Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Early Years Assistance (Best Start Grants) (Scotland) Regulations 2018 [Draft]

Thursday 4 October 2018 Social Security Committee About 09:00–09:45 Subordinate legislation 56 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

56 contributions
Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Agenda item 2 is subordinate legislation. The committee will take evidence on the draft Early Years Assistance (Best Start Grants) (Scotland) Regulations 2018, which are subject to the affirmative procedure. I welcome Shirley-Anne Somerville, the Cabinet Secretary for Social Security and Older People. I think that this is the first time that Ms Somerville has been at the committee, so I welcome her to her role. We look forward to working constructively with her in the months and years ahead. I also welcome the Scottish Government officials Dorothy Ogle, best start grant policy team lead, and Colin Brown, solicitor. Thank you for coming.

I invite the cabinet secretary to make an opening statement, after which we will move to questions.

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Social Security and Older People · Dunfermline
link

Thank you, convener. I am happy to be here to assist the committee in its consideration of the regulations. This is the first set of regulations under the Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018. They set out the rules for a new Scottish benefit and will allow Social Security Scotland to take applications and to process the best start pregnancy and baby grant. Assuming that the regulations are passed, alongside the tribunal regulations, we will be able to begin making payments by Christmas, which is well ahead of schedule. Given the failure of the Department for Work and Pensions to keep to schedule on its implementation plans, officials are now working through options to deal with the consequences and to ensure that our work remains on track.

The best start grants will be a form of early years assistance, which is provided for under section 32 and schedule 6 of the Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018. The grants will support lower income families with children by offering financial support at key transition points in the early years. The grants are intended to improve children’s wellbeing and, alongside other interventions in the early years, to provide the best start in life. When fully implemented, there will be three best start grants available and, in keeping with good practice, they will be implemented in stages, to ensure that we have a firm foundation before we move on to the next step.

The three payments are a pregnancy and baby payment of £600 for a first child and £300 for any subsequent child, which will help with expenses in pregnancy or of having a new child; an early learning payment of £250, which will help with costs of early learning at around the time a child may take up a nursery place, which will support child development; and a school-age payment of £250, which will help with the costs of preparing for primary school. The first pregnancy and baby payments will be made before Christmas 2018. The next stages—the early learning and school-age payments—will be introduced by summer 2019. Therefore, in due course there will be two additional schedules of regulations to provide for the early learning and school age grants. The current draft instrument will be amended to include schedules for all three grants.

The regulations that are being considered today provide detailed rules relating to the pregnancy and baby payment. They include provision for eligibility, including residence, the assistance that will be available, the value of the payments and when to apply. The regulations also include provision for timescales for the processing of redeterminations and certain issues of process relating to application dates.

The regulations have been developed with extensive consultation and user engagement. We provided illustrative regulations to the committee in September 2017, which was followed by a formal consultation running from 23 March to 15 June this year. As you know, the committee took evidence on draft regulations during the consultation period. I took that evidence and the consultation responses into account when making final decisions on best start grants, and I am pleased to be able to confirm two changes to the original policy.

To ensure that more kinship carers will be eligible, the tests for responsibility for a child include receipt of child tax credits, the child element of universal credit or child benefit for that child. Certain legal orders will also be taken as evidence. That means that the test now captures formal and informal kinship carers who have secured a DWP benefit for the child they care for or where there is a legal arrangement in place. If responsibility for a child changes during one of the application windows—for example, where a child moves from living with a parent to a kinship carer—a second payment can be made to the new carer.

For parents under 20, concerns were raised about the grandparent qualifying. In particular, those concerns were about the rights of the child, empowering young parents and the possibility that the young parent might not benefit from the money. In response to those concerns, and in keeping with the social security principles of dignity and respect, we are offering a choice for young parents. A young parent who is under 18 or who is 18 or 19 and still in full-time education or training can be the qualifying person, or the grandparent can be the responsible person and can qualify for the payment on that basis.

