Agenda item 2 is evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform, and her Scottish Government officials, on the draft Conservation (Natural Habitats, &c) (EU Exit) (Scotland) (Amendment) Regulations 2019. The cabinet secretary is accompanied by Scottish Government officials Steven Dora, who is a policy manager; Michael McLeod, who is the head of marine conservation; and Norman Munro from the legal services directorate. Good morning to you all.
I have an initial question for the cabinet secretary. What informal consultation did the Scottish Government undertake in drafting the regulations, and what issues were raised?
Roseanna CunninghamSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform · Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
There was no statutory requirement to consult formally, but we engaged with stakeholders—people will understand that only a short time has been available—and have taken on board their comments. For example, drafting changes were made in response to comments on the importance of consulting Scottish Natural Heritage for the purpose of issuing guidance, and officials worked with key partners including SNH to ensure that amendments will work for Scottish interests. We have engaged with the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and other United Kingdom Administrations on the content of equivalent statutory instruments through which similar technical amendments are being made.
We spoke to others: we did not have enough time to do a formal consultation, but there has been discussion.
We know that a wider Scottish Government consultation is taking place on governance gaps. Will you set out the Government’s view on the extent to which the draft regulations can achieve equivalence with current EU arrangements? Where are the outstanding governance gaps?
We do not see huge governance gaps. In effect, we are taking the European Commission out of the picture for the purposes of a post-Brexit scenario, but all the various reporting requirements will pretty much stay as you would expect, so we do not anticipate there being a governance gap, in the sense that people might think that there is going to be a big problem.
Equivalence with the current arrangements will be achieved by the draft regulations. In a sense, creating that equivalence is what they are about. There is no change being made to the existing policy approach and we have made changes only where we consider them to be absolutely necessary. All the protections and standards that are currently provided by the habitats directive and the relevant bits of the wild birds directive are being retained. The regulations are really about ensuring that the existing protection regime can continue to work effectively.
The regulations are not exactly the same as the current ones because that will not be not possible when we are outside the EU. We have to have something that can operate effectively from 11 pm on 29 March—or whenever it might be—and the draft regulations make that technical fix.
With regard to the process for designating special areas of conservation, does the Government consider that the new process, which requires consultation of nature conservation agencies, achieves equivalence with the current situation? Do you foresee there being gaps through loss of European Commission oversight that will need to be addressed?
The process for designation achieves equivalence with the current situation. That is what the draft regulations are designed to do. They do the bare minimum to the designation process to ensure that it remains operable. I say again that what is being done is simply to ensure operability, whenever the trigger time is.
We will continue to act on the advice of SNH and the Joint Nature Conservation Committee when we do designations, and we will follow the criteria that are provided by the European habitats directive, notwithstanding Brexit. We are simply replacing the function that is currently provided by the European Commission at the next-to-last stage of the process. This is literally just about fixing the technical bit that needs to be fixed to make the process operable immediately upon not just a no-deal Brexit, but any Brexit.
How do you see the European Commission’s function in scrutinising reports that are submitted under the habitats regulations being replaced following our exit from the EU?
We have already spoken a little bit about that: it is to do with the reporting duties that I mentioned earlier. The reporting requirements are intended, as a minimum, to reflect those that are set out in article 17 of the habitats directive and article 12 of the wild birds directive.
We will report publicly on implementation of the regulations within six years from the date of exit from the EU and every six years thereafter. We do not think that it is appropriate to set out the format in the regulations because that would introduce a counterproductive degree of restriction.
In effect, we have observed the format for EU reporting. We are lifting what we do and putting it into the regulations to ensure that we can continue to do it after the trigger point of Brexit.
In the absence of EU reporting, how will the Scottish Government and SNH approach assessing biodiversity trends in Scotland and comparing them with the rest of Europe?
