Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Mental Health (Absconding) (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Scotland) Regulations 2017 [Draft]

Tuesday 13 June 2017 Health and Sport Committee About 09:15–09:45 Subordinate legislation 72 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

72 contributions
Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the 16th meeting in 2017 of the Health and Sport Committee. I ask everyone in the room to ensure that their mobile phones are on silent. It is acceptable to use mobile devices for social media, but please do not take photographs or film proceedings.

Agenda items 1 to 11 are on subordinate legislation. Under agenda items 1 to 10, we will consider five instruments that are subject to affirmative procedure. As is usual with affirmative instruments, we will take evidence from the responsible minister and their officials. Once all our questions about the instrument have been answered, we will have a formal debate on the motion.

The first instrument that we will look at is the draft Mental Health (Absconding) (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Scotland) Regulations 2017. I welcome to the meeting from the Scottish Government Maureen Watt, who is the Minister for Mental Health; Ruth Wilson, who is a senior policy adviser in the mental health and protection of rights division; and Ailsa Garland, who is a solicitor.

I invite the minister to make a brief opening statement.

Maureen Watt SNP The Minister for Mental Health · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Thank you for providing me with the opportunity to speak about the secondary legislation that the Scottish Government is introducing as part of the implementation of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 2015. That act makes changes to the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 to allow service users with a mental disorder to access effective treatment quickly and easily. The 2015 act also amends the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 and the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2003 to improve processes and to introduce a victim notification scheme for victims of mentally disordered offenders.

The implementation of the 2015 act is part of the Scottish Government’s programme to streamline, simplify and clarify the system for the efficient and effective treatment of people with a mental disorder. It does not seek to overhaul mental health law; it simply seeks to make the changes that need to be made to improve further the operation of the law in that area.

When the provisions of the 2015 act come into force, they will build on the existing measures and principles that are set out in the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 to help to ensure that people with mental health problems know their rights, are at the centre of decisions about their own care and are empowered to participate.

There are five affirmative statutory instruments to talk about. One instrument is about the arrangements for patients who have absconded, three relate to cross-border matters, and the fifth clarifies the holding powers for nurses. As each instrument is to be considered individually, I will take a few minutes to explain the particular proposals, including our reasons behind them, before I take questions.

Policy was developed in consultation with stakeholders, and the draft policy proposals for the instruments were discussed with stakeholders before the proposals were finalised. Given the complexity and technical nature of some of the processes, it was not practicable to run a single public consultation. In order to maximise responses, two separate consultations were conducted. The aim was to engage as fully as possible while minimising pressure on stakeholders to consider several topics in one go.

Policy officials set up a reference group, which not only helped to shape the form of the consultations but focused on the implementation of the 2015 act. The reference group consists of a range of stakeholders; its membership includes the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland, the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland, professional groups, service providers and rights, advocacy and service user representation organisations. The group has had a key role in providing advice and recommendations.

The Scottish Government considers that the implementation of the 2015 act and the introduction of the instruments will help to improve the care and treatment of people with mental disorders.

I am happy to discuss the first instrument that the committee is to consider.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Thank you. I invite questions from members.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Sorry, convener, but should I go on and introduce the first instrument?

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Yes—if that is what you were intending to do.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

The first instrument relates principally to the provision of medical treatment to persons who have absconded to Scotland from elsewhere. The regulations have a dual purpose: to provide a process for the return of patients who have absconded from another European Union member state and to allow for the treatment of absconding patients pending their return.

When patients who are mentally disordered are detained in hospital, they sometimes leave without the agreement of the staff or go missing. That can be a concern, because many patients are detained in hospital because they are at risk of harming others or themselves in some way. We propose to make provision that follows the principle of least restriction and allows for such a person to receive medical treatment for their mental disorder. It is envisaged that the provision would be used when the absconding person is likely to be in Scotland for a short period before returning to their home jurisdiction once transport has been arranged. At present, the mental health legislation does not provide a framework to authorise giving treatment to a person who has absconded from detention in another jurisdiction and has been taken into custody pending return. We therefore propose to replicate some of the existing provisions that allow treatment of patients who are detained in hospital in Scotland.

