on mental health services in the Scottish Government’s programme for government for 2018-19 had the same perspective. Can you update the committee on the progress that is being made towards the goal of having a counselling service in every secondary school, an additional 250 school nurses and the offer of mental health first aid training for teachers in every local authority? Moreover—I know that this was not a commitment—would the Government consider offering mental health first aid training not just to teaching staff but to other staff in schools?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

If you will allow me to, convener, I will take those points individually.

On the provision of counselling services in every secondary school, our commitment in the 2018 programme for government was to ensure that every secondary school had access to such services. The work on introducing counselling in schools is progressing well, and we are continuing to work in partnership with COSLA on establishing a delivery model for that commitment. As you will expect, my officials have been working very closely with officials in the education portfolio on that, and officials are also continuing to work in partnership with COSLA and local authorities on establishing a formal joint agreement, with two of the four required stages now completed.

Further work is being undertaken on establishing the appropriate funding model for the distribution of resource to education authorities, and it is anticipated that the model will be considered by COSLA in April. A key issue that perhaps has not been highlighted so far is the fact that the counselling service that we are putting into secondary schools is a year-round, not term-time, service. After all, young people’s needs do not stop when the school closes for the school holidays.

Our first step in rolling out our 2018 programme for government commitment to put in place an additional 250 school nurses was a survey of the existing school nursing capacity in every NHS board area. That survey has now been completed, and it might well inform the development of an action plan for rolling out additional capacity and the necessary upskilling of the existing workforce, which is due in late spring. The relevant training and coursework materials have been developed to ensure that the existing workforce has the necessary skills to carry out what is a different role.

With regard to training teachers in mental health first aid, the current mental health first aid programme has been offered to six local authorities, where staff working with children and young people are undertaking the training, and we are on track to ensure that the offer is made to all local authorities within the original timescales that we outlined. We have also convened a joint project to design and develop a specific training course that will be made available to all school staff. I hope that that answers your final question, convener.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That all sounds interesting, but it is clear that, when you talk about, for example, setting up the funding model or getting an agreement, it is all about process. When can we reasonably expect a school to have one of those counsellors, and when we can expect all schools to have one?

10:30

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

I answered a question similar to that in the chamber not so long ago. We have committed to having the first tranche of counsellors in schools by the start of the 2019-20 academic year.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

We anticipate that it will be 50 per cent. I appreciate what you said about a lot of this being about process, but we need to ensure that the mechanisms are there to deliver the interventions on the ground.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Systems sometimes create busyness that is without outcomes. However, if you are asking for things to happen yesterday, minister, that will move things along a little bit. People can take comfort in process, but we really want there to be a difference in our schools as a consequence of the policy.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Absolutely—I do not disagree with that. We need action, and I hope that action is what will be demonstrated.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Minister, you will be aware that, last week, the convener of the Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee stated:

“The absence of basic data in relation to a whole range of factors in mental health provision for children means that it is not possible to say whether public spending is making a difference to young people’s mental health.”

The Scottish Government has made additional funding commitments, such as the £60 million investment in the school counselling service. In the absence of basic data on young people’s mental health services, how are the impacts of that and similar investments to be measured?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

The children and young people’s task force has a dedicated workstream to address finance and data issues. It might be helpful if I ask Hugh McAloon to give you some details about how the task force will carry out that work.

Hugh McAloon Scottish Government
link

In its delivery plan, which was published in December, the task force laid out how it will carry out its work on finance. It is seen as a complex area because it looks across a range of different services and players, but the task force broke it down into three fairly simple tasks.

The first task is to identify the full investment in children and young people’s mental health. The difficulty of measuring that has come up before—it moves beyond the health service to universal children and families services, including schools. However, that is the first task that the taskforce has set itself.

The second task is to ensure that the investment lands where it is intended. When money is invested in children’s and young people’s mental health, we need to ensure that we have a way of tracking that, so that it lands where it is meant to land.