I hope that that is useful to the committee in their consideration and I am happy to take any questions.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Thank you very much, cabinet secretary. I have been reviewing some notes, and I have found that you were kind enough to write to me, as convener, on 11 September in relation to the BSGs and that, at the start of your letter, you said:

“As you know, as part of this year’s Programme for Government, we announced last week that we intend to bring forward the first payments of the Best Start Grant (BSG) Pregnancy and Baby Grant to 2018”.

However, the key bit, which you referred to in your opening statement, was that that is

“assuming DWP puts the required systems in place for us to do so.”

You mentioned that the first payments could be in people’s bank accounts before Christmas, which I welcome greatly, as Christmas is a financially straining time for any individual or family, never mind a low-income family with a new child in the household. That will create great expectation and anticipation among some people that the money could come just at the right time for them. I am therefore concerned about the caveat:

“assuming DWP puts the required systems in place for us to do so.”

Will you expand on that, as there is some concern about it?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

Certainly. There have been a number of concerns recently when we have been developing our work on the best start grant, because the DWP has changed its timeframes for a particular area of work that would in essence allow the social security agency to easily access information about applicants. Unfortunately, despite the fact that we began joint planning with the DWP in November 2017 and we had been working to an initial start date of around June 2018 for the agency having access to the customer information system, that will not now be the case. DWP has now informed us that there is a further delay to that work at its end.

However, officials and the agency are working on contingency measures to ensure that we continue with the approach that the First Minister set out in her statement on the programme for Government. We will still work towards payments being made in December 2018. That will be done because of the contingency arrangements within the agency and not because the DWP has completed its work to ensure that the agency can access the customer information system.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Is it an additional expense for the new agency to put in those contingency arrangements?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

It will mean that the process that a client adviser will have to go through to check eligibility with an applicant will be more time consuming and will require more manual input, which will obviously have an impact on the agency. The agency is looking to work through the implications of that contingency. However, it is important to stress that we will move as promised with our timetable to ensure that payments begin before the end of the year.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I imagine that that will have a notional cost somewhere down the line. When the Scottish Government or the agency liaises with the DWP in relation to such matters—they can get quite technical and I do not always understand them myself—does the DWP work in a collegiate way? Does it charge a fee for that interaction? What is the relationship?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

On a working level, the relationship between DWP officials, Scottish Government officials and agency officials is good. It is, after all, a joint process. We cannot deliver devolved social security without the DWP. However, there comes a time when, because of the overarching priorities in a very large department such as the DWP, there are implications for the timetables that it is working to and therefore the timetables for its work on devolved benefits will slip. That is exceptionally unfortunate. We try to mitigate that by speaking to the DWP as early as possible in our work so that it knows what we wish to achieve and in what timeframe. The relationship is good at official level, but we remain frustrated that, in practice, the priority that is given to the devolved benefits is sometimes not what I would like to see.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Does the DWP charge you for the privilege of getting that relevant information or does it liaise as a matter of course?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

We liaise with officials as a matter of course. If we require the DWP to make changes to its system, there is a cost to the DWP and there is a responsibility on us to meet that cost. There is a difference between our asking the DWP to make changes to the system and simple liaison between officials, which goes on as a matter of course.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I am probing the issue because I suspect that, with other benefits, that relationship will have to continue and endure and work will have to be delivered timeously to ensure that the Scottish social security agency can deliver Scottish Government priorities on target. I am disappointed if the suggestion is that the DWP does not see paying low-income mums much-needed money before Christmas as a priority. If you are suggesting that that is not one of its top priorities, that would certainly disappoint me. Have you previously experienced such delays?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

There is on-going exchange and dialogue between the agency, my officials and the DWP on the timing of all the work that we are doing on every benefit. Of course, there are sometimes changes and slippage in timetables. That is why we try to deal with that as early in a process as possible. My concern is that there have been continual slippages in the important work on accessing the customer information system and we have received the details of the latest slippage very late in the day and very close to the point at which we will go live with the project, as the DWP knows. That obviously has implications. The agency is working on contingency measures so that we can still deliver on time. Obviously, that will become more challenging the more complex the benefits are. We can do it with the initial best start grant payments, but it will be an on-going challenge to the agency to ensure that we have contingency plans in place if the DWP continues to change its timetables.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

