I thank Ivan McKee for raising this subject in debate today, and I thank all members for their thoughtful contributions. Clearly there is a lot of support across the chamber for the day of the imprisoned writer. Scottish PEN, Amnesty International and others have a crucial role to play in raising awareness of, and showing solidarity with, writers who face persecution for expressing themselves. I join other members in thanking them for their work.
I will come to the central question of freedom of expression shortly. First, I would like to point out my belief that it is the job of Government not just to promote freedom of expression but to promote a broader culture that gives space for literature and writing to flourish. Daniel Johnson reflected on that point and on the precious nature of democracy and our freedom.
Tonight, I will speak at Literature Alliance Scotland’s literary cabaret, which has been established to pay tribute to Scotland’s publishing, festivals, libraries, writers and international activities. It will be a celebratory event and a reminder of the richness in Scotland’s writing talent. Today’s debate is a telling reminder of how not all parts of the world are able to promote and draw on writing so freely.
In Scotland, we defend fiercely the right to say what we think. That is something that we so often assume without thinking, but it is worth pointing out that that right is established and protected in law, both internationally and in Scotland. Following world war two, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which is described as a
“common standard of achievement for all peoples and all nations”,
set out fundamental human rights to be universally protected, including the right to freedom of opinion and expression. Since then, freedom of expression has been given practical effect in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the European convention on human rights. The Scotland Act 1998 and the Human Rights Act 1998 require that Scottish legislation, the acts of Scottish ministers and the actions of public authorities in Scotland all comply with the rights that are contained in the European convention.
We all have an obligation to respect the rights of others, perhaps especially the right to hold views that we disagree with. Pluralism in democracy is vital and fundamental to our individual autonomy and to the health of our society—or any society. That is why the motion is right to highlight the importance of defending and supporting freedom of expression for every person. Gillian Martin focused in her speech on the freedom of expression of a Basque writer.
Last week, in a speech in London, the United Nations secretary general identified winning the battle of ideas as being key in the fight against terrorism. He stated plainly that, when we protect human rights, we are tackling the root causes of terrorism. He spoke of the need to
“invest in ... inclusive societies where diversity is perceived as a richness, not a threat,”
and he urged
“Political, religious and community leaders”
to
“fulfil their responsibilities in promoting a culture of tolerance and mutual respect.”
He underlined the importance of
“standing up for free media and the right to dissent, promoting the rule of law, demanding accountability and justice”,
adding that
“the brave activists and civil society organisations that take on these issues ... are keeping us all safe.”
The legal protections that we have in Scotland are essential in themselves and as statements of a commitment throughout society to uphold this essential feature of any modern democracy. The day of the imprisoned writer reminds us that there is no such commitment in many parts of the world. Indeed, as noted by Reporters Without Borders in this year’s world press freedom index, there has been a significant decline in press freedom in nearly two thirds of the 180 countries. Peter Chapman referred to the situation in Mexico, and the case studies that are highlighted in the index demonstrate that not just journalists but poets, bloggers, novelists, artists and film-makers in Africa, Asia, South America, Europe and the middle east have suffered threats, attacks and imprisonment, and have even been killed for their activities.
In May, I met Ensaf Badawi, whose husband Raif—whom Sandra White referred to—was sentenced to 10 years in prison and 1,000 lashes for setting up a website that championed free speech in Saudi Arabia. In Russia, journalists who seek to uncover issues such as corruption often face threats, violence and harassment. Fifty-eight journalists have lost their lives in Russia since 1992. Andy Wightman spoke about the Russian situation.
Since last year, Turkey has been the world’s biggest jailer of journalists. Ross Greer and Rachael Hamilton set out their concerns about Turkey in their speeches, and Ruth Maguire set out one very personal case. In my last two brief conversations with the Turkish ambassador and consul general, I have raised the systemic issue of imprisoned writers. Tavish Scott is right to urge members of this Parliament to take responsibility not just to debate but to act.
The Istanbul 10, who were detained on 5 July while attending a workshop to discuss ways to continue their human rights work in Turkey’s state of emergency, is of course an issue of massive concern. After months of campaigning by the global Amnesty movement, on 26 October the Istanbul 10 were released from jail on bail. However, Amnesty Turkey’s chair, Taner Kiliç, remains behind bars awaiting trial.
When we consider such people, it is essential that we remember that they are being treated in that way for doing something that we would consider to be normal, acceptable and worthy of supporting and encouraging. It is impossible to overstate the importance of standing with all those throughout the world who make personal sacrifices to defend and uphold human rights. An important part of that is being absolutely steadfast in defence of our own rights and freedoms.
Beyond our borders, we remain determined to promote democracy, the rule of law and fundamental human rights. As we mark the day of the imprisoned writer and reflect on the individuals who have been highlighted by Scottish PEN and others, our shared goal must be to stand with those who suffer in this way and make it our ambition to do all that we can to ensure that freedom of expression is maintained throughout the world. As Ivan McKee said, words matter. Writers matter. This Parliament says that imprisoned writers and their creative minds matter to us.
I am sure that many of us in the chamber would agree with Gandhi, who reflected:
“You can chain me, you can torture me, you can even destroy this body, but you will never imprison my mind.”
Words matter. Writers matter. Imprisoned writers matter to us.
13:43 Meeting suspended.
14:30 On resuming—