The third—and probably the most important—task is to develop a consistent and agreed approach to ensure that the investment delivers for children and young people, their families and the taxpayer, and that there is a return on it.

That is a simple way of describing the work of that workstream. It is helpful that it is so simple, because it cuts to the core questions.

There are significant shared elements and interdependencies between the finance and data workstreams, so all those questions can only really be answered by an improvement in the quality of data in the entire system. It is an area that I am reasonably new to, but it seems that, although there is no shortage of data, it is hard to pull information out of it. There are also gaps in the data, so the task force is looking at the bits beyond the NHS in which the data—although there is a lot of it on what is going on—does not tell the full story because it does not reach into universal services. The interaction between the data and the finance workstreams will be really important for the task force.

I anticipate that a lot of that work will be informed by other workstreams, such as the workstream that is looking at universal generic services in communities, which will consider bringing together health and other integrated children and families services. That has probably not been done before. The data requirements to monitor the effectiveness of that will probably emerge as the recommendations of that workstream emerge.

Similarly, the work that is going on in the specialist workstream, which is looking at a new and reformed approach to CAMHS, will throw up questions about how we measure progress and the effectiveness of that different approach.

The whole thing fits together, and the three key questions—about identifying the level of investment, making sure that it lands where it is meant to land and developing a consistent approach to the return on it—run right through the task force’s work. We anticipate that the recommendations that we will get on them will provide clear direction on how to take that work forward.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Okay. That all sounds like quite a task, but we will clearly monitor it as it progresses. Thanks.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

The report on mental health services for children and young people that Audit Scotland published in September 2018 highlights that mental health referrals for children and young people increased by 22 per cent over the five years to 2017-18. Minister, you made a very important statement about making suicide prevention, for example, everybody’s business. What are the factors that have driven such a significant increase in referrals?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

As Dame Denise Coia noted in her initial recommendations, which were published in September and which led to the formation of the task force, the rise in referrals signals an increased demand for services from those with emotional distress. The rising demand partly reflects the success of campaigns and the increased awareness of mental wellbeing. It is important that we recognise that, as a society, we are much more willing to admit that we are not feeling well but are in distress, and to seek help.

However, the increase might also reflect some of the increasing pressures that we hear about from young people—I hear about them when I go into schools, when I talk to young people and when I talk to my family. Not the least of those pressures seems to arise from social media and the pressures that it puts on to that generation. I do not think that our generations appreciate those pressures, as we grew up in a different world. Mitigation of them is a fundamental rationale for the programme for government investment in the work of the task force and the drive to increase the range of early intervention and prevention services that we need to ensure are in place to help children and young people.

We have spoken about the work to ensure that our schoolteachers have mental health first aid training and adequate skills, and we are putting in an increased number of school nurses with a focus on mental health and wellbeing. School counsellors are being introduced in every secondary school, and the task force is working to look at early intervention, community wellbeing and so on. All those things are really important in terms of getting that early intervention in there.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

We are talking about young people, who are looked after by their parents, hopefully. What are you doing in your review in connection with parental guidance on the issue? Sadly, that is missing at the moment. There is a lot of peer pressure on children at younger and younger ages regarding mobile phone use, social media and so on, but I do not see anything about the parents and how you might help to educate them.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

You might be aware that the four chief medical officers around the UK issued guidance for parents last month on screen time and social media. Much of that is also about modelling good behaviour, including things like not using mobile phones at the dinner table, keeping screen time out of the bedroom, emphasising the importance of sleep and so on.

John Mitchell might be able to add a little bit more on the specifics of the guidance that the CMOs put out.

Dr Mitchell
link

As the minister said, there is specific guidance about social media. The other aspects of our interventions with parents are at very early ages in terms of psychology and positive parenting programmes.

With regard to the emerging concern about distress in young people, and the finding that something new is happening among our adolescent female population to do with their presentations and expressions of distress, we are expanding the distress brief intervention programme from the summer of 2020 to include people under the age of 18. We are already thinking that that will involve work with families and not just with individuals and young people on their own.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Would it be helpful for you to hear about how we are involving parents in the task force?