That is helpful to know. This committee would be scrutinising the Scottish Government if targets were set and missed and payments were not made. You would have to come to the committee to explain why that is the situation. It is important that we get the wider picture in relation to the process. However, wrapped up in all that is a good news story: that the payments are still on track and will be made to some of the most vulnerable families in our constituencies, so I appreciate that information.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

On the back of those questions from the convener, will you say whether the DWP has offered any detailed explanation of the reasons for the delay? You have indicated that you do not feel that it has treated the issue as a priority, but have you been offered any detailed explanation as to its stance?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

It has not done so for the delay relating to the customer information system. The challenge is that, as the committee is well aware, the devolution of social security is but one aspect of what the DWP does. We are trying to link into an exceptionally complex DWP system that, to be polite about it, has its own challenges relating to other aspects of what the DWP does. We are not trying to link into a static system. It is constantly changing and therefore the DWP has other priorities in its work on information technology systems. The challenge is when those competing priorities, which may come about at a wider corporate DWP level, impact on what we are doing. I can certainly check, but I do not believe that we have been given a specific reason why this particular project has been delayed. It is but one project among a number of projects that the DWP is carrying out.

09:15

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

Will you say a bit more about what it means in practice to ensure that the payments are made by Christmas? How do you manage that situation to ensure that the payments are made? What do you have to do to make up for the deficit in the DWP’s activity?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

As I said to the convener, what the agency will have do will be more time consuming and labour intensive. Rather than access information on the screen direct from the DWP system, the agency will have to check in a different way and then manually input information into a system. That is obviously more time consuming and we will have to ensure that there are no errors in the manual inputting. It is obviously much easier if we can access the information and use it directly. However, I stress that the agency has been concerned for some time that there might be a delay, because there have been slippages. That is why a lot of work has been done behind the scenes on the contingency arrangements to ensure that agency staff are ready, trained and enabled to take them up. I give the committee the assurance that the agency has been working for some time on the contingency arrangements to ensure that they work and that staff are comfortable about delivering them in due course.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I take it from what you have said that you have registered your concerns about the situation at a political level. Have you had anything approaching a detailed response to those concerns or a political response?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

I raised my concerns directly with Esther McVey and David Mundell at the joint ministerial working group on welfare in, I think, September. I was in London for that meeting, and I stressed our concern that the issue would impact on our ability to deliver the project in the most efficient manner. The fact that the agency had contingency measures in place meant that our timetable was not under threat. Although those ministers noted my concern, they also noted that the agency had contingency measures in place and that we would be able to deliver the benefit. It is perhaps a concern that there was a reliance on the agency to work out how to deal with the delay, rather than an attempt to deal with the initial problem, which related to the DWP’s concerns.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

I agree that it is concerning that, in terms of relative priority, devolved benefits appear to be quite far down the list. It would be helpful to have regular updates on any delays that might impact on the further devolved benefits that are being rolled out in due course. It would helpful if the cabinet secretary were able to furnish us regularly with information about the impact of those delays.

For clarification, is it still your intention that eventually, once these issues are resolved, this is the information system that you would want to use and that these contingency measures are short term, or is the agency developing an alternative system that would potentially be used in the longer term?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

No, these contingency measures are very much intended to be for the short term. We do not know at present for how short a term. That is because we are waiting to see when access to the system will take place, so I do not have a definitive answer about how long the short term will be, but it is certainly very much our intention to progress to the system in the long term. It is far more effective and it is far better for client advisers to be able to access the information and therefore better for anybody phoning the helpline to get that information as timeously as possible.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

Once these issues are resolved and there is access to the information system, would the access roll forward for the other benefits or would there need to be another set of changes to the information system?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

One of our challenges is that we have to look continuously at what new information we require for every benefit. Once the agency has access to the system, it will be helpful on an on-going basis with the calls. That does not mean that there will not be other challenges when we are moving towards other payments, and we will require assistance from the DWP to be able to link into other parts of the system.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

It would be helpful if you could let us know once that access is gained and those issues are resolved.

