Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Countryside Ranger Services (National Strategic Framework) (PE1678)

Thursday 1 February 2018 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30–11:00 Petitions 76 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

76 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition is PE1678, on a national strategic framework for countryside ranger services in Scotland. The petition was submitted by Ranger Robert Reid, on behalf of the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association.

We will take evidence from Ranger Reid this morning. He is accompanied by George Potts, who is the chairperson of the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association. Welcome, gentlemen. I invite you to provide a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions from committee members.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

We are here today on behalf of our association seeking your support for our petition, which asks the Scottish Government to implement the strategic framework for ranger services as set out in the “Rangers in Scotland” report.

The report, which was published in 2008, stated that there were more than 300 full-time equivalent posts in the sector and expressed an expectation that that number would grow. However, we can show that, in the past 10 years, at least 100 ranger posts have been lost. We are deeply concerned about that and about the impact that it will have on service delivery and the environmental and social benefits that rangers can deliver, as well as the impact that it will have on those remaining in the service and their career prospects. It is not a planned reduction; it is random, unstructured and ill-considered. We feel that we are now at crisis point.

The strategy that was adopted in 2009 marked a watershed, as it broke the direct link between Scottish Natural Heritage and the local authority ranger services with which they had grant-aid agreements. However, the structure and function of ranger services and their role within local authorities and other funded bodies was, by that time, well established.

The training and background of countryside rangers across Scotland resulted in a significant degree of continuity with the model that SNH had been able to support. A couple of employing authorities attempted to redefine the role of their rangers by breaking down the jobs into their constituent parts. However, almost without exception, that diminished the role of those involved and created vulnerable services where previously strong ones with an established track record had operated.

SNH still operates successful grant agreements with non-governmental organisations and with community-based and private sector ranger services. Those partnerships continue to prosper and act as a vital conduit in the delivery of SNH’s corporate strategy.

The association feels that the main casualty of the change in the relationship between SNH and local authority services was the loss of national reporting on the outputs of Scotland’s ranger services that SNH was able to co-ordinate, as that was a way of providing a comprehensive picture of what rangers deliver across Scotland and of benchmarking that in terms of the continued investment of grant aid. We know of a social return on investment study that was done before the change that showed a return of £10 for every £1 invested.

A significant investment of public money has been made over the past 44 years to create ranger services across Scotland with a local and a national identity. Those services operated under the guidance and support of a Government agency and ensured that national priorities were recognised in the delivery of local services. Recognition was also given through the use of our national ranger service badge—the only ranger badge in the world that has people on it—which acts as our charter mark and a mark of the quality standard in our sector.

The Scottish model worked extremely well and has been copied by other countries in the development of their countryside ranger services, and Scotland’s rangers were responsible for the formation of the International Ranger Federation, which is now in 90 countries. We feel that that leading role will soon be lost as the capacity of rangers across Scotland falls into terminal decline.

In conclusion, I draw members’ attention to the public support that our petition has received and particularly the many supportive comments that have been made. The wider public recognise and value their ranger services as forming part of a national approach, and we feel that the Government and relevant agencies should be asked to revisit the 2008 policy document. It is still relevant and aspirational and, if it is properly implemented and monitored, it will begin to address the issues that we are bringing to your attention today and help secure the important national asset that is rangers in Scotland.

10:45

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much. I want to begin by asking a wee bit about the background and the national strategic framework, which was issued in 2008. You have referred to who was involved in its preparation and flagged up the intention behind it, but I am interested in finding out whether, when you were developing the framework in 2008, you were aware of the critical decision to make the funding part of the main settlement to local authorities, which, as I understand it, was taken in 2009 on the back of the local government finance distribution review. When that decision was on its way, did you make any representations or raise any opposition in your belief that this is what would happen?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Our involvement was very small and mainly at the edges. The strategic plan was basically put together and given the nod by organisations such as the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and SNH.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

This is the 2008 plan that you are talking about.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes. That was what was put on the table. I do not know whether the idea was to address it in the future, but some employers and SNH looked at the document, saw the targets that were in it and saw that they were being met. Unfortunately, our problem is that the number of rangers for meeting those targets is in decline, and the new pressures on the rangers who are left are having an impact on their health and welfare. Moreover, given the loss of jobs, this is a career opportunity that is going downhill. Those are the concerns that we have.

