To ask the Scottish Government whether children in Glasgow must demonstrate greater needs than those in other parts of Scotland in order to gain access to an additional support for learning school. (S5O-02639)
Official Report · Chamber
Additional Support for Learning (Glasgow)
Portfolio Question Time Education and Skills
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 3
- John Mason SNP 2
- Liz Smith Con 1
The record
6 contributions
Children and young people should learn in the environment that best suits their needs. The legislation places a duty on local authorities to provide education in a mainstream school unless specific exceptions apply. In summary, those include: the education provided in a mainstream school would not be suitable for the aptitude and abilities of the child in question; mainstream education would be incompatible with the provision of efficient education for other children; and placing the child in a mainstream school would incur unreasonable levels of public expenditure. That applies across the whole of Scotland.
I thank the cabinet secretary for that reply. However, it appears to be easier for families in richer council areas, and for families who are perhaps better off and more self-confident, to argue their corner and to get their child into a special school.
The conditions and criteria that I set out in my original answer to Mr Mason apply across the country and are specified in statute. It is up to individual local authorities to make judgments, based on those conditions, on whether the educational needs of young people are being met. That should be the basis on which decision making is undertaken.
There are opportunities for parents, when they are dissatisfied with a local authority’s decision making, to pursue those issues through the tribunal process. I would encourage local authorities and parents to try to resolve these issues, but I accept that in some cases it is necessary for them to be resolved at tribunal, when all sides of the debate on the appropriate educational setting for a young person can be heard and resolved.
I put on record my personal thanks for the efforts that the cabinet secretary is making to assist with the families involved in the recent closure of the New School Butterstone. In the light of that and the comments about additional support for learning across the country, will the cabinet secretary undertake to have a formal review of the resources that are available for specialist education?
I am grateful to Liz Smith for her comments about the New School Butterstone. About 23 young people, as well as staff, are affected by the closure of that school. I see reports daily from each affected local authority about the progress that is being made on finding appropriate educational settings for the young people. That review work goes on daily. Progress has been made in some cases, but not in all, and it will take time to find appropriate placements for the young people.
It is important that we keep under active review the options that are available for the placing of young people outside mainstream education. Fundamentally, the law is clear—we should encourage mainstreaming. However, there are exceptions, which are specified in the Standards in Scotland’s Schools etc Act 2000. In consultation with local authorities, I want to maintain an overview of the provision that is available, to make sure that there are options available to meet the needs of young people in such circumstances.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 5 Dec 2018 →- Additional Support for Learning (Glasgow) Questions · 6
- Mental Health (Schoolchildren) Questions · 6
- Developing the Young Workforce Questions · 7
- National Standardised Assessments (Primary 1 Pupils) Questions · 11
- Probationer Teachers Questions · 6
- Castlebrae High School Questions · 4
- Young People with Autism (Educational Provision) Questions · 6
- Teacher Recruitment Questions · 6
- Funded Childcare (Nurseries) Questions · 11
- Modern Apprenticeships (Stirling) Questions · 4
- Primary Schools (Rebuilding) Questions · 5
- Apprenticeship Levy (Additional Apprenticeships) Questions · 8
- Brexit (Universities and Colleges) Questions · 4
- School Finances (North East Fife) Questions · 4
- Veterans (Skills Development Scotland) Questions · 4
- European Union Withdrawal Agreement and Political Declaration Debate · 144
- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
- Remembering Conscientious Objectors Members’ business · 24
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.