Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Ferguson Marine

Topical Question Time

Tuesday 18 September 2018 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 15 contributions · 7 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Jamie Greene Con West Scotland
link

To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to reports that £45 million has been loaned to Ferguson Marine, and whether this is related to the provision of two new ferries being built under contract to Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd. (S5T-01217)

Derek Mackay SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work · Renfrewshire North and West
link

Scottish shipbuilding has a proud history and a bright future. That is why the Government will continue to support the industry to thrive and reach its full potential.

Earlier this year, I advised the Finance and Constitution Committee that ministers had approved commercial loan facilities of up to £45 million for Ferguson Marine. The loan facilities were reported to Audit Scotland, and the expenditure will be recorded in the Scottish Government’s consolidated accounts. The delayed delivery of the two new CalMac Ferries vessels is disappointing, but the commercial loan facilities that have been provided to Ferguson Marine will support the delivery of those vessels and help the business to diversify.

Jamie Greene Con West Scotland
link

Unfortunately, it took a number of freedom of information requests and press reports for the Government to come to the chamber and give Parliament more information about those loans. The opening line of the FOI response says:

“The Scottish Government does not hold detailed information on all public funding provided to private companies in Scotland.”

I am sorry, but I find that absolutely incredible. Why does the Scottish Government not hold those details?

I will ask some specific questions to allow the cabinet secretary to clarify matters. What was the purpose of the £15 million loan? What due diligence was done on the firm before the loan was made? What analysis has been done of how the money has been spent?

The additional £30 million loan facility was explicitly not to go towards the CMAL ferries or to pay for budget overruns in those contracts; instead, in contrast to what the cabinet secretary has just said, it was designed to win new business opportunities. Will the cabinet secretary clarify for the record that none of the money that has been loaned to Ferguson Marine has been or will be used on the existing troubled ferry contracts?

Derek Mackay SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work · Renfrewshire North and West
link

That is quite an incredible position for the Conservatives to hold. It is clear that they do not speak to each other. It is just not true to say that I have not informed Parliament of the loans. As I said in my initial answer, I have done so; in particular, I have informed the Finance and Constitution Committee. I did so on 24 April and on 27 June. I am under no obligation to present that information to Parliament, but I did so. In the spirit of transparency, I went beyond expectations to offer that information to the Finance and Constitution Committee, and that was the appropriate thing to do.

Most members of Parliament understand issues of commercial confidentiality; certainly, members of the Finance and Constitution Committee, including the responsible Conservative members of that committee, understand what commercial confidentiality is. There are some matters that stay private. We have, of course, again fulfilled our freedom of information obligations.

On support for Ferguson Marine, it is incredible that a member who seeks to be elected in the west of Scotland tries to undermine Ferguson Marine in the fashion that Jamie Greene has. The financial support for Ferguson Marine is, of course, to ensure the yard’s viability and continued work and to ensure that it has working capital. Those were the specifics relating to the request. Of course we want the delivery of the new vessels as well, but it is good for a Government to engage in the fashion that we have to support Scottish shipbuilding.

I say again that, without any obligation to do so, I wrote to the Finance and Constitution Committee and informed it of the loans that the Scottish Government was providing.

Jamie Greene Con West Scotland
link

This is not about whether the Government should or should not support the marine industry; this is about accountability, transparency from the Government and good governance. I have heard about none of that today from the cabinet secretary.

The project is already delayed by at least a year and is already tens of millions of pounds over budget. There is also talk of a dispute between the yard owners, the Government and CMAL over project management and where the liability for those financial overruns lies. Delays cost money. Will the cabinet secretary tell us—in simple terms—who will pick up the tab for the dispute? Is it Ferguson Marine or the Scottish taxpayer?

Derek Mackay SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work · Renfrewshire North and West
link

Let me be clear about the Government’s investment in ferries. Since 2007, we have invested more than £1 billion in ferry services. We have deployed new ferries to the network, which has enhanced the CalMac fleet.

Do the Conservatives not even welcome the fact that the Scottish Government is supporting Scottish shipbuilding? What is so wrong with that position? We are delivering 400 jobs at Ferguson Marine, and there are new apprenticeships, too. Is that not to be welcomed by the Conservatives and others in the chamber?

Of course the delays are not welcome; they are unfortunate. However, the Government is committed to this investment for new vessels.

I say again that Jamie Greene may not be familiar with issues of commercial confidentiality. Of course due diligence has been conducted. That question was posed to me by the member who now seems more interested in other matters. Of course due diligence was undertaken in relation to the commercial loans. These are commercial loans, with commercial terms and bound by commercial confidentiality. Is the member seriously suggesting that we should not respect that and not respect the fact that, through our interventions, the Government has helped not only to save the yard but to deliver 400 jobs in that part of Scotland? The vessels will be delivered. We have provided support through the loans to address the working capital issue that Ferguson Marine raised.

I say again that the more responsible members of the Conservative Party who are on the Finance and Constitution Committee were alerted to the loans. What I did went over and above the transparency that is expected of me as a cabinet secretary. In fact, it was in order to be fully transparent that I offered that information about the loans to the committee, which respected that.