The regulations set out a clear process for considering treatment, which includes confirming that the absconding person is subject to measures that correspond to Scottish measures involving detention. We hope that, in most cases, the person will be returned to their home jurisdiction within a few days. We have focused on what best meets the person’s needs. It would have to be established that the absconding person has a mental disorder and, if they were not liable to be taken into custody under the absconding regulations, it would be necessary to detain them for treatment of that disorder.

I appreciate that one stakeholder would perhaps prefer us to take a different route. For example, it has recommended that absconding persons should be made subject to a short-term detention certificate. We have looked at the evidence in detail and officials have spoken to that stakeholder about its concerns. It acknowledges that a short-term detention certificate may not be appropriate in all cases, and we consider that additional provisions that it has requested are not needed. We are confident that the draft regulations are a suitable and proportionate way of allowing a person to be returned to their home jurisdiction when that is appropriate and to receive treatment for their mental disorder as required pending their return.

In the consultation process, most respondents agreed with our proposals. The best interests of the person should be uppermost in any decision. Under the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003, anyone in Scotland with a mental disorder as defined by that act has the right to access support from an independent advocate. That means that any patient who comes under the absconding regulations would have a right to access support from an advocate. If there was likely to be a longer delay, it would be open to the medical practitioner who was responsible for the person’s treatment to consider whether the person should be brought within the Scottish system.

I am now happy to take questions on the proposals.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

Good morning, minister, and thank you for coming. At the top of your remarks, you referenced the fact that the instruments were produced in consultation with groups of stakeholders. I absolutely accept that, and that may well be the case, but it is clear from briefings that members of the committee have received from the Scottish Association for Mental Health that not all the concerns that were raised in the consultation process have been acted on.

I particularly want to address issues surrounding these regulations. First, the draft regulations allow the responsible medical officer to authorise any person to take someone into custody. Arguably, that definition is vague and does not ensure that the person who is specified will have appropriate qualifications or experience to fulfil the duties. SAMH flagged that up during the consultation process. Why did you decide to omit any qualification threshold for people who can take patients into custody?

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

In general terms, we are aware of SAMH’s concerns. My officials met a representative from SAMH last week, and we thought that we had allayed most of their fears and concerns about the instruments, but after the representative went back and discussed the matter with colleagues, that does not seem to have been the case. Perhaps more reassurance of other people at SAMH is required.

The change is needed because there is currently a difference between the list of persons who can take an absconding civil patient into custody and return them, and the corresponding list for mentally disordered offenders. There is a list of people who can take people into custody, but the new provisions ensure similar specified persons in the two cases by including persons who are authorised by the patient’s responsible medical officer. The policy objective is to make both approaches similar to allow an RMO to authorise a person to take a mentally disordered offender into custody and return them to the hospital or other place from which the patient absconded. The accompanying code of practice will make clear which factors an RMO should consider when specifying a person.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

The regulations are subject to affirmative procedure, so we cannot amend them. You are asking the committee to rubber-stamp something with which not all of us are entirely happy. I do not see how the Government position would be weakened by redrafting and amending the regulations to include the word “qualified” and delineating in the subsequent guidance exactly what is meant by “qualified”, otherwise that could be open to interpretation and it might be misused.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Qualified persons are already specified. They include members of hospital staff, mental health officers and constables. The addition will allow the RMO to make a decision about the suitability of a person to take an absconding patient into custody and return them to hospital or another place from which they have absconded. The accompanying code of practice will make clear what matters an RMO should consider when specifying a person.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

With respect, just listing groups of people who can do that does not specify what qualifications they should hold or what expertise or experience they should have. I am not satisfied that that qualification threshold has been met.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Does one of my officials want to come in on that? The RMO will always take the decision at the end of the day.

