Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Carer’s Allowance Up-rating (Scotland) Order 2019 [Draft]

Thursday 28 February 2019 Social Security Committee About 10:15–10:30 Subordinate legislation 15 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

We move to agenda item 3. I invite Ms Somerville to move motion S5M-15926.

Motion moved,

That the Social Security Committee recommends that the Carer’s Allowance Up-rating (Scotland) Order 2019 draft be approved.—Shirley-Anne Somerville

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

We now have the opportunity to have a debate. I appeal for it to be a short debate, given the time constraints that we are under. Does any member have comments to make?

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

As I indicated in my questions, this is such a momentous stage in the devolution of social security entitlement that the uprating method that will be used deserves wider discussion, wider consultation and wider debate before we make the decision.

Members will know that, when the committee scrutinised the Social Security (Scotland) Bill, it was concerned about the exact position that we find ourselves in—in which a take-it-or-leave-it instrument would come before the committee without having had a high level of consultation, scrutiny or debate, because of how the legislation is drafted and how reliant it is on regulations.

It transpires that we are now in that position. We are making a momentous decision—it is a key milestone in the progress to full devolution of the social security entitlements—but, without yesterday’s debate, it would be done with almost no debate at all.

The Government and the cabinet secretary and her predecessors are on record as criticising the UK Government for exactly the policy that the cabinet secretary intends to implement. Regularly, ministers and members talk in the chamber about the almost £4 billion that has been cut from social security spending. The briefings that the cabinet secretary received when she assumed her position set out clearly that the coalition’s uprating policy of changing from the RPI to the CPI would cost recipients of social security in Scotland £1.9 billion up to 2021, yet we continue with the CPI, with almost no debate, in the absence of the issue being brought to the chamber yesterday. If the UK Government had continued with the RPI, carers would be almost £1,000 better off at this point.

For those reasons, I do not support the decision to uprate by the CPI. There has been a complete lack of debate and discussion and, given that this is such a huge decision, I am really concerned about the precedent that will be set.

Keith Brown SNP Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

I am happy to support the motion. If the issue was hugely significant, as has just been suggested, an amendment to the budget should have been lodged. No amendment was proposed, so that level of significance was not attached to the issue at that time.

People seem quite happy to see a cumulative cut of more than £2 billion to the Scottish Government’s budget—there have been no RPI increases to that budget over the past nine years—and yet, once again, more is being asked of the Scottish Government than is being given to it to undertake what is being asked.

Over the past few weeks, we have seen many demands to increase funding for all sorts of things. There was a demand for the Scottish welfare fund to be increased, even though it was underspent. However, I have seen no suggestions about where that money should come from. It is hard to see the logic in that.

What has been said tries to take away from how much is being done for carers through the social security provisions in Scotland, which are a major step forward. If we managed to convince the Scottish Government to accede to a request to revert to the RPI and then Brexit had a major impact on the housing market, would we be here next year to demand a return to the CPI to protect carers? For those reasons, I am more than happy to support the motion.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I have some sympathy with Mark Griffin’s worries about a tick-box exercise—I get his point. The issue is fundamentally complicated because the RPI has been found to be flawed. There have been a lot of calls for it to be fixed, although those calls have been resisted.

The debate is about two things. It is about whether we should debate and look at how we uprate—I totally agree that we should do that, which is why we asked for and got a welcome guarantee from the cabinet secretary yesterday that the method will be looked at consistently as we go along. That is important.

10:30

The RPI could be fixed and the flaws corrected, although, ironically, the flaws are to do with clothing price estimates and not housing, so some of the discussion is slightly offbeat, given what the problems actually are. However, it would be irresponsible for the Government to suggest that we should use a flawed measurement as a starting point for the new system. For that reason, I support the Government’s position, but it is important that we keep on reviewing that.

I doubt whether the RPI will be fixed any time soon, because it is linked to the gilt market, and there would be significant effects on that. The last gilt will expire in something like 2066, so I suspect that we will have to wait quite a long time for anybody to be willing to fix the RPI.

