Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Dog Breeding (PE1640)

Thursday 26 April 2018 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00–09:45 Petitions 109 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

109 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The first item on the agenda is consideration of two continued petitions on which we will take oral evidence from Roseanna Cunningham, the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform, whom I welcome. The first of those two petitions is PE1640, on action against irresponsible dog breeding, which was lodged by Eileen Bryant.

The cabinet secretary is accompanied by Andrew Voas, who is the veterinary head of animal welfare at the Scottish Government. Thank you both for attending. We may be joined by Emma Harper and Christine Grahame for consideration of PE1640.

We have quite a range of topics to cover, cabinet secretary, but we will be happy to hear a brief opening statement, if you have one.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform · Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I did not come with a prepared statement, but you may want me to make one up now, convener.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

No. That is helpful, because there are, as you can imagine, a large number of questions. In your submission to the committee in October you said that “A Nation With Ambition: The Government’s Programme for Scotland 2017-18”

“notes that improvements to the licensing and registration arrangements for dog, cat and rabbit breeding will follow the preparation of legislation for a modern system of registration and licensing of animal sanctuaries and re-homing activities”

and that its immediate priority

“is to establish the principles that can be included in legislation for that modern system”.

Can you give me an update on progress in establishing those principles?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Yes. Members of the committee might be aware that we have fairly recently consulted on animal sanctuaries and rehoming activities. We have not yet published the analysis of that consultation, but we expect to do so within the next couple of weeks.

Officials are drafting legislation that will include principles on, for example, the ability of local authorities to vary, suspend or revoke licences, risk-based frequency of inspection by independent third parties and setting of consistent fees to allow cost recovery.

There will be a detailed requirement for licence holders to follow specific guidance on how to care for animals, so there is quite a lot happening, and there is quite a dynamic process.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I appreciate that the analysis has not been published yet, but do you have a sense of whether there was consensus around the key issues?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Andrew Voas might be able to fill in the specifics. Most people think that what is being done is a good idea. As you would expect, however, there are questions about whether it will be appropriate for every size of establishment, so there might be different approaches depending on establishments’ size. I understand that nobody is saying that they think that there should be no such scheme, so it is heartening that we do not have that division of opinion. We are confident that moving forward in this way is absolutely the right thing to do: most people would consider it to be the appropriate thing to do.

There might be questions about the burden that would be put on very small establishments, compared with very large ones. Should there be different approaches? There are issues around the detail, about which, I suspect, there will be conversations. However, as far as I know, no one is saying—Andrew Voas can correct me if I am wrong—that there should be no licensing or registration.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

That is correct. As the cabinet secretary said, there was general support among respondents to the consultation. There were a few queries about where thresholds for different licences should kick in. We came up with suggestions for consideration regarding the number of dogs or cats that could be kept.

Obviously, there is difficulty in equating other animals. Licensing will cover the full range of exotic animals, horses, reptiles and fish, so technical questions have been raised about, for example, how many fish would need to be kept before one would need a certain level of licence, and what will happen if different species are kept at the same premises. Those are the sorts of things that we are thinking through in drafting the legislation.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. In relation to the arrangements that you have been talking about, and specifically for puppies, will there be a national register that includes unique breeder numbers and puppy identification numbers? Has the matter been gone into in such detail?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

We have not ruled out a national register and are looking at how one might operate. A national register would certainly allow easier access to information, but setting that up will take some consideration; it cannot be created overnight and we will have to think through how it would be managed.

I suppose that a register could include unique breeder identification numbers. However, as I understand it, all dogs already require unique microchip identification by the time they are eight weeks old, so perhaps there is already a base of information that we can use to begin that process.

I flag up that the Kennel Club has raised concerns around privacy, in respect of a national register, so we will need to engage with it to bottom out precisely what it thinks the problems might be. That is part of the ongoing process.