We will continue to take advice on this. The reporting requirements are closely aligned. The UK as a whole will continue to report in a similar way to how it reports now. It is a contracting party to the Bern convention and it is worth remembering that there are other international conventions that apply to a lot of the work that we do on the environment and which are not reliant on the EU connection, on which there has been a focus. At the point of Brexit, the UK will continue to contribute to the Bern convention Emerald network. The reporting requirements are closely aligned, so comparison with published EU reports will still be possible.
We are not in the middle of doing something that might be affected by Brexit, if that is what you mean. There is nothing that can run at cross-purposes.
We are fully aligned. Nothing new is being suggested that looks as though it would give us an issue. If Brexit does not happen for another 21 months or two years or whatever, I cannot speak for the position at that point. I can speak only about the position now.
This is preparation for a no-deal Brexit. We are having to do it on this timescale to make sure that we are in a solid place for 29 March. Right now, nothing is waiting and I am not aware of anything on the horizon that might fall into that category. Of course, I cannot rule out the possibility that if Brexit is delayed considerably, something might emerge, but we are committed to doing the work that is necessary.
With the greatest of respect, officials are probably quite busy just getting all this done. Guidance will be published when the SSI comes into effect. It will not be published in advance. This instrument will not happen unless Brexit happens, so there is no separate publication schedule for the guidance.
In the longer term, we will review and update existing Scottish guidance but the guidance that goes along with this particular instrument will be published when the instrument comes into force and I have no idea when that might be.
That is a useful clarification. I have one more question about the introduction of a proportionality test into the regulations, in relation to how sites are managed, not designated. That seems to be quite a significant divergence from what is currently in the habitats directive. I understand that it is aligned with what DEFRA wants to do, but I think that it raises significant concerns around the appropriateness of management actions on protected sites and whether we could end up downgrading some of that much-needed management work.
We are not going to introduce the possibility of permitting activity in protected sites that would otherwise not be allowed. The use of the term “proportionate” is intended to reflect the relative importance of habitats and species within the UK on an international scale. It is clearly defined in the regulations, which say:
“‘proportionate’ means proportionate to the relative importance of—
(a) the part of the natural range lying in the United Kingdom’s territory; and
(b) the part of the natural range lying outside the United Kingdom’s territory”.
The EU general principle of proportionality is not invoked in that context. It is in effect about protecting habitats and species that are of international importance and significance in the UK.
Steven, does this relate to the Scottish Crossbill?
I am still not clear why there is a divergence between what is in the habitats directive and what is in this instrument. It is bringing in a proportionality test in relation to management. I am sorry, but your answer does not make it clear what that means.
There are things across the EU that are of great significance that might not be habitat issues for the UK at all. If we simply bring over the whole management process, without some reference to that reality, we run the risk of disproportionately applying rules to things that are not really the issues that we need to be concerned about. There are habitats directive and wild birds directive issues that are regarded in the same way on an EU-wide basis, because we are working on an EU-wide basis at the moment. However, we will not be operating on that EU-wide basis any more, so we have to ensure that we can give proportionate importance to the habitats directive and wild birds directive issues that relate to the UK and not to the rest of the EU.
Can you give an example of where that might apply and where we might want a separate approach to proportionality in relation to a certain species, compared to another one? The provision is quite a broad, catch-all one to put into legislation.
Favourable conservation status is an EU-wide concept that is managed at an EU level on a biogeographic scale—we are in the Atlantic biogeographic region. If you remove Scotland and the UK from that process but still want to uphold that, you have to define something that works in comparison to what the habitats directive currently says. The habitats directive requires member states to make a proportionate contribution to the Natura network, based on habitats and species that are found within their territory and are listed in the directive. The drafting of the principle that we are discussing tries to replicate the spirit of that provision in the directive. It is not about managing individual sites; it is about adapting the network as a whole to ensure that it is protecting an appropriate range and proportion of each habitat and species that are found in Scotland and the UK.
