Thank you for inviting me to attend the committee today. I certainly welcome the committee’s interest in a significant incident that affected a number of health boards in Scotland. It was a global ransomware attack that was aimed at causing maximum disruption to a large number of organisations across the world. However, it is worth acknowledging the extent of the incident across the UK and, in particular, the NHS.
Across the NHS in England, some 47 health organisations were infected with the malware, including 27 acute trusts. In Scotland, 11 territorial health boards, two national health boards and a number of GP practices experienced some impact from the attack, although that impact was less severe than the impact that was felt in England. We have already learned from the attack that swift co-ordination and the sharing of information limited the impact on the NHS in Scotland. We must all reflect on the incident, identify the lessons that can be learned and, more important, share those lessons with partners so that we can help each other to put in place appropriate and effective measures to combat cybercrime.
I again acknowledge the tremendous efforts of NHS staff and the wider public sector in responding to the ransomware attack and providing assurances around the security of their networks. I reassure everyone that there were no reported breaches of patient data or personal details as a result of the attacks. A UK-wide criminal investigation remains under way, led by the national cybersecurity centre and supported by Police Scotland, and health boards continue to fully support those inquiries.
There are a number of lessons arising from the attack that we must learn. Reviews are under way to capture what can be improved in order to reduce the chances of a similar attack happening in the future. The Scottish Government cyberresilience unit will also arrange a lessons-learned exercise to help health boards and other agencies to mitigate the risks from further ransomware and other cyberattacks.
During this time, there was considerable collaboration across the NHS as well as cross-sector engagement. Collaboration at that level is essential and helps to create confidence in the public sector’s ability to respond to such events. Historically, there has been strong collaboration between all e-health leads, e-health infrastructure leads and IT security teams, both nationally and regionally, on IT security issues, with regular meetings being held. NHS National Services Scotland hosts a quarterly meeting called the national information security forum, which is attended by all IT security representatives from each board. They discuss current threats and vulnerabilities and exchange intelligence. That cohesiveness was particularly helpful during the attack, as it allowed security information to be shared quickly and implemented immediately, business continuity ideas to be discussed and good practice to be shared across health boards. Moreover, unaffected boards provided their security expert resource to help those who had been impacted.
Further ideas are being discussed about taking a more national approach to managing IT security across the board and providing systematic and regular intelligence briefings on potential attacks and vulnerabilities. Although we cannot prevent another cyberattack from happening, we will continue to minimise the risk and impact of future attacks.
Initial assessment highlighted that, across health boards, around 1 per cent of devices—around 1,500—were affected. Of that total, some 1,100 were in NHS Lanarkshire, which means that only 400 devices across the rest of NHS Scotland were affected by the attack. Of the 13 boards that were affected in the NHS in Scotland, NHS Lanarkshire felt the most significant impact, but the board took appropriate precautionary action and, along with other affected health boards, put business continuity arrangements in place to ensure that patient services continued to be delivered across the NHS. Although investigations are still under way in NHS Lanarkshire, early indications are that, although the board’s estate and patching regime were appropriate, it had not yet deployed the specific patch prior to the date of the attack. Moreover, it was going through an extensive replacement programme, which is why it was so badly affected. Lessons learned will improve the deployment time of critical patching, and that will be the focus.
There continues to be substantial investment in IT across the NHS. The Scottish Government provides funding of around £100 million per annum to health boards for IT investment and the maintaining of cybersecurity resilience. Health boards spend at least the same amount per annum, although further analysis of health board spending estimates that over £350 million was spent in 2016-17, a similar level of investment is expected this year.
Although the attack was unprecedented in its scope, with hundreds of organisations affected across the globe, it was not an isolated incident. The NHS, along with other organisations, faces similar attacks every day, most of which are thwarted by the controls and protections that are in place. All health boards have IT security frameworks and policies, but the IT environment across health boards is complex, with a mixture of legacy and new systems and technology. Work is continuing to ensure that legacy systems are updated as soon as possible, as developments in technology move on, but some special medical devices still need to run on old IT, and there are challenges around updating them.
Health boards have also put in place appropriate regimes for patching, which is the process of applying fixes from software and hardware suppliers to IT systems in order to improve security. However, I make it clear that the adoption of any patches received from a supplier requires a technical assessment to ensure that there are no unintended consequences for NHS systems. These criminal activities mean that the NHS and other parts of the public sector need to be vigilant and keep their systems up to date and fully protected at all times.
Finally, in response to the attack, the national cyberresilience leaders board quickly convened an extraordinary meeting on 16 May to review the circumstances surrounding the attack and the multi-agency response to it and to identify the next steps to ensure cyberresilience across all sectors. At that meeting, the board agreed to accelerate delivery of a public sector action plan that it had previously been working on to help all Scottish public bodies to develop a shared understanding of and approach to achieving cyberresilience. The board will present the action plan to ministers shortly for their consideration, following which we expect to consult at pace with the wider Scottish public sector on implementation. The plan is expected to include a commitment to develop clear minimum standards of cybersecurity for all Scottish public bodies for implementation during 2017-18 and proposals to provide assurance around higher standards of cyberresilience in key public bodies.
I thank the committee again for the opportunity to be here today, and I look forward to your questions.