I am aware that a committee of which Jamie Greene is a member has been invited out to the yard to find out more about the vessels. I do not think that he has visited the yard yet, despite that offer having been made.

The Government will do the right thing by Scottish industry and jobs. If that means that a Scottish shipbuilder is building vessels for our CalMac fleet, surely that should be welcomed.

Stuart McMillan SNP Greenock and Inverclyde
link

Does the cabinet secretary agree with me that it is the height of hypocrisy for a Conservative MSP, particularly one with a Port Glasgow connection, to come to the chamber and talk down shipbuilding in my constituency and talk down high-quality and skilled jobs, bearing in mind the devastation that his party brought to shipbuilding in 1979, when the Conservative Government shut the yards, paid off thousands and devastated communities, including the cabinet secretary’s and mine?

Derek Mackay SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work · Renfrewshire North and West
link

I agree with Stuart McMillan. It has been important not only for shipbuilding but for industry that this Government has taken bold decisions to support Scottish industry across Scotland. This issue is a good example of that. The Tories are not satisfied with devastating Scottish industry because, even now in opposition, they are undermining and attacking our efforts to support the Scottish economy. It is surprising for a member who proclaims to be for jobs in the west of Scotland, including Inverclyde, to try to undermine the Scottish Government’s efforts in the chamber today.

Colin Smyth Lab South Scotland
link

The cabinet secretary will be aware that the costs of completing the two ferries that Ferguson Marine is building to serve the Clyde and Hebrides network are rising, and that the company claims that that is due to insufficient design work by CMAL prior to it issuing the invitation to tender. Ferguson Marine has described the discussions with CMAL as frustrating. Does the cabinet secretary agree that it is time to get CMAL, the Government and Ferguson Marine around the table to resolve the issues and to get the ferries completed as soon as possible at a fair price that not only delivers for increasingly frustrated passengers but helps to secure the future of this important shipyard and its workforce?

Derek Mackay SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work · Renfrewshire North and West
link

I thank the member for the way in which he has raised that issue. That is a far more helpful contribution than that of the Tories, who are simply trying to undermine the loan support that we have given to the company.

Clearly, as finance secretary, I am interested in procurement right across the public sector, and I think that there is something to be said for ensuring that all parties continue to get round the table and talk, so that we make the necessary progress.

The question was, in essence, about the commercial loan that was offered. I think that I have been able to show that I absolutely have complied with the Parliament’s expectation—and I have gone above and beyond that by offering the information to the Finance and Constitution Committee.

As to further work in relation to CMAL, which is the procuring authority, and Ferguson Marine, we can have further discussion in that regard.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

As a member of the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, I have heard how important new ferries are for Scotland. We have heard that we need a new ferry to be ordered every year for the next 10 years. I do not dispute that; I am asking the cabinet secretary whether he thinks that due diligence has been correctly done in this case, given that the company to which the loan has been made has not submitted audited accounts since 2015. That raises the question of whether it is diligent to lend the company the money. Where is the due diligence?

Derek Mackay SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work · Renfrewshire North and West
link

For any loan offer, we would expect due diligence to be complied with. It has been. External consultants have worked in that regard, as well as finance officials. Members would expect me to appreciate and abide by commercial confidentiality—[Interruption.]

I can certainly reassure the Parliament that due diligence was carried out. This is a commercial loan, with commercial terms. The benefits to Scotland and Scottish shipbuilding are clear. I am surprised that the Conservatives are turning on the company involved, in the fashion in which they are—[Interruption.] The Tories seem quite agitated this afternoon—it is their question, I have to say.

The Conservatives might want to talk to their colleagues on the Finance and Constitution Committee about the information that has been mentioned. I pointed out to Mr Greene that he was invited to visit the yard; Edward Mountain would have been given the same invitation if he is a member of the same committee, as I think he is.

I have been happy to engage on questions and FOI requests, and if the Finance and Constitution Committee wants further information, I will engage positively with it. I remind members again that I volunteered information on the loan to the committee, although I was under no obligation to do so. I think that that was the responsible thing to do. I have not been dragged to the chamber; I have been quite forthcoming in presenting information. Of course, we will add the further information to which I referred in my initial answer.

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

We have just enough time for another supplementary question.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Thank you, Presiding Officer.

I invite the cabinet secretary to continue to be forthcoming. Does he consider the problem to be CMAL, not Ferguson? When will he sort that out?

Derek Mackay SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Economy and Fair Work · Renfrewshire North and West
link

I am sure that Jackie Baillie well understands that it would not be appropriate for me to take sides in the chamber in any procurement issue or dispute. As I think that I said to her Labour colleague, if there is anything further that I can do in terms of procurement responsibility, I will engage in that. I will be genuinely happy to engage with Jackie Baillie on this and any other matter.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Migration Advisory Committee Report Questions · 10
  3. Ferguson Marine Questions · 15
  4. Bank Closures Debate · 51
  5. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  6. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 1
  7. Decision Time Decision time · 2
  8. United Nations International Day of Peace 2018 Members’ business · 21

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.