It is perhaps worth saying that our association has been totally voluntary for 40 years. In other words, the rangers who run and support it do so on a voluntary basis.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So, in 2008, COSLA, SNH and so on produced what they thought was a really good blueprint for the future.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

And there was a national framework under which a countryside ranger in one part of the country would have a connection with a ranger in another part. However, the decision in 2009 to bundle up the money and give it to local government was, in your view—

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

We had no say in or input into that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

But you believe that that was where the change came, because there was no longer any discrete fund to support a nationwide approach.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

The document talks about the national reporting that was to be co-ordinated by SNH. We believed at the time that it would still take an active interest in the outputs of rangers and the type of work that they were being asked to do.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

SNH now grant aids NGOs and various estates, and it still has to return national figures. However, local authorities do not, so no one in Scotland knows how many rangers we have. According to a survey that we are working on—we had hoped to complete it by today, but we are only about 50 per cent through it—it looks as though we have lost 100 ranger posts in Scotland.

That said, a lot of good news is coming out of that survey. We asked a lot of questions about, for example, ranger service delivery, and that is very much meeting all the targets in the strategic plan. We as the people on the ground are delivering on a daily basis.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

But the basic decision was to lift ring fencing from the money going to local government, with the consequences that you have highlighted.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that the same has been true in other areas. Thank you—that was very helpful.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning. As you have suggested, the strategic framework dates back to 2008, which means that it has been a decade since the work was done. Has anything changed in that time with regard to the initial concerns that prompted its development?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

The framework was brought to us—we did not have any input into the framework. It was a case of us being told, “This is what you will deliver.” It was a new approach to what had to take place. We had no way of asking questions or having any input into what the impact would be, but we had to implement it on the ground when it came in.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

There has not really been a change since the framework was brought in. Bob Reid and I between us have 70 years of experience and in essence, we are doing the same job; we have just changed the language in which we do it. We have moved from promoting country parks to biodiversity to access and, in latter years, to health. However, the job is much the same. The strategic framework reflected a distillation of the experience Scotland-wide and set the tone for how we could go forward.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Why do you consider that the 2008 framework would still be relevant today? What benefits would it bring to the provision of ranger services?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Basically, ranger services are delivering the framework daily. The trouble is that we do not have enough people to make the type of impact that the framework was aiming for.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes, very much so. It is what the rangers today are out delivering. They are meeting Scottish Government targets, European Union targets and Westminster targets on biodiversity and all the other aspects that come within the job remit.

The ranger services have had to absorb a lot of changes that have come through naturally from the EU, Westminster and the Scottish Government. We are trying to meet the requirements that are set for us. Our employers are enforcing that in the sense that they have to report back that they are meeting the targets. That filters down to the ranger services and back up to the heads of department. That is how the stats are brought together.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

My question was going to be whether the framework is still referred to by stakeholders, but you have answered that in your responses to Mr Whittle.

You talked about the survey that you are doing. When do you expect that to be complete and what are your plans for it? What are you going to do with the information when you get it?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

We were hoping that we would already have it completed. Unfortunately, it is not finished. It involves a telephone conversation with every ranger service in Scotland. The survey takes roughly 15 to 20 minutes and a lot of questions are asked concerning the numbers and the roles that ranger services are delivering, some of which have changed. We are also finding out from questions in that survey whether the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association is delivering what our members ask for.

I hope that we will have put all that information together by the end of February. As to what we will do with the information, maybe the Government should do some major statistical work on the evidence that is coming out of the survey, because we are not statisticians; we are basically concerned people who are trying to look after our members’ welfare.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

You spoke about the jobs that have been lost. Is someone filling those posts or are those jobs not being done?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

No one is doing those jobs. There have been some reconfigurations in certain services, but that is around heads of department and what departments are attached to.

