I am pleased to have the opportunity to address the committee and bring forward this order as part of a package of measures in an on-going project to update and modernise corporate insolvency in Scotland, particularly the insolvency rules for the winding up of companies currently contained in the Insolvency (Scotland) Rules 1986. The project follows on from the recent modernisation of rules for company insolvency in England and Wales, which culminated in the making of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
By way of background, I should explain that, under the devolution settlement, the law on corporate insolvency in Scotland and the division of legislative responsibilities between the Scottish and United Kingdom Parliaments and Governments is complex. That is particularly true in relation to winding up, which is sometimes known as liquidation. For example, in relation to business associations, the general legal effect of winding up is reserved but the process of winding up is devolved.
In an effort to facilitate the efficient, effective and user-friendly modernisation of the Insolvency (Scotland) Rules 1986, both Governments agreed that it would benefit the petitioners if the rules on Scottish company winding up and any further changes to future Scottish statutory instruments were contained in one instrument rather than being split between a Scottish Government SSI and a UK Government statutory instrument as would require to be the case under the devolution settlement as it currently stands. Furthermore, because of the complexity of the winding-up reservation, it is not always clear whether a winding-up matter can be said to relate to the general legal effect as a reserved matter or whether it relates to process as a devolved matter. It would therefore have been difficult for the Scottish and UK Governments to draft separate winding-up rules that dealt only with matters that fall within their powers.
Accordingly, both Governments have agreed to the preparation of a combined order under sections 63 and 108 of the Scotland Act 1998. Section 63 of the act enables an order to
“provide for any functions, so far as they are exercisable by a Minister of the Crown”
that is, a UK minister
“in or as regards Scotland, to be exercisable ...
(b) by the Scottish Ministers concurrently with the Minister of the Crown”
with the consent of that minister.
Conversely, section 108 of the act enables an order to
“provide for any functions exercisable by a member of the Scottish Government to be exercisable— ...
(b) by a Minister of the Crown concurrently with the member of the Scottish Government
but with the consent of that Scottish Government minister. The order will therefore allow for the mutual conferring of functions between Scottish ministers and a minister of the Crown, so that both have the power to bring forward, as appropriate, winding-up rules or regulations for companies, incorporated friendly societies and limited liability partnerships in Scotland, irrespective of whether those rules or regulations relate to reserved matters under schedule 5 of the Scotland Act 1998 or matters that are not reserved.
Crucially, each Administration must agree to the other Administration exercising any functions conferred by virtue of the order. That approach will enable each Administration to make provision on winding-up matters without any doubts being cast on the scope of the relevant enabling powers.
As noted earlier, we believe that users of the legislation will benefit as the order furthers the aim that rules on the winding up of companies in Scotland will be contained in one instrument rather than being split between two, thereby easing the transparency of regulation in respect of the general legal effect and process. That view is shared by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland in its letter of 30 October to the convener. The immediate intention is that the Scottish Government will, with the consent of the UK Government, take forward an SSI to make provision for winding up in reserved and devolved aspects, as part of the current project to replace the Insolvency (Scotland) Rules 1986 with updated and modernised rules.
Convener, I hope that you and the members of the committee will agree that this is a sensible approach to enabling the modernisation of corporate insolvency in Scotland to move forward in an effective manner, and I believe that it provides an excellent example of the two Governments working together to make the Scottish devolution settlement work for the people of and industry in Scotland.
As set out in correspondence that I issued to the committee on 26 October but which was, I believe, received only yesterday, the order has no wider impact, given that it has been defined narrowly around the issue of winding up. It will make worthwhile improvements and make processes more efficient and effective.
I thank the committee for its on-going support and for taking the time to consider the order. We are, of course, happy to take questions, if that would be helpful.