Those are the kinds of things that are coming up that we will deal with as we try to develop the best scheme.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Is there a general acceptance that there is a need to keep track of what is going on much more than is happening presently?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

As I said at the outset, we have not ruled out a national register. We are examining whether that would be practical and do what it would exist to do, which is to provide public information. We cannot overlook that there may be underlying technical problems. As I have flagged up, the Kennel Club has an issue about privacy as well, in particular because a lot of breeding is done domestically: where people do the breeding is also their home address. People do not necessarily live in one place and run a separate breeding establishment elsewhere, so the business address and the home or family address are the same. We need to consider whether that issue is serious enough to affect how we think a national register might look.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I welcome Christine Grahame to the meeting. Committee members have questions to ask, then I will give Christine Grahame the opportunity to ask questions.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

This is a new thing for you, convener—me in listening mode.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I had thought that the Deputy Presiding Officer would have to do a lot of listening.

Good morning, cabinet secretary and Mr Voas. Thank you for coming.

In your submission to the committee in October, you provided an update on discussions between officials in the United Kingdom and in the Republic of Ireland on sharing intelligence about illegal imports. You mentioned discussions regarding Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs draft legislation on animal activity licensing, which had been proposed for introduction in England and Wales. Where do matters stand?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

We anticipated that question, so we checked. I can tell you that DEFRA has published the draft legislation. It is currently being taken through Westminster, and the current expectation is that it will come into force in October.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

That is good. At our previous consideration of the petition, Emma Harper mentioned that she had attended a meeting in March with stakeholders. She suggested that good progress was being made in closing routes for illegal transfer of puppies. Is that the case? Where has that got to?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I think that Emma Harper was probably referring to the ongoing collaborative work between the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, Dumfries and Galloway Council and counterparts from across the UK. This is a problem that goes beyond our boundaries and includes the Republic of Ireland, so various other agencies are involved.

There is evidence that operation Delphin, which is trying to tighten up enforcement, is beginning to have an impact. However, we know that there is profit in such activity, which is why people do it, so there is concern about trade displacement, as Michelle Ballantyne might imagine.

It is interesting—I have spoken about this at an SSPCA event—that Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs has taken what I call the Al Capone option. It is identifying undeclared income from puppy dealers and targeting it. It has recently launched a third task force to do that. That is to approach the matter from a slightly different angle, but it looks as though it is quite a fruitful way of tackling the issue, because the whole thing is about money.

I cannot tell you that a magic solution has been developed. What I can say—if this is what Emma Harper was referring to, as I suspect it is—is that we feel the consistent on-going collaboration is beginning to make a difference. We just have to check that we are not displacing the trade elsewhere. HMRC’s involvement is probably very helpful.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

In your submission, you also referred to the “early discussions” about the possibility of

“a co-ordinated public awareness raising campaign”.

Emma Harper mentioned that, at the meeting with stakeholders, there had been some discussion about a national programme of awareness, which might include a short video. Could you update us on how all of that is progressing and what the target audience is considered to be?

09:15

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Just last week, I tweeted as part of one of those campaigns, which involved the SSPCA, the Scottish Government and various leading animal welfare organisations, and which was publicising the message “say no to puppy dealers”. I think that I managed to do two out of the three tweets that I was asked to be involved in. If you were search “say no to puppy dealers”, you would be able see what was being done. The SSPCA is hosting a website under that name as well, giving advice to people who are thinking about buying a puppy. It is similar to what we were doing in the run-up to Christmas. Pretty much every year in the run-up to Christmas, we try to steer people away from buying puppies for Christmas because, inevitably, six to nine months down the line, those puppies are all being handed in because they do not stay puppies for long.

There were video clips attached to the more recent social media campaign. We are going to follow that up with our bigger marketing campaign, which we are in the process of developing. That campaign will be aimed at, in particular, those who are tempted by cute puppy images—and unfortunately social media is awash with those. We all look at them; they are great, but unfortunately they lead to some people buying in the wrong way. We just need them to stop and think before they do that. The interesting observation to make is that the research that the Scottish Government has done suggests that, when it comes to puppy-buying decision making, it is young women who make the buying decisions. That gives us an idea of where some of the specific targeting has to go and may lead to a change in where we put the advertising: if it is young women who are making those decisions, we need to be where young women are, whether that is online or elsewhere. We may seriously have to think about targeting first-time buyers, young people and—clearly, given the research—young women in particular.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

Thank you. The research suggested that teaching children about animal welfare could be built into the curriculum. Is that more of a medium to long-term ambition? It is targeted at youngsters, who will become the puppy-buying public.