It is members’ responsibility to have the appropriate depth of understanding when we debate a subject. I would never call for us to use a statistically flawed method of uprating. That would be irresponsible, and it is for that reason that I support what the Government is doing.

It is beholden on us as a committee and individually to bring the appropriate depth of understanding to debates. We might not like what is proposed and we might see other issues that will be caused by it, but it is incumbent on us to understand that we need to call and press for fixes to be made or to find an alternative. We need to look at the thing in the round.

I heard what Mark Griffin said about cliff edges and so on, but that is a different issue from uprating. We should not conflate the two issues. We need to look at them separately and figure out how we can do the best for our carers along the way. For that reason, I will support the Government’s position, but I empathise with Mark Griffin and see where he is coming from.

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow
link

I thank the cabinet secretary for answering our questions straightforwardly, although I do not agree with everything that has been said.

I have always recognised the importance of the work that the Scottish Government has done on introducing the supplement. I hope that that goes without saying. Through the bill amendment process, the committee and the Government were clear that there should be an annual uprating mechanism and, as Mark Griffin said, it is healthy to debate what uprating mechanism we should use to reflect the effects of inflation on people’s living costs.

There is huge distrust of use of the CPI, which the UK Government adopted in 2010, and that distrust goes wider than members of the committee, as it is also expressed by a number of third sector organisations. We need to take that into account.

I see this not as a budget issue but as a matter of principle. We may have a difference of opinion, but I want us to adopt a measure that truly reflects people’s costs, and people’s housing costs are an essential element in the calculation. I am also concerned about the earnings issue. I noted what the cabinet secretary said about the things that she has to weigh up in relation to the agency agreement, but it distresses me deeply that, although we do not know the numbers, some carers will lose all of their entitlement because of the lack of flexibility.

I welcome the fact that we will have future discussions on the subject and I note that the cabinet secretary said that she is content that the proposed approach is correct, but I hope that she will keep an open mind. No one would want to support a statistically flawed process but, for today’s purposes, use of the CPI is the wrong approach and I do not support it.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Time is against us. I call Jeremy Balfour, to be followed by Alison Johnstone.

Jeremy Balfour Con Lothian
link

I, too, welcomed Mark Griffin’s debate, because there is an issue here. I support the Scottish Government’s position, but the committee will need to have dialogue with the Government on how future regulations are considered. As Mark Griffin said, one of our concerns when the bill was going through was that we were leaving a lot to regulation, and there is a danger in that approach. We might like only 75 per cent of what is proposed, but we cannot amend it.

Other regulations will come forward, so we need to find a mechanism to allow them to be debated without our having to vote just yes or no at the end of the process. We have had a bit of discussion about using third parties to do that. It is important that we do not end up in a situation where we like a lot that is in the regulations but, because of one or two things, we have to vote against them. The committee needs to think and have a dialogue about how we deal with that in a way that is open and provides scrutiny but does not delay decisions.

Alison Johnstone Green Lothian
link

It is widely recognised that the Greens support the use of the RPI rather than the CPI in this situation, but I understand that, at the moment, the Scottish Government is locked into uprating at the CPI rate, as the UK Government is doing. I am not sure that there is an alternative to the agency agreement. The situation is difficult, and we are in an unsatisfactory situation this morning, as has been expressed fairly widely by members. For those reasons, I will abstain in the vote on the motion.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Thank you for making your position clear.

As no other members want to comment, I will make a few remarks before the cabinet secretary sums up. I take seriously my role as convener in scrutinising the Scottish Government’s work on the delivery of social security. I hope that that was clear from the extensive questioning that I allowed Mr Griffin, given his specific interest in the issue.

I am sympathetic to an evidence-led methodical approach to considering what measures should be used to uprate thresholds and levels for benefits and entitlements. If the committee wishes to carry out work on that, we absolutely should do it. However, the details of the uprating of carers allowance and carers allowance supplement were provided to the committee on 12 December 2018, some 11 weeks ago, and it was not until the past couple of days that particular issues were raised.