Looking forward to the future relationship, I am aware that the Scottish Fiscal Commission wrote to the committee saying that it wanted to have a formal agreement with the DWP, as it does with Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs. There was some support for that. I do not know whether a formal agreement would have helped to resolve any of those issues—possibly not—but do you think that that is something that is important? What does the DWP think about that? Has it responded? Would it help to avoid these things happening in future?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

It would not have helped with this issue, because this particular issue is a delay to a DWP IT system change, which is solely to do with the DWP and its IT systems.

I have a great deal of sympathy with what the Scottish Fiscal Commission has said about the need for it to have access to information. I note that the Scottish Fiscal Commission has that agreement with HMRC, with which it seems to have a good working relationship. I have written to the secretary of state about the issue, giving my support to the SFC. I have yet to receive a reply to that letter, which was sent only on 19 September, I think. However, I think that it is important that a memorandum of understanding is in place with the DWP to allow the SFC to be able to access the information that it needs, which will also have implications for its advice to Government.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

So, it is about the flow of information and the technical detail. That is helpful.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

I have a few questions that cover a couple of different areas. The first question continues the discussion that we have been having.

Cabinet secretary, you spoke about the burden on the agency as a result of the failure of the DWP to give access to the information system. Is that going to cause any difficulty for applicants? The way I see it—correct me if I am wrong—is that if you had access to the DWP system, you would be able to check an applicant’s entitlement automatically. Is the absence of access to the system going to require an applicant to give proof of an entitlement during that process and put an extra burden on them?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

I can assure the committee that there will be no difference to what an applicant sees or experiences during the process. This is purely about what happens behind the scenes when we are looking at an application. The applicant will have the same assistance, the same support and the same reassurance that they would get from the agency whether that access had been in place or not. The basis of the contingency measures was very much that what we put in place will mean that the applicant’s experience will be the same.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

Will you be able to check their eligibility without them having to provide any extra information?

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

That is great. My next question is a more technical question specifically on the order concerning the multiple pregnancy supplement. The order says:

“The supplement is to be added to the grant in respect of only one of the children born, or to be born.”

I am looking for an assurance that the multiple pregnancy supplement would cover not just a twin birth but also a triplet birth or anything beyond that, and that there would be a £300 supplement for every additional child that is born.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

That is great. Thank you very much for that assurance.

My other questions are around the timing of the introduction of the payments. Are you able to say why the pregnancy and baby payment is going start when you have set out, but the early learning and school age payments are being deferred until summer next year?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

Certainly. As the committee knows, our first priority around social security is safe and secure transition to what we do, through a staged implementation. That is what we did for the carer’s allowance supplement, when we batched payments. For this benefit, the decision has been taken that we will start with one payment and then move forward with the second and third payments. The reason for that is that, although we are now paying the carer’s allowance supplement and the agency is very much up and running, experiencing calls and assisting, the situation with that benefit is entirely different because it involves the first application-based process. It is a different payment system. As with all other aspects, we will work through a staged and managed process to ensure that the applicants get the best possible experience.

Although there is always the wish to do things faster and to try to ensure that the payments are in as quickly as possible, I will not jeopardise our determined policy of doing things in a staged implementation manner so that we can learn lessons along the way, particularly when we are doing things for the first time.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

My final question is about uptake. What is the Government going to do to boost uptake of the payment, particularly after the discussion and debate that we had in the chamber on Tuesday about the particularly hard-to-reach groups, particularly black and minority ethnic communities?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

We will have to take a number of measures. There will be different measures for the different payments. With regard to best start grants, we are mindful of what has already happened and of the processes that are already in place to ensure that expectant mothers, for example, are encouraged to take up their entitlements. That is why there has been a great deal of work done with the health services, with midwifery in particular, and also with health visiting and family health partnerships to ensure that the health visiting pathway has information about best start grants, and that is a link with the financial health check that is part of this process.

With regard to the difficult-to-reach groups that you mentioned, when we go forward with the best start grants, we are also linking with a lot of different agencies and stakeholders to make sure that they are fully up to date with what is going on so that they can pass the information on. We are also looking at our communication strategy, which will ensure that we are getting the information out to stakeholders and directing it to individuals.