My other question is related to that. What role do you see for local authorities, given that they are often left picking up the pieces when puppies are abandoned?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Education through schools is very important—it is about the future generation’s attitudes to animals. When we talk to young people, we talk about not just puppies but animal cruelty in general. I suppose that that is part of encouraging empathy in young people. We know that if people are able to express empathy to animals, they will also feel that way towards human beings; it is not an either/or.

The SSPCA already does tremendous work through schools. The work that it is doing reaches about 300,000 young people each year, so the approach is already quite an important part of what is put out there. At the end of the day, it is not mandatory to include the issue in schools, but local authorities or, in some cases, individual interested teachers are pulling in that aspect. We are reaching a pretty significant number of young people already.

Local authorities are already represented on the SSPCA group that is looking at the issue—they are actively engaged. Because they often end up picking up the pieces, it is important for them that they try to encourage anything that will help. I think that they were responsible for flagging up the notion of trusted traders, so they are involved in a two-way conversation with all other interested parties. They are not sitting back from the debate.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

The scoping research that was published last November notes that key national and international animal welfare non-governmental organisations are very concerned about the escalating illegal puppy trade. The report recommends developing a process to accurately record both the legal and known illegal trade, with one suggestion being to copy the format of the European Union trade in wildlife information exchange. Can you explain a bit more about that and say how the Government might liaise with the rest of the UK to explore that suggestion?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Yes. There is UK-based activity going on. The Animal and Plant Agency, or APHA, is in the process of gathering and collating intelligence about illegal imports. We have not yet discussed any formal mechanism for recording and reporting such activity. You will understand that one of the difficulties is that there are no restrictions on movement and trade across the various internal borders in the UK. That means that dogs that are illegally traded in any part of the UK could come from other regions in the UK. It is quite difficult to be able to track that, and we know that illegally traded dogs can also come from the Republic of Ireland or Europe. Work is already happening, with APHA having taken on that role. In fairness, I do not think that we are yet at a point where I can describe a formal mechanism, but you can rest assured that the issue is being actively looked at. Again, it is just about some of the technical problems around managing the situation, given that, at least within the UK, there is complete freedom of movement.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I was going to ask whether any other options are being explored but it is clear that you are looking at the possibility of doing that.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Yes, we are. It just makes sense for that to happen on a UK-wide basis.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Some illegal puppy traders, or the individuals involved, have been identified, and I assume that they will be on a record somewhere and will not be allowed just to carry on under another name or whatever. I know that that is probably more of a criminal matter, but some progress has been made in cracking down.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

In an earlier answer, I talked about some of the effort that is going in, including going after undeclared income. Things are happening on a number of fronts. We are not putting all our eggs in one basket—I do not think that that will ever be possible, because we will constantly have to be looking at taking a wide range of actions, and it will be the cumulative impact of those actions that will begin to have an overall impact.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Good morning. I will follow up on my colleague Rona Mackay’s question about the scoping research. The report recognises the different types of trade and the variety of offenders involved. It also recognises that different responses are required to tackle illegal domestic and international trade. Can you give us an update on exactly where the Scottish Government’s work is with other jurisdictions and agencies on taking forward research in the area?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I refer to my earlier answer about the on-going collaborative working that we are part of—I will not just repeat that, but it partly answers your question and is incredibly important. The Scottish Government is not taking forward any specific research in the area, but we are considering how best to monitor the marketing campaign to try to assess its effectiveness and impact. In a sense, that is all part of the much wider effort that is going on across the whole of the UK.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

What exactly is the marketing campaign? How effective is it? How are you going about it?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

It is the marketing campaign that I just referred to.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

I could expand on that a bit.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

Yes. There was a week-long marketing campaign that involved the Scottish Government—

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

It was last week. The SSPCA and other NGOs agreed to co-operate to launch the say no to puppy dealers website that the SSPCA is hosting. You can google it—the website address is www.SayNoToPuppyDealers.co.uk, and you will find information there. We are trying to point people to that website who are thinking of buying a puppy or concerned about the risks. Everybody is trying to get people to go to the website.

