PE1629, by Jennifer Lewis, is on magnetic resonance imaging scans for ocular melanoma sufferers in Scotland. At our previous consideration of the petition in June, we agreed to invite NICE and the Scottish Government to respond to the petitioner’s argument that recent clinical trials have brought new evidence to light. NICE considered that it would not be appropriate to comment on any aspect of the petition, as it has not produced guidance on the use of MRI scans for ocular melanoma sufferers. The Scottish Government considered that there is
“currently not sufficient evidence … to enact a change in surveillance protocols for people with ocular melanoma”.
We also invited the Scottish Government to respond to the petitioner’s view that guidelines are interpreted flexibly by centres elsewhere in the United Kingdom, which will provide MRI scans if requested. The Scottish Government presented its understanding that MRI scans are
“offered in a limited capacity in England.”
The petitioner considers that the number of hospitals that offer MRI scans upon referral or request represents
“more than a limited capacity”
and notes that other hospitals elsewhere in the UK will also provide an MRI if the circumstances and concerns with regard to metastasis are explained to them. She contends that that is not provided to patients in Scotland even when they explain the situation.
The Scottish Government provided further information in relation to the formation of a UK-wide group, which
“will share expertise and develop UK wide guidance and recommendations”
to
“ensure a consistent approach to screening and surveillance”.
The petitioner and OcuMel UK have queried the benefit of such a group. OcuMel UK considers that that work has already been completed by the guideline development group, which produced guidelines approved—but not published—by NICE in 2013. OcuMel UK stated its concern that as the new UK-wide group is yet to be formed, it
“could considerably delay any advances in care for patients in Scotland”.
Since late October, there have been further submissions that set out concerns about what are referred to as “negative developments” with regard to the provision of scanning services in Scotland. The concern is that patients are now required to attend local ultrasound appointments rather than go to the specialist centre at Gartnavel. In her submission of 21 October, the petitioner identifies three aspects of the role of the national services division that she feels are not being met as a consequence of the new approach to the provision of scanning services.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for further action?