Hugh McAloon Scottish Government
link

Joanna Murphy, who is the chair of the National Parent Forum of Scotland, is a member of the task force. With Joanna’s input, the task force is establishing a parents network to reach out to parents groups across Scotland. The network is at an early stage, but the task force will use it to inform the development of its recommendations. Young people and parents are at the centre of the task force. Dame Denise Coia talks a lot about that.

We are looking at the potential for some form of digital platform to provide advice and support to not just young people and children, but their parents. That is key. The task force will look at how that can fit in with other services out there that parents use and how we can integrate the advice and support on mental health that we provide into those services.

Finally, there is Denise Coia’s work and that of the task force on community hub-based approaches to earlier intervention and support around mental health. It is very much at the forefront of Denise Coia’s mind that we should look at support for parents. She has spoken to a lot of parents, particularly of children who were rejected for CAMHS, and the constant message from them is that they need someone to talk to, to help them through their situation. Parents are very much at the heart of the recommendations that I would expect to come out of the task force.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I think that you are on the right track, if that is the case. As a parent, it is music to my ears.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are mindful that the petition was prompted by Annette McKenzie losing her daughter, having been unaware that her daughter was on medication. There is the whole question of when something should be confidential and when it is wise to ask someone to share what they are doing with the people around them. We are very conscious of how difficult this has been for the family.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

According to the chair of the children and young people’s mental health task force, Dame Denise Coia, the following changes are required

“to reform and improve the system of children and young people’s mental health services:

A stronger focus on prevention, social support and early intervention;

A wider range of more generic, less specialist interventions to free up specialist services to see those in most need of them; and

Better information and understanding for the public, and all agencies and services, of where emotional distress and mental health and mental wellbeing problems are best supported.”

Do you agree with that assessment?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Absolutely. Those are the themes that underpin the task force’s work. They are what Dame Denise set out in her initial recommendations and they have informed our commitments in the programme for government.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

What current mental health policy initiatives address Dr Coia’s recommended reforms and what more needs to be done to do so?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

We have spoken about the on-going work. We have a commitment to put a school counsellor in every secondary school in Scotland and to provide additional school nurses. Teachers in every local authority are being offered mental health first aid training. We must not look at schools in isolation. We do not train someone in first aid and expect that they will use their skills only within the work environment or when they are volunteering. The training that we are offering will equip a whole population of people with skills that they will be able to use in their everyday lives.

There are a broad range of policies and on-going commitments that will help to improve the knowledge and skills that people have to deal with mental wellbeing and mental distress, and to raise awareness of those issues throughout the population. Hugh McAloon might want to talk about specific aspects of the task force.

10:45

Hugh McAloon Scottish Government
link

It might be helpful if I say a little bit about the process that will be used with the task force. A team within our division is exclusively providing support to the task force, but the task force is independent of Government, and we are well used to carrying out such work.

I have been involved in similar work in relation to youth employment. It took a more traditional approach, in that the independent group came up with recommendations and the Government and COSLA considered and then implemented them as a whole.

This time round, the approach feels a bit more interactive, which is important because we are looking at a set of live issues for children and young people and their families. In some ways, the work is similar, in that independent recommendations will be made for the Government and COSLA to consider and—if there is agreement—implement. However, rather than waiting until the task force finishes its work in 2020, we anticipate that it will provide recommendations for consideration at various intervals as it does its work. Rather than waiting until everything is ready, the task force will make recommendations in specific areas as they are ready.

We probably all agree on what needs to change. Dame Denise Coia describes well why there needs to be a wider-ranging and easier-access approach that is built on prevention and early intervention. Those aspects are underdeveloped at the moment. Waiting times are too long. The level of rejected referrals is far too high and should not be a feature of the system at all, and that results in distress and anguish for children and young people and their parents. Those are the reasons why we are doing the work.