That was just a lead-in to a longer-term marketing campaign that we are in the process of setting up and which we have now agreed will be part of the programme of Scottish Government-funded marketing campaigns over the next 12 months. We are establishing the scope of the campaign and, as members have heard, we have an idea of who the target audience will be. We are looking at the most effective way of reaching those people—they are the sort of people who would not necessarily look at a Government website to get information, but we are trying to find innovative ways of reaching them. The campaign may use things such as decoy advertisements. Someone who is looking for a popular breed online may see an advertisement that says, “Puppies at an attractive price”, to get them to look, but which then gives warnings about the health risks or the fact that they may be supporting illegal trade or left with a puppy that requires thousands of pounds to be spent on vet’s bills and might need to be put down a few weeks later. That is the sort of approach that we are thinking of taking. We have not decided exactly which approaches we will use, but those are the thoughts that we are developing as part of the longer-term marketing campaign.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

How do you intend to monitor the campaign? You are talking about targeting the illegal international trade as well, so it is quite a complex exercise.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

The campaign is about targeting prospective buyers. Effectively, we are trying to remove the demand that ends up being satisfied by the illegal puppy trade, because people do not think through their decisions. It will come in on the demand side. A lot of the collaborative work that we have already discussed is about tackling the supply side. In effect, both have to be happening at the same time for it to ultimately begin to work.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

No, no—not at all. From the report, it seems that, in relation to behaviour, although consumers say that they feel a bit overwhelmed and confused, they also think that the online trade is much more heavily regulated than it actually is and that their purchases are safer than they actually are. However, there are opportunities for interventions, and you have said what some of those might be. The report talks about the pet advertising advisory group’s minimum standards for advertising and the use of pop-ups and links—they are included in the recommendations section. Are you following up on some of that, or is that being done separately? Have you thought about how you can regulate websites in conjunction with other legislatures and agencies—or even if you can regulate, given that some of those websites are not based in the UK?

09:30

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

That is one of our difficulties. Any attempt to regulate websites or other things on the internet can become, as we know, extremely difficult. We are considering legislating to require sellers to include unique identity numbers and other relevant information in any adverts that they place. However, we have to go back to consumers and what they know and understand. If we legislated in that way, we would need to think through how we could ensure that people understood that they should look for that information when they see an advert. Tackling consumer behaviour is a big issue across a whole range of issues, not just this one. It is not easy because people can remain unaware of a lot that is going on. They are not making decisions in any malicious or deliberately bad way; they are just not aware of what they should be looking out for. We see it as our job and the job of people such as those at the SSPCA—who regard it as their job too—to try to have the widest possible campaign so that the largest number of people know what they should be looking for when they see adverts.

We are looking at legislative requirements but the internet is almost impossible to police. I do not know that we can do anything in an interventionist way about that. For example, if we legislated to require each puppy to have a unique identifying number—it is a bit like the travel ads with the Association of British Travel Agents—

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

People would have to know to look out for that. As we know, even with the well-established ABTA scheme, there are still people who go through other ways of doing things.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Yes, but that presumes that the buyer knows everything that there is to know, which I think is unfair. This is a process of educating consumers; in a sense, that is what a lot of marketing and social media campaigns are about. There will not be one easy answer; there will simply be, across a broad range of actions, the hope that we keep advancing that understanding. Andrew Voas has already flagged up some of the ideas that might come up in his answer to Maurice Corry. That is all part of this. We need to think through the practicalities very carefully, but we will be looking for ways in which we can ensure that consumers know more rather than less.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

The report makes a number of recommendations about regulation, but it suggests that that process needs to start with a review of all legislation that relates to the breeding, sale and international transit of dogs, which would require an

“analysis of domestic breeding regulation as well as international imports”.

It notes that such a review is “particularly necessary” in light of the UK leaving the EU. Can you tell us how that will be factored into the Government’s consideration of regulation? You mentioned that perhaps there would have to be a centralised UK database. Can you expand on your thinking in that regard?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

In a sense, we are in the process of modernising legislation, which is pretty much consistent with what is being done in England and Wales. We could consider changing the requirements for the international movement of dogs only if we did so alongside other UK Administrations. A lot of people benefit from things such as the pet travel scheme, but it is being abused so there are obviously issues around policing it.