There is not just one stream of work. There will be road shows, for example, as there were for the carer’s allowance supplement. The communication strategy will have a specific eye on how we deal with individuals who may not even know that they are eligible or that there is a payment out there for them, and will encourage people to come forward. We are considering those things very carefully. There will obviously be lessons to learn, and I am more than happy to work with the committee on the lessons that we will learn about the uptake as we go forward.

Alison Johnstone Green Lothian
link

I will carry on from where my colleague Mark Griffin left off. The Scottish Fiscal Commission projects a 58 per cent take-up of the best start grant by 2022. I appreciate that means-tested benefits tend to have a lower take-up rate and that this figure would be an increase on the take-up of the sure start grant, but that still means that 42 per cent of families will be missing out. I appreciate the steps that you have outlined to Mark Griffin, but will the Government have a really good look at that figure? Are there actions being considered if it becomes apparent that that 58 per cent figure is not being reached and that take-up is not all that it needs to be?

09:30

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

This will be a learning process and it is not something that we say that we are going to get right from day 1. We are determined to do everything that we can, but there will inevitably be lessons to be learned around take-up. The numbers that the Scottish Fiscal Commission gave on take-up were lower than those of the Scottish Government’s forecast. We had been forecasting a higher take-up, and that was based on the work that we know will be done to encourage people to come forward to get the payments. It is very difficult to forecast take-up of a new benefit under a new system, and that is why there is a difference between the forecasts from the Scottish Government and Scottish Fiscal Commission.

When it comes to the issue of uptake, anybody who is eligible for a payment but who does not take it up is one too many, so we have to understand the reasons for it and what we can do about it. It will be an iterative process and we are more than open to learning as we go. I would not be satisfied with the Scottish Fiscal Commission’s figures, if that is what we reached. We must ensure that we are continuously doing all that we can, particularly for the difficult-to-reach people who will not be coming forward for these payments in the first instance.

Alison Johnstone Green Lothian
link

Obviously it is a new payment and it is being delivered by a new agency, and I suppose that Social Security Scotland has yet to develop a real presence. People will have to become aware that that is where they need to go. It is not impossible that some people may think that they have to apply to the DWP for the best start grant. The Scottish Fiscal Commission raised that possibility last month in its work on projecting the costs.

Is there something in place to ensure that if someone approaches the DWP to apply for a best start grant, they will be signposted to the right place? The worst thing that could happen is that they go to the DWP and miss out because the DWP does not understand and does not have the information.

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

One of the things that we have to recognise is that because we have a system now in which the DWP still pays the majority of benefits in Scotland and Social Security Scotland delivers only 15 per cent, there will be individuals who are not quite sure where payments are paid from. There is a great deal of work being done on communications that the DWP will give out. The agency also gives out information about reserved benefits, which comes from the DWP. I give the example of what happened with the carer’s allowance supplement. Before that went live, there were very detailed discussions about what would happen if someone phoned up the DWP about the carer’s allowance supplement and what the DWP would say. That work will happen with the best start grant. We are absolutely determined that no one falls through the gap. It is not their responsibility to know what number to phone; it is our responsibility to get the information out to them.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I want to take us on to a slightly different issue. Schedule 2 of the regulations is on the pregnancy and baby grant, and paragraph 4(1) of part 1 of schedule 2, which is on the residence requirement, states:

“The residence requirement referred to in paragraph 1(c) is satisfied by an individual on a day if, on that day—

(a) the individual is ordinarily resident in Scotland”.

Paragraph 4(2) goes on to list all the other elements of eligibility, starting with the individual being

“(a) habitually resident in the European Economic Area or Switzerland”.

What does that mean in terms of entitlement? Does it mean that someone is eligible if they are in Scotland at the time of the birth or does it mean that they have to be here for a period of time?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

I will bring in one of my officials to go through the detail of the residency requirements, but I can explain the background. I go back to the point that I made to Alison Johnstone, which is that no one can be allowed to fall through the gaps. A concern about the residency requirement as it was initially laid out in some of the draft regulations was that there was the potential for someone to not be eligible for a sure start grant in England and not be eligible for the best start grant in Scotland because of the requirement to be resident in Scotland. The reason for the change is to ensure that no one falls through a gap and that if they are in Scotland and are eligible, the process is an easy one for them to go through.

