I thank all members who signed the motion and allowed it to be debated, and my staff for their assistance with the event today.
For the past seven years, I have been campaigning alongside women who have been victims of the debilitating impact of mesh implants—women who have seen their careers end and their relationships break down, who have lost their ability to walk, who are forced to use wheelchairs, who have lost organs and who live in constant, chronic pain that affects every aspect of their lives. Some of those remarkable women are in the gallery tonight, and I salute their determination to be here today. [Applause.] All through the campaign, they have acted in the interests of others. They have tried to get mesh banned so that no other woman would suffer as they have suffered. There was no real hope, however, of any improvement for them—but there is now, and they are rightly calling for action.
Many of those women have asked their general practitioner or their consultant for help. When they do, they can be referred to consultant urogynaecologists based in Glasgow and Edinburgh at what have been described as Scotland’s mesh “centres of excellence”. Those centres, however, are often staffed by the very surgeons who implanted the mesh in the first place and who may be subject to litigation by the same patient. Therefore, they will not operate.
Women who are accepted for remedial surgery want and expect full mesh removal, and many have been told that that is what they will get. However, the reality is that, despite today’s press release from the Scottish Government, full mesh removal is not available in Scotland. Instead, mesh that is accessible to the surgeon when they operate is removed, with the rest left inside the body. I repeat to the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport that full mesh removal is not available in Scotland.
Unlike in the rest of the United Kingdom, surgeons in Scotland favoured the type of mesh implant that has caused the most crippling of injuries because of where it was placed and the fact that it is so much bigger.
In the United States, Dr Dionysios Veronikis has developed new techniques and specialist medical instruments that allow him to carry out successful full mesh removal. His pioneering methods, developed over a decade, mean that the entire mesh implant is removed carefully and in one piece. He then photographs the mesh and measures it to ensure that it corresponds with the medical record of what was put in. He does that so that he can confirm by photograph that the entire piece has been removed.
Previously, the Scottish national health service sent patients to see Dr Elneil at the University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. Dr Elneil carries out full mesh removal, but her list is closed and she has a huge backlog. Right now, we have a small window of opportunity to act—an opportunity that, if we do not take it, will be lost. That opportunity is the genuine offer from Dr Veronikis to come to Scotland to work up to six days a week to carry out full mesh removal procedures, and, critically, to train Scottish surgeons in his techniques. That is a serious and genuine offer that I urge the cabinet secretary to take up.
In correspondence with me, the cabinet secretary has rightly said that Dr Veronikis must be “of appropriate professional standing” and
“recognised by the General Medical Council”.
I am sure that none of us would disagree with that sentiment. It can be done. Dr Veronikis is a leading international expert in his field. Many surgeons want to learn from him, including Christopher Harding, who is one of the chairs of the British Association of Urological Surgeons and one of the UK’s top specialists.
Dr Veronikis has specialised in obstetrics and gynaecology since 2000 and female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery since 2013. He was awarded the distinguished surgeon award by the US Society of Gynecologic Surgeons in 2018 and he has a hugely impressive CV. He could quickly be registered as what the GMC calls a “visiting eminent specialist”, which would mean that he could complete the GMC registration process. Therefore, registration is not a barrier to his coming here.
The national health service would then need to cover his costs and provide an operating theatre for him to work in. It is my opinion that that could be financed by using some of the additional £27 million that the cabinet secretary recently allocated to waiting times reduction; after all, mesh survivors have been waiting not weeks but years for such treatment. These are exceptional circumstances that require an exceptional response.
If members are wondering what such an action would deliver, they need look no further than the Parliament’s public gallery, because Dr Mary McLaughlin, a law lecturer from Ireland, is here. She has flown over because she wanted to be here to prove the impact of the full mesh removal that Dr Veronikis carries out. On 14 January, she paid £15,000 out of her own savings to go to the US for surgery. She had all 28cm of the mesh that had been implanted removed from her body. Within a few days, she had much more mobility and, within a few weeks, she was walking again. Today, she is so free of pain and suffering that she has travelled to Edinburgh as living proof of what the procedure can mean.
Let us compare that to Mary’s previous condition: she was unable to carry on with her job and was virtually bedridden; indeed, she was in so much chronic pain that she could not even sit to enjoy Christmas dinner with her family. Just two months after her surgery with Dr Veronikis, she is well enough to travel here to be with us today. Her situation contrasts with that of Lorna Farrell, who is also in the gallery, Claire Daisley from Greenock and the many others who have ended up in even more pain and in wheelchairs following so-called full mesh removal in Scotland. They still have mesh inside them, despite being told that they would have full mesh removal. There are others who have been told that the mesh implant that they were given cannot be fully removed here. The reality is that Dr Veronikis can do it and he is offering to come to Scotland to train our surgeons in how to do it.
The decision whether to take up that offer lies with the cabinet secretary and no one else. I never beg Government ministers, but I implore the cabinet secretary to do the right thing and give these injured women the best treatment that is available. They have lost so much, and they should not have to travel to the US or elsewhere, as some are having to do. They are having to beg, borrow or steal, or to use their life savings, to buy treatment. The cabinet secretary has the opportunity to act and to change lives. She has the chance to do the right thing. The alternative is that the women we are talking about will be left living a life of pain and misery, with careers and relationships lost, and they will face a lifetime of medical costs. I believe that, collectively, those costs would far outstrip the cost of bringing Dr Veronikis to Scotland.
These women had the meshes implanted in Scotland. The recommendation for the procedure was made in Scotland. All they ask for is the realistic opportunity to have this dreadful material removed from them in Scotland. [Applause.]