Can things be made better? That is not something that we can do unilaterally. I do not want, at the Scottish Government level, to pause everything that we are doing to do some kind of separate broad analysis. We have identified things that we need to move on with and we are in the process of doing that. It is a question of managing and balancing those things. I appreciate that the call for that broad review has been made but, to be perfectly honest, we would find it logistically difficult to add that into what we are already in the process of taking forward. I do not know whether Andrew Voas wants to say anything more about that, but it is a question of resources at this point. For us, it is of more immediate importance to ensure that we get right the action that we are in the middle of progressing.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

Not particularly, no.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

It was a very good answer.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

What you say about consumers is very interesting, but the other side is dealing with the actions of those who are, in quite unpleasant ways, making the lives of puppies miserable and perhaps misrepresenting to consumers what they are buying. In terms of providing tougher sanctions and sentences, what is the Scottish Government’s position on having the facility to issue definitive legislation and sentencing guidelines for criminal justice and enforcement agencies?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

That is a criminal justice matter. Obviously, sentencing guidelines are useful but, regardless of sentencing guidelines, courts will always simply look at the facts and circumstances of the case that is in front of them before awarding a sentence. I would need to discuss issues to do with sentencing guidelines with my colleague.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That discussion is beginning, is it?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I do not know whether we are actively talking about sentencing guidelines on this.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

Not at the moment. We will be shortly.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Not at the moment, no.

I think that fixed-penalty notices would be useful, and it could be of use to amend the Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 to allow for them, particularly once we do the title legislation on breeding and sale. The fixed-penalty method would save the enforcement authorities quite a lot of time and resources in dealing with issues that come up, particularly if they are just failures to comply with conditions or whatever that are easily identified. That whole area is a bigger, trickier area, because we are potentially moving into criminal law, which carries with it all the requirements of proof that exist in criminal court cases. Clearly, it has to be part of what we do, but it cannot be the only thing.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You referred to increasing the maximum penalty but also having fixed-penalty notices, which would give a broader range of options, but in your submission you had indicated that you would be consulting key stakeholders and enforcement agencies and that there would be wider consultation. Could you give us an update on that?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Discussions are taking place with various key stakeholders—you could probably name them yourselves, but they will include the SSPCA—about potential amendments to the act. I remind everybody that amending the act would require primary legislation and, clearly, that would involve a much longer timescale. We would need to identify a legislative vehicle for that and there is not one over the next year, as far as I am aware. The minute we begin to talk about primary legislation, we are into a much longer timescale.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that Parliament has shown itself to be very nimble in producing fast legislation on other issues, so it might be that you could get a consensus and be nimble on this one.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I will pitch that to the Minister for Parliamentary Business, but I am not quite sure how he will take that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It is not the easiest defence when we manage to deal with something in a couple of weeks but, anyway, I understand that the normal process takes slightly longer.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I do not think that you would want the same thing to be happening with every piece of legislation.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

Good morning. As you know, cabinet secretary, I am pursuing a member’s bill on responsible dog ownership.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

Yes, really. As a wee trailer, I say that I am launching the consultation at Edinburgh Dog and Cat Home a week on Friday.

A lot of what you have said is important, but the important point that I pick up on is about cutting off the demand, because the rest is very tricky—the online activity and the stuff that comes from puppy farms. My bill will try to deal with that in statute and balance it with measures on breeders and dealing.

I have a couple of questions that follow on from what you said. I was interested in the idea of a national register of licensed breeders in Scotland. I understand what you said about the Kennel Club—privacy and all that stuff—but do you have any timeline in mind for when your decision on whether to have a national register of licensed breeders will come to fruition? That would be terribly useful.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

We are considering that as part of the drafting process. It is an active part of it. We are already at the point of drafting for sanctuaries and rehoming.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

We will come on to the breeders after.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I do not know whether we have a timescale. I think that we said that we hoped that it would be sometime this year for the sanctuaries and rehoming.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

That is right.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

That will be put through at some point this year, and then we will move on to the broader issues, including things such as the national register.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

We hope to consult fairly soon on issues to do with breeders.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

