I am saddened that we are having the debate—first, because we should not need it, and secondly, because the issue should have been dealt with in September when I first called on the First Minister to hold an independent inquiry. I thank members from opposing parties who signed the motion that is in my name—particularly David Stewart, Rhoda Grant, Monica Lennon, Liam McArthur, Alex Cole-Hamilton and John Finnie. No Scottish National Party MSP supported it, but I am confident that SNP members believe, as I do, that there should be zero tolerance of bullying.
I welcome those who have come from the Highlands to listen to the debate—they are up in the public gallery—and I thank them for all the work that they have done to bring the matter to the Parliament’s attention. I also welcome those who are following the debate live on the BBC. There is huge interest in the matter.
When I was elected in 2016, it was apparent that there were significant issues in NHS Highland—not just waiting times and poor financial performance but something else. I could not quite put my finger on it, but something made me feel uncomfortable, to be frank.
The way in which an organisation treats those it works with paints a good picture of the way in which it treats those who work for it. In 2016, the deep division between patients in Caithness and Skye and NHS Highland warned me that something was seriously amiss. The protesters felt ignored and felt that NHS Highland had shown them unbelievable arrogance, which is perhaps why more than 1,000 of them took to the streets in Caithness on a wet and windy afternoon in October 2017.
My concern grew further when doctors and nurses across the Highlands started to inform me of issues and pass on correspondence from NHS Highland. A trickle became a flood. The issues should have been addressed with senior management, but people felt unable to do that because of the response that they expected to receive. That attitude manifested itself at board level. The huge turnover of non-executive board members in the past five years should have been a flag to previous health secretaries, but it was not.
An even bigger, deafening klaxon should have sounded for the then health secretary when the non-executive board members passed a motion on 28 August 2017 that said:
“We feel the culture and leadership of the organisation is a risk to our stated values and objectives”.
That came from NHS Highland’s board. The motion was passed on to NHS Highland’s chair, who subsequently denied that he knew about it, and to the Scottish Government. The result was a governance review, which condemned NHS Highland’s executive management. I will quote from one paragraph of the review report, which John Brown produced—if members want to look it up, it is paragraph 4.30. It says:
“The Chair should consider externally facilitated support, such as mediation, to provide a safe and secure environment for Board members to meet with him and the Chief Executive to discuss recent concerns and for an agreed way forward to be found.”
One has to ask—what exactly was going on in the boardroom that made it an unsafe and insecure environment? Perhaps exactly what was going on elsewhere in NHS Highland.
On Friday, there was a meeting to discuss bullying, organised by the GMB and the whistleblowers. We heard stories of what was going on. I want to quote one—just one of the 100 plus that have been reported. This is from a lady:
“Each time it got worse and worse, crying and begging my husband before a shift not to make me go in, and crying when I returned home. My bullying in the work place got so bad that it affected my mental health. It was so bad that it affected not only me in work but my home life and my life with my kids.”
This is from a healthcare professional doing her job, and she is not the only one. I have heard about other harrowing cases from people who have contacted me directly. I have been so concerned that on one occasion, I contacted the office of the chief executive of NHS Scotland to seek help, as NHS Highland remained uncommunicative.
It does not stop there. There are patients across the Highlands who feel let down and unable to raise the issues they want to raise because of the unpleasant reaction that some have received when they have had the temerity to complain.
Everything that I have seen and heard has convinced me that there is a bullying culture in NHS Highland and it cannot be written off as gossip, as the chair of the board tried to do on 27 July this year. To me, it is evident at every level, from the boardroom to the floor of the wards. I see it in the way that NHS Highland works with its own staff, with its patients, and with those who dare to question service provision or management. On the latter point, I will just say: trust me, I know.
On Friday, the cabinet secretary announced an independent review into bullying in NHS Highland, which I welcome, but I am afraid that that is just the start. The review will need to look back to identify where the culture of bullying emanated from. John Sturrock will need to speak to staff, patients and board members, which will take time.
I hope that, during the course of this debate, the cabinet secretary can confirm who will be allowed to contribute to the review; that the review will look back at least 10 years; and that the review will cover what I would term the coercion of staff by the projection of authority, which I believe goes on the whole time.
When it comes to reporting, I hope that the cabinet secretary will confirm to me what “early 2019” means, because, sadly, time is a luxury we do not have. We have to address this issue that is festering and which I am told has been around for over 10 years. We need to do it for the sake of the staff, the patients and the victims in NHS Highland. Bullying has no place in any of our institutions and particularly not in NHS Highland.
17:12