Ruth Wilson Scottish Government
link

The addition will allow an RMO to use their judgment on who should fulfil the role of taking a person into custody. The RMO will look at who from the prescribed list is best placed at that moment.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

The human judgment element causes me concern. Just saying that hospital staff can take somebody into custody without specifying qualifications might lead the RMO to infer that any member of hospital staff could perform that role. Given the distress that the person in question might be in—they might have been without their medication, usual treatment and support for some time—there could be a particularly charged situation that requires a very finessed skill set. We have not covered that by just saying that it is up to the RMO and the person can be anyone from the hospital staff.

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

The amendment in the draft regulations simply replicates the system that we have at the moment for civil patients. We have the list that includes a mental health officer, a constable, a member of staff of a hospital and any other person who has been authorised by the RMO. We are simply replicating that for offenders who have absconded within Scotland and therefore leaving flexibility for the RMO to consider who is most suitable at the time, as my policy colleague said.

09:30

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

I am all for giving the RMO flexibility but I want parameters around that flexibility, and I do not understand the problem with bottoming that out in guidance and using the word “qualified” so that RMOs can discharge that responsibility confidently.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

As Ailsa Garland said, the provision brings the situation into line with the system for other patients. We are talking about very few people—people who are in danger of being a risk to themselves or to others. I think that you will agree that speed might be of the essence in some cases: we need to quickly ascertain what the problem is and make sure that the person is given the best possible treatment and returned from whence they came as quickly as possible.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

I do not question that. Speed is obviously important. However, when people have to make speedy decisions, they often make the wrong ones. I just want to protect the RMOs and the patients they are dealing with. If that means bringing the system into line with the system for domestic patients, perhaps the system for domestic patients needs to be tightened up. I am still not happy with the regulations.

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

I clarify that the amendment is just about domestic offenders who have absconded in Scotland. We are amending two different sets of regulations and replicating what is in the civil system. RMOs already make decisions that they think are appropriate for civil patients, so we are creating a similar system. I am not sure whether we are aware of issues around the making of such decisions for civil patients at the moment. We are simply replicating the system for offenders.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

I do not think that we are going to reach agreement on this, but I am not satisfied that that qualification threshold has been reached.

If I may, convener, I will move on to the other problem that SAMH raised about medical treatment for people who have absconded from jurisdictions outwith Scotland. As the regulations stand, the Government is proposing to treat people over several days without the same authorisation under mental health law that would be provided for someone who is resident and receiving treatment in Scotland. People who abscond to Scotland could be subject to prolonged detention and treatment without a right of appeal, which could be seen as an infringement of their human rights. The issue was raised in the European Court of Human Rights through a case in Finland. In its judgment, the court said:

“forced administration of medication represents a serious interference with a person’s physical integrity and must accordingly be based on a ‘law’ that guarantees proper safeguards against arbitrariness.”

In that case, those safeguards were missing. How confident are you that, if such a case were brought before the European Court of Human Rights, it would not be found similarly wanting?

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

The case of X v Finland involved a quite different set of circumstances and did not relate to absconding. We are content that the regulations provide significant safeguards in relation to the treatment of those who abscond to Scotland from other jurisdictions. Such medical treatment can be given only when the absconding person is subject to a measure in their home jurisdiction that corresponds to certain Scottish measures involving detention, all of which contain safeguards for the patients involved. Additionally, the absconding person needs to be medically examined before treatment is given. It needs to be established that they have a medical disorder, that they would need to be detained for the purposes of receiving treatment and that without treatment there would be a significant risk to the safety and welfare of the absconding person or to others.

On the safeguards, our mental health legislation is rights based, and we have sought to reflect that in the regulations. For some individuals, compulsory treatment is used to provide medical treatment to alleviate suffering and to protect the person and others and, as you know, compulsory treatment is allowed only in strictly controlled circumstances. Absconding patients are covered by the same safeguards.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

Okay. Going back to the judgment in X v Finland, we cannot hypothethise about the circumstances in which that would be applied under Scots law in terms of individual circumstances that might occur in relation to patients absconding to Scotland with regard to the regulations.