The task force’s role is not about endlessly describing the situation, but about how we change it. I expect the task force’s recommendations to be challenging, because it would be surprising if they were not. We know that the status quo needs to be challenged. As we go, I hope that we will be able to work with our colleagues in local government in taking forward some of the recommendations, even as the task force continues its work. I anticipate that feature of our approach to be evident over the next year and a half.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Earlier, we talked about social media, which is an important strand of work in the committee’s inquiry into mental health. Dr Mitchell mentioned the chief medical officer, Catherine Calderwood, who has said:

“There’s no evidence of causation of harm”

but that there has been

“a rise in children’s depression rate”

and that children say

“that their quality of life is lower if they are using screen time for long periods of time.”

We welcome the Government’s recent announcement about the new guidance on the healthy use of social media and screen time. What work is being undertaken on the development of the guidance? Has the Scottish Government done any work on the impact that social media is having on young people’s wellbeing?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

I think that Rachael Hamilton would agree that we grew up in a very different world from the one in which our children are growing up. Sometimes, as parents, it is quite difficult to understand the pressures that young people are under.

With regard to the Scottish Government’s commissioned work, we are developing advice on social media use, which will be produced by young people, for young people. That is really important for the credibility of the guidance, as well as to help us to understand the landscape and the world in which young people live. If the committee is interested, we would be happy to inform the committee of further timelines as they become available.

Research on the impact of social media was commissioned last year, and we will publish it very soon.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Has the Scottish Government had any collaboration or discussions with social media platforms such as Facebook and Instagram? There are recommendations that age verification could be improved and that the sharing of data might be useful. I presume that those issues are part of the research that you have undertaken. The industry has a duty of care, too, and there has been a suggestion that a voluntary code of conduct should be developed. I presume that those will be some of the points that come out of the work that has been going on with young people.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Those sound very much like some of the things that would have been considered as part of the background preparation for the commissioning. I do not have the exact detail of that to hand, but I am happy to write to the committee to provide you with that information, if you are interested in it.

Philip Raines Scottish Government
link

Many of those issues start to move into the territory of the UK Government, so we will have to work closely with it. UK Government colleagues are doing a lot of work in the area and discussions on many of those issues are on-going. We need to pool our efforts to ensure that there is a collective effort across all the nations in having discussions with the relevant platform providers or others. I guess that the question is about where we can best lend our efforts to support that work.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

A number of the submissions that the committee received as part of our inquiry into mental health support for young people in Scotland referred to a need for a change to the approach of mental health services, from a biomedical model that is based on medicating children and young people to an approach that is based on levels of psychological distress and trauma and recognising the social, psychological and biological factors. People are advocating a different approach from that of thinking that there is something wrong and we need to fix it.

Do you agree that such a change of approach would be helpful? What policy initiatives are planned or are under way that would encourage such change, which is partly about mindset?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

We need to recognise that the issues around young people’s mental health extend across a spectrum, from wellbeing to mental illness, just as they do for all of us. As we have heard, the task force’s intention is to have a whole-system approach to change and improvement right across that spectrum from wellbeing to treatment for illness.

We would challenge the idea that there is a single biomedical model. The few children who have mental illness must be able to access evidence-based treatment, which must include medication. We would not question the need for some children to receive medication for a physical illness, so we have to be careful about how we approach the issue of mental illness. However, I absolutely recognise that people have concerns about the use of medication for children.

The 2017 UK National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidelines on treating depression in children and young people clearly state:

“Antidepressant medication should not be used for the initial treatment of children and young people with mild depression.”

The guidelines provide information on the use of that particular medication in more severe conditions. That is the prescribing guidance that we expect clinicians to follow.