What you are describing concerns designation, whereas the provision that I am asking about concerns management. Those are two different things. If something is designated, how you apply management proportionately is a different question to that of whether you would proportionately designate a species based on its range, biogeography and everything else that you discuss. Why is the principle being applied to management rather than designation?
It is not being applied to management; it is being applied to the adaptation of the network in the future. The provisions for the management of sites are in regulation 48 of the original 1994 regulations and transpose article 6 of the habitats directive. The article 6 provisions in the habitats directive require you to take appropriate steps to ensure that sites are managed properly.
We have not changed regulation 48 at all; it still stands, for each and every site that we have in what is currently the Natura network. That provision will apply if we adapt the network to include further sites in the future using the new adaptation provision.
We will seek advice; there is not an intention not to do so. Any amendments will be made on the basis of scientific advice from nature conservation advisers. The power taken is necessary to account for possible future technical and scientific progress, but we would always seek advice. Amendments would probably be prompted by scientific advice rather than the other way round. We can issue guidance in the future to clarify how that advice will be formally taken. Obviously, we will work with the other UK Administrations to ensure consistency across the UK, and any amendments would be subject to the affirmative procedure. There is every intention to take advice.
One would not doubt your motives at all, cabinet secretary, but things might be clearer if there was a specific requirement in place in the legislation.
The directive does not have that, either. We need to remember that all that we are doing is transposing what exists; we are not creating new things over and above that.
Can you foresee circumstances in which the Scottish ministers would amend the schedules or annexes to the birds or habitats directives in a different way from the rest of the UK? Would that fall under a common framework, given that the regulations create a “UK site network”?
Sure. The committee has taken evidence for over an hour on something that we are doing that is different from what the rest of the UK does. In fairness, Michael Gove also had to consider the possibility of the reintroduction of lynx on an English basis, which he was entitled to do. The possibility of that kind of decision making is contained within the devolution of environment powers as is.
There might be some divergence. Indeed, there is divergence, because we are in the process of reintroducing beavers formally. That has already arisen—it is nothing unusual. I would not expect there to be massive divergence. The odd thing will arise out of the specific circumstances that exist in Scotland. Obviously, we are retaining all our current environment powers, but there is an existing UK biodiversity framework in place. Currently, there are discussions at the official level about how we can set up an agreement across the four Administrations to ensure that things are managed properly at that more general level. However, I cannot rule things out, given that the committee has just gone through a whole session on a divergence.
To be clear, there is latitude for divergence under a common framework, notwithstanding the fact that the regulations create a “UK site network”. You have just given us an example of that.
Yes. It is recognised that there is devolution of powers. That has always been the case. The situation with the beavers is under the current set-up, not the future one. There is nothing new about the situation.
Terminologically, the Scottish regulations use the term “‘UK site network” essentially to replace references to Natura 2000, but the UK regulations use the term “national site network”. The Green Alliance has suggested that we should have a shared description, which would be “international site network”. Do you have any views on that? It is a comparatively modest point.
The definitions are the same, so it is the terminology that is in question. Nobody would be surprised to discover that the England and Wales terminology of “national site network” would cause a bit of confusion for Scotland. Indeed, I wonder whether Wales is content with a “national site network” that covers both sides of the England-Wales border. We thought that, to avoid there being an issue about the use of “national” in the UK context, we would simply use the designation “UK site network”, to make it clearer. As I said, the definitions are exactly the same.
By the same token, are there any issues for the powers of the Scottish ministers deriving from the UK regulations? I realise that that is not directly related to today’s discussion, but it is an adjunct to it.
I think that the answer to that is no. The UK regulations create no new powers that apply in Scotland—they have not crossed a line on any of that. The UK Government is doing what it is doing, which is the equivalent exercise to what we are doing here.
In that case, we move on to the third item on the agenda, which is consideration of motion S5M-16057.
Motion moved,
That the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee recommends that the Conservation (Natural Habitats, &c.) (EU Exit) (Scotland) (Amendment) Regulations 2019 draft be approved.—Roseanna Cunningham
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.