I thank the members who have signed my motion. I am looking forward to listening to all today’s speeches, including that from the Minister for Public Health and Sport. I hope that the cabinet secretaries and other ministers with a remit in this area—particularly those with transport and environment responsibilities—will take note of the debate.
In the developed world, we manage our water resources to a high standard to ensure good health, but air is the only environmental common that we depend on every second that we are alive. It is around us constantly and is inextricably linked to our health and wellbeing.
There is much progress to make on improving air quality in Scotland. The British Lung Foundation cites the evidence that air pollution contributes to the death of about 2,000 people a year. I note Professor Dave Newby’s timely research for the British Heart Foundation, which shows the impacts of air pollution on those who live with cardiovascular disease. His research analysed the impact of air pollution on more than 4 million people across 12 European countries who were living with heart failure, and his team found that the hospitalisation risk dramatically increased when the air pollution level was high.
When air quality worsens, that can have an instant and visible effect. A couple of weeks ago, I attended a meeting in Kincardine with hundreds of local residents who were angry about dust clouds blowing off the redundant ash pans at Longannet, which had forced many of them to take refuge indoors. The situation has been remedied, but questions remain about the actions of agencies, and the issue will be the subject of a forthcoming petition to the Parliament.
Much of the pollution that we now encounter is not the visible type that caused the pea-soupers of the previous century or the ash clouds of west Fife. Today, two thirds of air pollution comes from vehicles in the form of nitrogen oxides—NOx—and particulates, so it is clear that the primary focus for action needs to be on tackling the air pollution from transport.
Tomorrow is national clean air day. I congratulate Global Action Plan on its campaign and I congratulate Friends of the Earth, the British Heart Foundation and the British Lung Foundation. They are all doing incredibly valuable work to help us to understand the impacts of air pollution and the changes that are needed to protect our health and environment.
The national clean air day theme of reduce, talk, avoid makes it clear that air pollution is everyone’s business and that we are not powerless to act. We can be mindful of our own impact and reduce pollution by, for example, switching off the car engine when stationary and using our feet for short journeys.
We can talk about air pollution to headteachers, managers, councillors and parents in order to get action at pollution hotspots, whether that is about engine idling or car sharing. On days when the Scottish Environment Protection Agency’s pollution monitoring shows poor air quality, we can take action to avoid areas by walking on side streets and getting out of cars, where pollution levels are further concentrated inside.
Those soft measures are important, and I note that the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform visited a school this morning to highlight awareness. Alongside those measures, we need Government intervention to bring about a step change in our transport and planning systems and cut the pollution that is driving climate change as well as ill health.
Yesterday, we saw that although Scottish climate emissions from energy generation continue to fall, transport has overtaken that sector as the biggest carbon dioxide emitting sector. The exhaust pipe problem is also reflected in the high levels of nitrogen oxides and particulates that line our lungs and enter our bloodstream.
There are 38 air quality management areas designated across 14 local authority areas in Scotland. They are triggered mostly by dangerously high levels of NOx or particulates, and 23 of them remain in breach of the legal limits.
Atholl Street in Perth, which is in my region, is one of the worst streets in Scotland for particulates. The air quality objective that was set in 2002 for Atholl Street should have been met by 2010, but Perth and Kinross Council has persistently failed to address the matter. In fact, planning decisions, including the one that was taken recently to build a vast area of new housing in Scone, continue to be made against the air quality concerns of the local director of public health. Air quality is being ignored in the planning system.
The failure to meet the legal European Union air quality limits has been the subject of a protracted legal challenge against the United Kingdom Government by the organisation ClientEarth. In the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee, we heard recently that the Scottish Government’s strategy was captured by the most recent ruling in the High Court in England, because it appears as a chapter of the UK plan. Given that that ruling was made in December last year, it is disappointing that the Scottish Government did not take the opportunity to consult on a revised Scottish plan.
I welcome much that is in the clean air for Scotland strategy, but there are questions about the level of ambition that is needed to resolve this public health crisis. The introduction of a solitary low-emission zone next year would exclude polluting vehicles from one polluted area of one city. There is now the political will in Edinburgh and Glasgow for implementation, but there are major questions about the preparedness of either city’s council to put the required infrastructure in place by next year. I know that a number of members will want to reflect on that in their contributions.
A bolder commitment to more low-emission zones is needed, but alongside that, other measures can be brought in. Members will be aware of the live consultation on my proposed bill to change the default speed limit in built-up areas from 30mph to 20mph. Studies by Imperial College London show that that can have a positive impact by reducing pollution from diesel engines, but the real prize would be to make a change to the road environment that could be the foundation for an increase in walking and cycling by making our streets safer. Alongside that, prioritisation of walking and cycling infrastructure in the budget would provide facilities to deliver a tipping point in our attitude to active travel and allow us finally to emulate the Copenhagens and Amsterdams of this world.
I look forward to hearing other members’ contributions on how we can solve this public health crisis and I invite the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform to allow those views to feed into a refreshed air pollution strategy for Scotland.
13:22