This is a technical instrument that would, in short, remove two public bodies from the remit of the Commissioner for Ethical Standards in Public Life in Scotland. Members will know that the post of commissioner was initiated by Parliament and is independent of the Executive. That independence is a vital check on the Executive, irrespective of the party in power.
The consultation exercise for the Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards came up with an interesting result: of the nine responses, only two supported the move, while six were against. That does not strike me as an overwhelming vote of confidence in the proposal.
This issue is not about technical instruments alone. It is about a fundamental separation of powers and it is about checks and balances in our parliamentary system. I ask the cabinet secretary to confirm two quick points—first, that the new public health Scotland body, when it comes into being, will come under the remit of the commissioner; and, secondly, that the commissioner will still have an advisory role over any potential breach of standards by members of either of the public bodies that are referred to in the order. Subject to the cabinet secretary’s reply, I am minded to support the order.