Senior ranger posts have been lost, and main grade posts and seasonal posts are being lost. Seasonal posts back up the ranger service at the busy times of the year when Scotland goes through a tourism boom, so there are fewer people on the ground providing a professional service.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Are there some areas that are better than others at keeping the ranger service going? I am thinking about rural areas and tourist areas, in particular.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

One example is that of Highland Council, which axed the whole ranger service in the past two financial years and moved the rangers into a trust. However, we found out from the survey that even the rangers who were put into local authority trusts a number of years ago are not secure in their jobs now, and they feel that they are targets in the next round of cuts. Rangers have been moved from one organisation to another. Local authorities have been taking a big hit. The National Trust for Scotland is looking to shed 79 members of staff in the current round of cuts and rangers will be included in that. It might be worth saying that one local authority interviewed for a range of posts three or four weeks ago and appointed a ranger, but he has now been paid off. It is a crisis.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I note from the evidence that, when there was a transfer from Highland Council to High Life Highland, the council said that there had been a reduction in the number of countryside ranger posts from 22 to 10.5 full-time equivalent posts.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes. It is also worth noting that, although we have the reading from 2008, there were a lot of job losses in the 1996 period. The reductions that are taking place now are probably the second round. One of the reasons is that local authorities, under various pieces of legislation, had to appoint access officers for work that was previously done by a range of services. There are biodiversity officers and conservation officers, so there are jobs in the countryside, but they divert from the wide role that rangers undertake.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Once the survey is completed, it would be helpful for us to get a copy of the results. Are you expecting to get an indication of the number of rangers from the survey?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

We are working on that at the moment. I will have a wee look at what we have. It is done service by service. We have lost 17 senior ranger posts, so we are now sitting at 24.5 posts. We have lost 50 ranger posts, so we are now sitting at 147.5 posts. We have lost 33 seasonal ranger posts, so there are 44 posts. However, we are only halfway through the survey.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Good morning, gentlemen. In your petition, you refer to the ranger development partnership and the ranger manager forum. Who are involved in those groups and what do they discuss?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Scottish Natural Heritage, Forestry Commission Scotland, the National Trust for Scotland and Historic Environment Scotland are involved, and there is representation from the Loch Lomond national park and COSLA. There are also one or two representatives from local authorities. As an organisation, we feel that we need to write to every ranger authority—councils and other employers—to state our concerns.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

You said that only some local authorities are in the groups—the key funders and employers are not involved.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

The local authorities are not all involved. COSLA is, but we have not been in discussion: there has not been a meeting for perhaps two years, as far as I am aware.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

The things that we discussed included the professional qualification for rangers that the association had developed, and other programmes that we had developed, such as the Scottish junior ranger programme and the challenge award, which I hope employers will consider taking on board. However, through the survey, we are finding that services do not have the capacity to promote the programmes or to take them forward.

11:00

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Is your association responsible for the policies and the guidelines that rangers work to? Do you update them, or are they stagnating?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

No, we are not responsible for those. The whole ranger system came out of the Countryside (Scotland) Act 1967. The then Countryside Commission for Scotland drew up the vision for rangers—and the commission got it right.

The parks system for Scotland brought together country parks, regional parks and what were called “special parks”—“national” was not a word that was used at that time. As George Potts and I would say, things are not as they were in the good old days in terms of Government funding. The carrot that was dangled was a 75 per cent grant from central Government to establish the system. It was recognised that the system was required because of what was taking place on the ground.

George Potts Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Michelle Ballantyne used the word “stagnating”. That is not a word that we are familiar with—the profession is young and vibrant and there are lots of young people with energy and enthusiasm who bring in new ideas, share best practice and ensure that the service that they deliver is relevant to their customers.

Over the years, there have been lots of changes, many of which have been led by the rangers themselves. The profession does not stagnate, because lots of young people come through and we have new challenges, new legislation to comply with and new requirements from the employing authorities.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I was referring to Mr Reid’s comment that the committee had not met for two years. That committee is where updates to policy guidelines and qualifications are made. Have things stagnated in those two years, or is somebody else taking on the work?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

I suppose that that confirms how powerful that little group is, when it gets together, in representing the industry. However, it might not cover as wide a range as we would expect it to.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

You have lost a voice by that group not meeting. Do you know why it is not meeting?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

No. It is possibly because the pressures that have been put on the association to deliver mean that it is struggling to survive at the moment and things have slipped, or perhaps no one has picked up the gauntlet.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I note that you met the chair of SNH in 2016, and that you have liaised regularly with the nominated SNH member since then to

“exchange information and address concerns.”

