I thank Monica Lennon for securing the debate.
It will come as no surprise that I will focus my comments on a situation with which I have had much involvement: the incinerator, pyrolysis plant or energy-to-waste unit—whatever members want to call it—at Carnbroe in Coatbridge, which has been mentioned already.
The historical facts of the case are what they are—Elaine Smith outlined them. Suffice to say that North Lanarkshire Council rejected the original proposal, but its decision was overturned on appeal by the reporter. Money was subsequently spent by North Lanarkshire Council on taking the matter to court; unfortunately, that was in vain, too.
Despite that, another fact holds true: there is no incinerator yet. There are a variety of reasons for that, but it is in no small part down to the efforts and dedication of the campaign group, Monklands residents against pyrolysis plant, ably led by Maggie Proctor—Elaine Smith mentioned her, too. When Maggie speaks to people, one of her key messages is to remind us that the areas that will be affected by such a development are not just the Coatbridge areas of Carnbroe, Sikeside and Shawhead, but many others for miles around.
That leads me to thank all political parties and politicians across North Lanarkshire for joining me in placing objections with the council. I include the MSPs for the neighbouring areas, Alex Neil, Richard Lyle and Clare Haughey; Neil Gray MP; and the Labour and Conservative list MSPs for Central Scotland. It would be remiss of me not to give a special mention to Elaine Smith, who, as my predecessor in the Coatbridge and Chryston constituency, fought the proposal for a long time.
When I was elected, the situation was well known to me. I had family and friends in Carnbroe and Shawhead, and I knew about the 6,000-strong petition, but I felt that I had a duty to test the matter. Last summer, I undertook a survey, over a very short space of time, in the area most affected. Nearly 500 households responded—I am keen to stress that that number of households responded. Their survey returns showed that many of those households contained two, three or four family members—members can do the maths. Almost all those people said that they had serious concerns about the building of the plant.
Following that, a community meeting was called with the developers, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and the campaign group so that people could raise their concerns. Hundreds packed into Carnbroe primary school. I do not think that anyone could have left the meeting in any doubt about what people in the local area thought of the new proposals: they felt the same as they had always felt.
Having that information allows me to come to forums such as this in my role as MSP and say with full confidence that the people of my constituency do not want the proposal to proceed.
There are a variety of reasons why people do not want it, of which health inequality is by far the most prominent. Coatbridge already has a high level of health problems, including asthma, COPD and lung disease. I am delighted that the Scottish Government has targeted Coatbridge as one of the first low-emission zones after the major cities, especially as the road running through Whifflet, which is not much more than a stone’s throw from the proposed development, regularly exceeds the recommended emissions level.
People are worried that the chemicals involved will affect their health and that of their children. They are also concerned that the area could be made less attractive in terms of housing and being a place where people bring up their families. It could put people off the area. This all comes after I sought assurances from the Government that the new road networks around the M8 would bring economic benefit to the local area. What a shame if the only tangible thing that is brought is waste, feeding down the A8 and coming off at the Carnbroe junction.
On the history of the area, a recycling plant had to be closed down by SEPA at Shawhead—again, just a stone’s throw from the proposed plant. At this point, I should mention community campaigners such as Keirsten Smith, who helped to bring about that closure.
The group of which Elaine Smith was a member will be set up again, following the public meeting that I mentioned—although perhaps that has been overtaken by events. There is an application in place, for which objections had to be in by the start of the month. Hundreds of objections have come in, including from the MSPs I mentioned. The application, which will go before councillors, is an amendment to a previous application that had to be withdrawn. Questions were raised about whether that should have been allowed, as the proposal is clearly for a major new development, and therefore should have been subject to sections 35A and 35B of the Planning (Scotland) Act 1997. I have asked the Government a question on that matter, and I await a response.
The environmentalist in me leads me to take a particular view of the need for and usefulness of incineration but, despite that, I accept that a wider argument may be required. How many of them do we need? Where should they go if they are required? How should local communities be involved in the planning process? Those are all questions that we must answer.
I know that the proposed site is not the right place. The plant should not be in a heavily built-up and populated area with high levels of poverty and health inequality. It should not be in an area that many of us are actively trying to regenerate and where we are trying to encourage expansion—including the exciting plans for the Monklands hospital. It should not be in Coatbridge. The people do not want it, and they have spoken time and time again.