John Mitchell might be able to give a bit more information on the safeguards and the guidelines on the use of medication. It is an important issue that is raised each year when we publish the figures on the number of children who are prescribed medication. I absolutely understand why that can cause some people alarm, but the vast majority of children have a psychosocial intervention or a talking-based or play-based therapy to treat their illness or condition.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is that being monitored? One of the questions at the core of the petition is about the point at which people are prescribed medication and the extent to which general practitioners and others are under pressure. Medication should not be the first port of call, but there are pressures that can lead to that happening, although I am not saying that that is a universal experience. Has any work been done on what happens when the straightforward option is prescription but the guidelines say that it should not happen until further down the line?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Yes; a lot of work has been done over recent years. John Mitchell will provide the committee with the detail on that.

Dr Mitchell
link

It is thanks to the energies of the petitioner that, as the committee will be aware, I wrote to all general practitioners in Scotland and to the royal colleges on this very important issue. My very detailed letter explained the issues in the petition and the importance of being aware of the guidelines and following them, as well as issues to do with consent and capacity.

As part of the specialist task force sub-group’s work, we have had conversations with the Royal College of General Practitioners about the prescribing of medication by GPs. That on-going conversation is looking at whether there might be an opportunity for the emerging single national Scottish formulary for medicines to lay out—if there are shared care arrangements—who should be prescribing what and when. Those conversations are happening.

As the minister has said, we have an annual publication that gives us data on the prescribing of medication for mental health problems in adults and children, which is broken down by health board. Primary care data is also produced for discussion at practice level about prescribing not just mental health medication, but other medication.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

On the question of whether prescribing medication is the first port of call or whether that happens further along the line, is that monitored? I am not a clinician, but there may be circumstances in which a GP feels prescribing medication at the first stage is the most appropriate decision. Is that monitored?

Dr Mitchell
link

As the minister has said, the NICE guidelines are clear that antidepressant medication should not be used for the initial treatment of children and young people with mild depression—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The NICE guidelines may say that, but we know that such prescribing happens. Is that monitored?

Dr Mitchell
link

We monitor the use of antidepressant prescribing in children—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Does that monitoring establish the point at which the medication was prescribed in the journey of a child?

Dr Mitchell
link

It does not go into that detail, but we would expect the prescribing of antidepressants to be supervised by specialists in specialist child and adolescent mental health services. As I said, part of the work of the specialist group—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am sorry to interrupt, but does that mean that you would not expect a GP to prescribe antidepressants for children at all?

Dr Mitchell
link

No.

Dr Mitchell
link

No. We would expect the initiating of prescribing to be a specialist function. GPs would be asked to do the on-going prescribing—the provision of a prescription—hence the conversation with the Royal College of General Practitioners about the precise arrangements for that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is that specifically for antidepressants rather than other related medication that might be used for somebody experiencing anxiety?

Dr Mitchell
link

As happened in the tragic case that the petitioner has come to us with, the medicine used was not an antidepressant—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

But it was a medicine prescribed for anxiety.

Dr Mitchell
link

Yes, but with a primary function for another purpose. The information on prescribing in primary care is, as I have said, generic; there is not a specific measurement for children and young people of exactly what is prescribed for those conditions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Does that mean that you would not know whether—I am not saying that they are—young people are routinely prescribed antidepressants at the first appointment?

Dr Mitchell
link

They would not be prescribed antidepressants at a first appointment with a GP, because the NICE guidelines are clear that they would not be. If a child or young person presents to a GP with moderate or severe depression, the expectation is that that GP would seek specialist help and involvement, and any prescribing would be initiated through that process.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The system would not identify prescriptions for anxiety that were not antidepressants but something else.

Dr Mitchell
link

Not across the total range of medicines—it does so in the same way as it identifies physical health conditions.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

On that point, is data on the pathway collected? For example, in a case in which the GP prescribes tablets for anxiety, is data collected about any previous recommendation that that young person be treated through a different form of therapy? That would enable us to see a correlation between which pathways are working and which are not, before they are referred to a specialist.