Colin Brown Scottish Government
link

The reason for the requirement for someone to be habitually resident in the European Economic Area or Switzerland is to ensure compliance with the co-ordination arrangements that apply throughout the EEA and Switzerland, whereby nationals of those countries who move to another country within the area will have the same rights of access to social security in that other country while they are resident there. For most people, that condition works through the conditions of the passporting benefits—in most cases, people have to be in receipt of a passporting benefit. The specific provision here refers to the extension for people up to the age of 18 who are not in receipt of passporting benefits, but who will qualify by virtue of their age. It is to ensure that the regulations are compatible with current arrangements.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

The situation with the passporting benefit is quite clear. If someone is on such a benefit, they are entitled to the pregnancy and baby grant. When I first read the provision, it seemed to be saying that if someone happened to be in Scotland at the time that they gave birth—if they were passing through or were on holiday or whatever—they would be entitled to the grant. Is that not correct?

Colin Brown Scottish Government
link

It is saying more than that. The person would have to establish that, for the time being, their ordinary residence was in Scotland. Scotland would have to be the centre of their living arrangements at that time. An example might be someone who comes here to study and who is going to be in Scotland for a period of time. They might still have some form of habitual residence in a different country, which they intend to go back to, but at the time they are residing in Scotland, which is more than simply being here on a day. If that were the case, they would qualify on the same basis as somebody who was habitually resident in Scotland.

Jeremy Balfour Con Lothian
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. On a positive note, I would like to thank you and your officials for the changes that you have made, which I think came out of our previous session. The changes strengthen the regulations and give greater protection, particularly to children who are very vulnerable and might be moving between different grandparents or parents. In that respect, they are extremely helpful.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Cabinet secretary, do you wish to respond?

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I am glad about the fact that we are having a love-in this morning.

I want to ask a bit more about uptake. When the committee visited Social Security Scotland on Monday, we found that staff had to do a couple of quite specific things with regard to uptake of the carers supplement. In writing to people, they decided to use white envelopes rather than brown ones, because many people who might benefit from the supplement were likely to view a brown envelope negatively, thinking that it might contain a bill or a negative piece of correspondence from an official organisation that wanted to pursue them for money rather than support them. Another thing that the staff had to do was reassure a lot of people on the telephone that it was not a scam, because they thought that it was too good to be true, wondered what the catch was and thought that it could not be right. We heard that when we visited the agency.

I do not underestimate the challenges that will be faced as regards uptake when the best start grant rolls out. Many of us could not get our heads round—this came up strongly in the debate, too—the relatively low uptake of the previous sure start grant. We know that, when people are expecting a baby, there is engagement with midwives, maternity services and the national health service, and there are antenatal classes. A suite of statutory services kicks in and the DWP pretty much knows which individuals have qualifying passporting benefits that would ensure entitlement to the sure start grant.

As a politician rather than someone who has to deliver the service on the ground, for the life of me, I cannot see why those dots are not joined together better. We know who is having a child, we know which benefits would enable them to qualify for the sure start grant and we know where they stay. Why on earth has no one rattled at their door to tell them that they are qualified for it and to ask why they have not applied for it? Surely there could be some kind of soft automatic enrolment.

That all sounds quite naive. I am sure that it is much more difficult to get one agency to talk to another agency about whose responsibility it is to deliver on the ground. However, given what I said about the carers supplement and having to use white envelopes and to persuade people that it was not a scam, although we know that it is challenging to reach hard-to-reach groups and there might be some people whom we do not know about, we know where most of the people who qualify for the best start grant are. What assurances can you give that there will be a much more co-ordinated approach to uptake on the ground than there was under the previous scheme?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

One of the main differences is that the DWP does not actively promote and encourage uptake of the benefit and the payments. That is a clear difference from what we will be doing. For example, through the work that we are doing with health visitors and the NHS, we are going out and promoting uptake.