I read the cabinet secretary’s letter when we received it, including the section on “Uprating in future years”, which clearly states that, when we move from carers allowance to carers assistance and the Scottish Government and Social Security Scotland take control of the benefit, the Scottish Commission on Social Security will have a statutory role. That seems an absolutely appropriate time for the committee to have a substantial look at the level of benefits and how they are uprated. That is the appropriate way for the committee to do our business, particularly given that we have had that information from the Scottish Government for the past 11 weeks.

The situation is disappointing, given that we are considering an investment of an additional £37 million that will go into the hands and pockets of carers, who do an amazing job. If we want to talk about the level of benefit, let us have that discussion, but that should be at budget time, when we can consider the consequences of any financial asks to the Government from back benchers or Opposition parties.

The figure that we have been given is that using the RPI would put an additional £3 million into the pockets of carers. If we are going to have a political discussion about how best to put £3 million into carers’ pockets, let us have a frank discussion about where that money comes from and the best way to spend it. Is that through changing the uprating mechanism, extending the young carers grant or looking at respite care for carers? We could consider a wider package to improve the lot of carers.

The committee absolutely has to continue to scrutinise without fear or favour in relation to the level of benefits and how they are uprated but, in my opinion, opposing an affirmative instrument when that opposition would, if successful, in effect mean less money and not more money for carers is an irresponsible way of doing business.

Ironically, I commend Mark Griffin for raising the wider issue. There are underlying discussions to be had in areas of scrutiny that our committee should engage with.

Others have had the opportunity to say where they stand in relation to the debate; that was my opportunity to put my thoughts on the record. It has been a high-quality debate and the cabinet secretary now has the opportunity to sum up.

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

Thank you, convener; I appreciate that opportunity. As some members have pointed out, the first time that I raised the matter formally with the committee was in the letter that I sent in December 2018, which set out in detail what we proposed for the carers allowance and the carers allowance supplement. There has been some time for the committee to reflect on that, and I would have been happy to provide further evidence or to appear before the committee earlier, had a request been made to have that wider debate. I am, of course, more than happy to do that in the future.

The debate has been informative not just on the instrument that we are looking at but on the wider points that Jeremy Balfour and others raised about how we deal with regulations as we move forward with social security. The letter of December 2018 was my first opportunity to make clear my direction of travel on the issue, but I am mindful that more might need to be done to ensure that the committee is aware of the issues and has opportunities to engage with them.

I hope that Mr Balfour and others are reassured that section 77 of the 2018 act requires me to report to Parliament, to discuss the issues and to be held accountable for them. As the convener pointed out, the draft regulations will go to the commission for independent scrutiny and they will be available for the committee and wider stakeholders to take a view on and require further evidence about. I will be more than happy to take part in any deliberations at that point.

I am mindful of the points that have been raised today and of the fact that people still have concerns about what we have chosen as a measure of inflation. As I said yesterday, I am happy to hear those discussions as we move forward. I will look seriously at and reflect on the wider point about how we deal with regulations under the 2018 act. I am available to the committee at any point should further questions be raised on that issue.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Thank you, cabinet secretary. That concludes the debate.

The question is, that motion S5M-15926, in the name of Shirley-Anne Somerville, be agreed to. Are we agreed?

Members: No.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

There will be a division.

For

Allan, Dr Alasdair (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) (SNP)

Balfour, Jeremy (Lothian) (Con)

Ballantyne, Michelle (South Scotland) (Con)

Brown, Keith (Clackmannanshire and Dunblane) (SNP)

Doris, Bob (Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn) (SNP)

Robison, Shona (Dundee City East) (SNP)

Against

Griffin, Mark (Central Scotland) (Lab)

McNeill, Pauline (Glasgow) (Lab)

Abstentions

Johnstone, Alison (Lothian) (Green)

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

The result of the division is: For 6, Against 2, Abstentions 1.

Motion agreed to,

That the Social Security Committee recommends that the Carer’s Allowance Up-rating (Scotland) Order 2019 draft be approved.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I thank the cabinet secretary for coming.

10:43 Meeting suspended.

10:46 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:45 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
  3. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 15
  4. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. 10:30 Social Security Scotland Evidence session · 79

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.