It is a bit like asking how long a piece of string is. I am trying to think what the expected time lag might be for taking all this forward. Provisions on sanctuaries and rehoming should be done and dusted by the end of this year. When it comes to considering the things that might apply to a register, it will probably be the end of next year before we make a decision about that.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

Yes, we hope to consult later this year on proposals on breeders and the selling of dogs, cats and rabbits. That is the commitment that we have made.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Yes, but if the consultation took place this year, that means that the drafting would be take place next year.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

I am obviously looking at this in the context of what I am doing.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

I am trying to think what I need to put in.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Yes. If we are consulting on that this year, any action will be another year down the line. We would probably talking about the end of 2019.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

We would like to be a bit more ambitious than that.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I do not want to give a timescale that then turns out not to be achievable.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

I appreciate the difficulties.

The second point that I wish to raise is this. When you talked about a seller including a unique identity number, what is meant by the “seller”? Is that the dealer or the breeder?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

The numbers would be breeder identification numbers.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

It is breeder identification, so it is not the dealer.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

No. In effect, we would be giving an ID number to a recognised breeder and then ensuring that, when the breeder was undertaking any commercial activity, that ID number was part of what they put out to advertise what they were doing.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

That is one of the things that we have to think about because, in effect, all dogs have to be microchipped and there is a unique microchip identification number as it is. We have to look at the technicalities of whether we can build on the microchip base or whether we will require to do something separate.

09:45

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

I think that, now that we have microchipping in place, the more we can put on the microchip from the initial stages, the better for everyone concerned—the police, the SSPCA, vets and potential owners. I appreciate that there are difficulties. There is more than one microchipping company, which is another issue.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I remind people about the privacy issues that the Kennel Club has raised.

Christine Grahame SNP Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale
link

I am not too bothered about them.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

I have a brief point of clarification. There have been references to engagement and intelligence sharing with the Republic of Ireland. Is there a two-way trade in illegal imports and, if so, what is the balance in that trade?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I am not sure that I can specifically answer that question. Yes, there is co-operation. I would hazard the opinion that it is not a two-way trade, but Andrew Voas might be in a better position to explain some of the detail.

Andrew Voas Scottish Government
link

Overwhelmingly, the puppies are coming from breeders in the Republic of Ireland into Scotland, England and Wales. We have good co-operation with my counterparts in the Republic of Ireland and in Northern Ireland, so we share intelligence at that level, and I am aware that the Irish Government has co-operated with enforcement campaigns on the movement of puppies into England and Wales as well as into Northern Ireland and Scotland.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I flag up that the Daily Record is currently running a campaign against illegal puppy trading, which will help to raise public awareness.

Finally, how optimistic are you that we will eventually be able to crack down on this horrible trade?

Roseanna Cunningham SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I have said on a couple of occasions that there will not be a single solution to this. I am pleased that the extensive collaboration that is going on is beginning to make a difference but, as we know only too well, criminal activity often just finds a different way of doing things. I do not think that we will ever be able to say that it has been completely eradicated. Anybody who said that would probably be misleading. As with any other activity, I think that we can reduce it, but I am not sure that I would want to commit myself to saying that we can eradicate it.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We have reached the end of our questions—that has been very helpful.

I now welcome members’ comments on how we might take this forward.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

There seems to be an awful lot going on in different places, with Christine Grahame’s member’s bill, the work that the Government is doing, some of the combined UK and cross-water work that is going on. I suppose that at this stage I am slightly unclear how we can lend to that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It might be worth taking the opportunity to reflect on what we have heard today but also tasking the petitioner to provide a written submission on what they have heard today. We know that folk are really engaged with this across our communities. We want to reflect on what we have heard and then come back to think about how we might take this forward. It may be that, having aired all the issues—and there is work being done in different bits of the Parliament—we may decide not to continue in the Public Petitions Committee, but I think that we should afford the petitioner an opportunity to respond before then.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If that is agreed, we will reflect on the evidence at a future meeting and we will also invite the petitioner to provide a written submission.

I thank Andrew Voas for his attendance. I will suspend briefly for a change of witness.

09:49 Meeting suspended.

09:53 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 109
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 30
  4. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 14
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 15
  6. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 16
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 24
  8. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  10. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
  11. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 24
  12. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.