We will move on to PE1662 by Janey Cringean and Lorraine Murray on improving treatment for patients with Lyme disease and associated tick-borne diseases. We first considered this petition in September, when we heard evidence from the petitioners, and agreed to seek the views of a range of stakeholders. The submissions received are supportive of the petition and discuss a range of issues around testing for, treatment of and education about Lyme disease. We have a wealth of information, which members have had the opportunity to read, which I will try to summarise as briefly as possible.
In relation to testing, the Scottish Government advises that the testing laboratory at Raigmore liaises with experts at Public Health England to ensure access to the most robust and scientifically justified testing regime available. However, the Scottish Government recognises that there are gaps in the effectiveness of the tests and notes that the NICE guidelines, which are expected to include consideration of the effectiveness of testing, are currently in development and will be considered by the Lyme borreliosis sub-group once published. That is expected to be in April 2018. The Royal College of General Practitioners in Scotland is represented on a group developing the NICE guidelines and adds that it is taking forward work with the University of Leicester on a new research method of blood tests. Lyme Disease UK and Lyme Disease Action refer to uncertainty and complexity and patients being caught in the middle due to the current limitations of National Health Service blood tests. Lyme Disease UK considers that testing should be extended and suggests upgrading the testing laboratory at Raigmore to a reference laboratory and extending its remit to cover all tick-borne infections. The Scottish Government notes that that is under consideration.
All the submissions acknowledge the need for greater awareness and education among both the public and professionals. The Scottish Government, Scottish Natural Heritage and the RCGP highlight a range of work being taken forward, including the development of professional resources such as podcasts and webinars and appropriate information resources on websites, including Health Protection Scotland. The RCGP provides information about its e-learning course, which has registered over 2,000 users since its launch in September 2014, although the RCGP notes:
“It is difficult to measure the percentage of Scottish general practitioners who have completed the training, as the course is not restricted to a GP or Scottish-only audience.”
The petitioners indicate that they are encouraged by the general agreement among the responses that more needs to be done to tackle Lyme disease. However, they express their disappointment with the draft NICE guidelines, which they consider to be very narrow in scope. The petitioners welcome support for the suggestion of a specialist treatment centre and the argument for pilot specialist clinics and they also strongly support the elevation of the testing laboratory’s status to a reference laboratory. The petitioners summarise the response with suggested actions that they indicate they would like to see taken forward within a Scottish national plan for tick-borne infections, similar to that developed in France. The petitioners also draw our attention to the French national plan.
That was a brief summary. Before members make any comments or suggestions for further action, I welcome Alexander Burnett, who has joined us. He has had a significant interest in this issue for some time. Mr Burnett, I will ask you to come in later, once we have had contributions from the committee members.