As I have said before, I am always open to discussion, but the reality is that this budget will give a real-terms increase to the resources of local government before they even consider using their power to raise council tax.
I will comment briefly on the economic model of the United Kingdom as a whole. It is clear—the evidence tells us this—that the UK Government’s economic model is centred on London and the south-east of England. It is no surprise that other parts of the UK, including Scotland, are at a disadvantaged position because of that model. A UK Government cannot walk away from its responsibilities in macroeconomic policy; neither can the Tories abdicate their responsibility to have proper fiscal policies, because we cannot raise less and spend more.
When challenged on how to make savings, the Conservatives can point only to measures such as stopping the baby box scheme. That is their answer to how they would find half a billion pounds to fund tax cuts for the richest businesses, people and home owners in society.
It is no good for Murdo Fraser to say that, if only he was in charge, he would have a Scottish Fiscal Commission report that says he would have £16 billion more to invest in Scotland’s economy; it is no good for Murdo Fraser simply to cry wolf when I find extra resources for the Scottish budget. I have set out a clear and transparent process. If only the other Opposition parties could engage constructively in that process.
On listening to business, many business organisations have welcomed much of the budget. The Federation of Small Businesses welcomed the small business bonus—of course—and went on to say:
“Further, the introduction of a new business accelerator relief is a clever move that deserves plaudits.”
The Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, which takes a considered opinion of public funding, said:
“it is welcome news that Scottish public services will receive more funding. As, without extra resources, the financial resilience of many services would inevitably be put into question.”
Liz Cameron, from the Scottish Chambers of Commerce, said of the budget:
“We welcome much of the substance of Mr Mackay’s announcement ... In particular we appreciate his willingness to listen to the voice of business”.
I could quote many more organisations that have welcomed the investments in this Government’s budget. Even the Scottish Retail Consortium, which is much quoted by the Tory party, said:
“the decision on income tax to protect workers on low and modest earnings is exactly right.”
The Scottish Council for Development and Industry said:
“This is a progressive, mature and significant use of Scotland’s income tax powers.”
There is much support for the budget, including from the public, who back our tax plans by two to one.
James Kelly has presented an alternative that is, frankly, neither competent nor coherent. The effect of his tax proposals would be cut in half, given the behavioural impacts. Other elements of his budget would require legislation. The Labour Party was asked when it would present its alternative budget, and it transpires that the detail will come after stage 3. That is a preposterous position from the Labour Party, and it shows that Labour has no credibility whatever.
Working with the Green Party, we have produced a budget that is able to find consensus on investing in our public services and lifting the public sector pay cap in Scotland.
Of course, when James Kelly did the arithmetic on the income tax plans, he said that an MSP’s tax would increase by only 26p. I advise members not to seek advice from James Kelly on their tax returns, because he was wrong to the tune of 1,300 per cent. That is how inaccurate he was, just on the proposition on MSPs’ income tax. Why would we trust the Labour Party on the overall budget?
This is a very serious budget, which uses Scotland’s devolved powers responsibly and fairly. It protects the students of Scotland from tuition fees. It expands childcare, which is good for children and good for the economy. It protects universal support around poverty and inequality, delivering free school meals for children in primary 1 to primary 3. It ensures that the ill do not have to pay prescription charges and it supports the continuation of free eye examinations. The NHS—a precious service—is the largest beneficiary of the budget, and the budget protects the entitlements that give us the best deal anywhere in the UK.
The budget will help to build 50,000 new affordable homes. It will help to expand digital, with investment of more than £600 million. There will be new interventions on homelessness and child poverty. There will be real-terms increases for the NHS, higher education, further education, and police and fire transformation. I know that those commitments command the support of the Scottish people.
Bruce Crawford was right when he said that the budget puts in place resources that speak to the vision of what we want this country to be. The budget delivers on the commitments that the First Minister made in the programme for government. It prevents the negatives that come from Westminster austerity and turns real-terms reduction in resource into growth. It will create a more equal society, tackling inequality and growing our economy.
As we approach the completion of stage 3 and the legal stages of the Scottish budget—of course, we still have the non-domestic rates element and the local government finance order to deal with, so it is not quite over yet—we have an opportunity to deliver divergence and make Scotland, for the majority, the lowest-taxed part of the UK and, crucially, the fairest-taxed part of the UK.
Brexit is a huge challenge to the UK’s economy and to Scotland’s economy. Businesses have said to me that it is a much greater concern than even the perceptions around tax as propagated by the Tories. Therefore, we are delivering stimulus, sustainability and a stronger society, respecting the powers that we have and using them wisely with an evidence base to restructure tax in order to build a better and fairer country.
I ask members to consider all of that and the £40 billion that is allocated in the spending plans in the budget.
I might not be a Morrissey fan, but the old band is back together: better together is back together. I am more of a Proclaimers kind of a guy, which is why I visited Leith yesterday. There was indeed sunshine on Leith at the GP surgery there. The NHS is the biggest beneficiary of the budget.
I commend the budget to the people of Scotland because I know that it commands the support of the Scottish people. I hope that it will command the support of members this evening.