That work links to on-going work that is separate from what I do in my remit on, for example, the financial health check guarantee, which will ensure that low-income families will receive personalised advice on income maximisation. There is also the healthier, wealthier children programme, which supports pregnant women and their families who are at risk of experiencing poverty by creating referral pathways between the NHS and money and welfare advice services. Between the work that the agency is doing to promote uptake of the best start grant and the work that is being done within Government to ensure that we are doing all that we can to provide financial health checks to low-income families, we will ensure that we have a better uptake than the DWP achieved. Time will tell whether the uptake is better enough. If there is one person out there who does not receive the benefit who could receive it, that would be a concern and we would need to challenge ourselves to see what more we could do.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

It would be good to get some more information about the work that is done on the ground, whether by the midwife at the 24-week pregnancy check or in antenatal classes. It would be good to get an overview of the provision on the ground to mop up access—although not today, obviously.

I say this again, because it was a theme that came through strongly when we visited the agency: people sometimes think that things are too good to be true. What do you think that the Scottish Government could consider doing nationally and locally to raise awareness and to notify and inform people—not just expectant mothers—of the range of benefits that Social Security Scotland will roll out? What could the Scottish Government do to let people know that the new benefits are being rolled out, that it is not a scam, that it is not too good to be true and that they are not handouts but things that people are entitled to? What could the Scottish Government do to drive up the uptake not just of the best start grant but other entitlements?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

You are right to point out that there is a challenge to do with the fact that the agency is new, which means that people will receive a letter from an agency that they might never have heard of in which they are offered money and told that it will go into their bank account. Yesterday, I visited our Glasgow offices, where I spoke to some of the staff who have been working on the initial conversations about the carers allowance supplement. Reactions such as “Is this real?”, “Is it a scam?” and “Is this letter legitimate?” came through. There is an obligation on us to raise awareness of the fact that the agency is in place and of the different benefits that are available.

I will give examples of what we did to improve knowledge of the carers allowance supplement. Roadshows were held, and there were adverts in local papers and on local radio stations. We did a lot of work with trusted organisations, because many people will go to a trusted organisation to check out what is going on and will believe what that organisation tells them over what they are told by a new agency that they have not previously heard of. The situation will develop over time, but the work that we did with Citizens Advice Scotland is the type of work that the agency is looking to do on the best start grant. As I said earlier, there will be a full communication strategy when the grant starts to be paid to ensure that we get publicity for what is going on.

09:45

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

I would like to ask about potential recovery of the best start grant. Most of the people who will be entitled to it will be entitled to it because they receive a qualifying benefit. If there is any error on the part of the claimant or perhaps by the DWP in notifying them of their entitlement to a qualifying benefit, with that decision subsequently being reversed, will the Scottish Government seek to recover payment of the best start grant?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP Dunfermline
link

It will depend on the circumstances of the case, but the agency would need to understand why DWP decided that a person whom it thought was eligible was no longer eligible and why that reserved benefit was not properly awarded. The agency will look at it on a case-by-case basis. There is also the issue of how we will look at any such case—that will be done with dignity and respect and on the basis of trust. It will not be up to the claimant to prove that they were doing nothing wrong, because we will believe that somebody is innocent unless, for example, they have done something specific such as commit fraud.

We will never act on the basis of trying to catch someone out, nor will we fail to be sympathetic to the position that an individual is in. I cannot give a categorical yes or no answer, because it will depend on the case. However, when the agency looks at any aspect of the process, it will look at what happened in that case with a degree of sympathy for and understanding of the circumstances of the individual case. I give that reassurance in relation to the work that the agency is doing on all such areas. It will not be done in such a way that it is assumed that a person has done something wrong and that, therefore, we will need to claw back money.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Thank you.

There being no other questions, we move to agenda item 3. I invite Ms Somerville to move motion S5M-14101.

Motion moved,

That the Social Security Committee recommends that the Early Years Assistance (Best Start Grants) (Scotland) Regulations 2018 draft be approved.—Shirley-Anne Somerville

Motion agreed to.

Bob Doris SNP The Convener · Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Thank you.

09:48 Meeting suspended.

09:50 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 56
  3. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.