11:00

Dr Mitchell
link

We would expect that, if a young person in distress presents to a health service, the GP’s first order of business would be to use their clinical skills to consider support and social prescribing opportunities. That information would be documented in the primary care records. However, there is not a national amalgamation of that information, as such.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Do you think that it would be useful to do that so that, in extreme cases in which suicide happens, we could see whether a distinct pattern emerged in the pathways that GPs have recommended?

Dr Mitchell
link

When a serious incident such as a suicide happens, critical incident processes mean that there will be a detailed exploration of the previous historical narrative leading up to what has happened with that person, and that will lead to recommendations being made. We have a lot of information on suicides and the prodromes to suicide. The challenge is more in the generality of ordinary practice, as it must be recognised that presentations of distress, not only to primary care but to schools and other services, as well as to employers and so on, are relatively common. The hard data on that story is not present and it is not possible to pull it together.

As I said, we are working with the Royal College of General Practitioners on the issue of prescribing to try to get a better handle on that information. However, I cannot give you comfort about whether a narrative around the young person in distress, which would show that the environmental supports that are available to someone have been explored, has been clearly documented and measured. The situation is the same with, for example, middle-aged men with high blood pressure who have an earlier narrative that involves advice about their weight and smoking and recommendations that they take out sports memberships. That narrative is not necessarily measured to the same degree as the data that we have about antihypertensive prescribing in Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you think that the process that says that antidepressants must be prescribed only by a specialist should apply to other forms of medication that are being given to address mental health issues, such as something for anxiety that is not an antidepressant? Is that something that you should be considering?

Dr Mitchell
link

We have to allow fundamental clinical decisions to be made according to clinical judgment. A wide range of medical treatments are used. Some of those are reserved for specialists and some of those are not. Fundamentally, which treatment to use is up to the clinician who is assessing the situation and initiating the prescribing of medicine, if that is what is judged to be the correct course of action.

To say that all prescribing of everything under any circumstances for mental health problems should be done only by specialists would not be possible, because that sort of approach is not possible in relation to physical health. We also have to remember that prescribing is not necessarily done by doctors.

The approach has to be proportionate. We have to accept that, for someone who is saying that they are anxious and that the problem that they have is that their heart is beating so fast that it is troubling them, a GP might choose to use a medicine that would maintain their heartbeat at regular level rather than choose to prescribe an antidepressant or a sedative medicine. It would be impossible to limit the ability of clinicians to prescribe the broadest range of medicines.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes, although I suppose that the question is whether physical distress is a consequence of emotional distress; a clinician would be able to identify that and to apply the same kind of caveats or precautions that apply to the prescribing of other medicine, which goes to the heart of what resulted in the petition being lodged.

I thank all the witnesses for what has been a useful session that has given us a lot of information about how to progress our inquiry into mental health support for young people in Scotland. We will reflect on what has been said. The minister offered to provide more information on a number of occasions. We would welcome any information that you think would be useful to us. We might want to look further at Dame Denise Coia’s work. We will have an opportunity to reflect on what we have heard. Are there any specific points that members would like to make at this stage?

The inquiry is not work that we have decided to undertake lightly. We want to think about which aspects of the issue we should focus on to strengthen the work that is being done elsewhere. I am very conscious of the work that Dame Denise Coia is doing and how substantial that is. At a later stage, we will have an opportunity—

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I am sorry, convener. I just want to make the point that it might help with our inquiry if we could get a bit more information about the digital platform that Hugh McAloon talked about, if that would be possible.

Hugh McAloon Scottish Government
link

We can provide that separately, if that would be okay.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am not saying that you have outstayed your welcome, but you have certainly provided us with a substantial amount of your time and given us plenty of food for thought, which we appreciate. We are conscious of the need to do work that bolsters the existing work and assists in what is a very challenging area.

We will have an opportunity to reflect further on how we should proceed with our inquiry but, for now, I thank all the witnesses very much for their attendance.

11:07 Meeting suspended.

11:10 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 63
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 69
  3. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.