Has that been helpful to the relationship between the ranger service and SNH? Has there been any direct approach to the Scottish Government on the matter?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

We have a good relationship with Alison Matheson in Inverness, who is our SNH link person, so we are well supported in that sense.

SNH, like many other organisations, including the Forestry Commission Scotland, seems to be going through a period of change, and we think that we may not feature at the decision-making level at SNH as we did in the past. The countryside sector, whether we are talking about forestry, Historic Environment Scotland, the private sector or the estates, is in an unknown period.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

SNH has a new chair, so it may well be worth it to request a meeting with him. He has been in front of our Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee and is willing to look at a number of issues, so it might be an opportune moment to speak to him.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

We are in the process of seeking a meeting with him. In 2014, the previous SNH chief executive officer said that the best value for the national health service in Scotland is Scotland’s ranger service.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

From the survey, we can see that there have already been about 13 million visitors, if we put together all the ranger services that we have established. Therefore we provide a large professional service over a wide area. We are proud of it and it is envied elsewhere. The Danish Government picked up the Scottish system, and the English and Welsh ranger associations are envious that we have a national identity, which they do not have. We do not want to lose that. It may be worth saying that our logo is in the Parliament, as part of the Public Petitions Committee exhibition in the foyer.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I understand that rangers are employed by a wide variety of employers, in a range of sectors. How does the framework apply to rangers who are employed in the private sector? Would implementation of the framework be supported by landowners, for example?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

The framework applies across the board—whether the employer is and NGO, a local authority, a private sector organisation or a rural community or island community. It covers all those areas. We are also finding that although some rangers are grant aided, they still fear that their jobs are not secure, even in the private sector.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Is that because the general atmosphere is one of employers saying rangers can be let go?

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Yes—it seems so. We have not been able to have any overall protection, as the Scottish national ranger service.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that we have reached the end of our questioning. We now need to think about how we will progress the petition. Do members have any suggestions?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I have been remiss in not declaring an interest at the start of the meeting. My brother-in-law is a ranger—although not in Scotland. England has the same issues as Mr Reid raises.

As a starting point, we should write to the Scottish Government to seek its view on the petition.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We would be interested to hear the Scottish Government’s views on the importance that it perceives the national service as having, and on whether it recognises what Mr Reid describes as a consequence of the decision in 2009. We could perhaps also write to other organisations that have interests in land, including the Forestry Commission Scotland and the National Trust for Scotland.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I would like us also to write to COSLA to seek its thoughts, because it has been directly involved.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There might be a conversation to be had about ring fencing having been removed and whether COSLA has been tracking what has happened.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Rather than just get an overall view from COSLA, I wonder whether we could perhaps write to each local authority. It would be good to get a figure on how many rangers each still employs. We could also write to arm’s-length external organisations that are associated. We have seen the reduction at High Life Highland, which I presume is an ALEO. We need to get figures from those, too.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

It might be worth my while to say that in the Highlands the tourist industry is homing in on Skye and the Fairy Pools, but there is no ranger service on the island.

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

No—there is not. Since the 1970s, rangers have been trained to deliver management of people in the countryside. The issues apply over a wide area.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

If we are going to ask local authorities for their numbers of rangers, either via COSLA or directly, can we also ask them for their three to five-year plans for them? Most authorities have forward budgeting, so if they intend to have budget cuts it would be good to know that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could also write to the national park authorities and to Scottish Land & Estates. I do not know whether organisations such as Community Land Scotland would have a view on whether they manage their land—

Robert Reid Scottish Countryside Rangers Association
link

Crown properties have ranger services.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes. If we are looking at communities that have taken over land, we could ask whether they have taken over the responsibility for rangers, too. There is also SNH itself, of course.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is quite lot to be going on with.

Mr Reid, once you have your survey in a form that you think might be worth our while to see, as you said, we would appreciate that.

I thank our witnesses very much for their attendance, for giving evidence and for answering our questions. There is quite a lot for us to proceed with, and we will keep you in touch with the progress of the petition.

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow witnesses to leave the table.

11:10 Meeting suspended.

11:11 On resuming—

  1. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 56
  2. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 76
  3. 11:00 New Petitions Petitions · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.