You talk about the approach being based on mental health legislation. The problem with that is that no protection under mental health legislation is afforded to patients who abscond to Scotland, because they are excluded from the provision of treatment authorised under the 2003 and 1995 acts. The regulations set out that the Scottish Government therefore proposes to provide treatment to patients without those protections. In other words, despite what you said about the work that was done and the agreement that was reached about the use of short-term detention certificates not being appropriate, that is, effectively, what we are talking about.

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

The Scottish Government is completely committed to maintaining human rights in Scotland. There is a clear system in the absconding regulations. I do not think that it is quite correct to say that, because they are set out in regulations rather than in primary legislation, there are no procedures and safeguards.

A number of checks need to be done before someone can be given medical treatment. It has to be established that they have a mental disorder and that were they not liable to be taken into custody it would be necessary to detain them to give the treatment. All of that has to be decided by a medical practitioner, who must also consider whether, without treatment, there would be some risk to the safety of the patient or others. There is then a process whereby certain sections of the 2003 act are applied and modified so that they work appropriately for absconding persons. I therefore do not think that it is correct to say that there is no scheme or system or that there are no safeguards. All of that is set out in detail in the regulations.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

My fundamental point is that absconding persons are not afforded the same rights and protections as Scottish citizens, who are protected by primary legislation. I cannot see why we cannot change the regulations to give them those same protections.

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

Our position is that, as I said, a clear system is in place for those people. The fact that it is in regulations rather than in primary legislation does not mean that it is a lesser system. I take your point that they will not receive treatment under the 2003 act—I think that that is one of SAMH’s issues—but they will receive treatment in accordance with the conditions and requirements in the regulations. We feel that there is a clear system there.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

Access to justice is key. I would be anxious that people who are not protected by primary legislation, who will be dealt with through the hodgepodge of provisions in the regulations, will not have the same access to justice that they would have had if they had been protected in the same way that Scottish patients are protected under primary legislation.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests. I am a registered mental health nurse, and I am one of probably only two people around the table who have worked with mental health legislation in practice.

What rights does someone who has absconded and is now in the care of a Scottish mental health facility have in terms of accessing advocacy and making complaints to the Mental Welfare Commission, and what rights do they have in general? Alex Cole-Hamilton has raised concerns in that regard, so it would be helpful if the minister could clarify what those rights are and where those people currently stand in that regard.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

The 2015 act builds on the rights and duties in the 2003 act, including the right to access support from an independent advocate. The new provisions will require local authorities, health boards and the state hospital to provide information to the Mental Welfare Commission on how they currently exercise their duty to collaborate and to secure advocacy services for people with a mental disorder, and how they plan to do so in the future. That will help to ensure that information on the provision of advocacy is easily accessible and that independent advocacy is provided, as it should be. The Scottish Government will continue to work with the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland on the implementation of the new provisions. As far as I understand, the commission is broadly in agreement with the instruments.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Anyone who is detained under mental health legislation in Scotland has additional support through a mental health officer, who oversees the process. Are there any plans for mental health officers to oversee any part of the regulations?

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

There is no statutory role for an MHO under the regulations, as persons will not be detained under the 2003 act. However, the statutory guidance will set out best practice in terms of how the clinical team will engage with social work.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Thank you for that reassurance.

Alex Cole-Hamilton has raised concerns about RMOs deciding who would take someone back into custody. I have personal experience of fulfilling that role. My understanding is that, in the vast majority of cases, the role would fall to registered mental health nurses and nurses who work on the ward from where the patient absconded or who are part of the wider clinical team, such as community staff who have worked with the patient. Will the regulations lead to any changes in who fulfils that role? Do you envisage that similar people, with similar experience and levels of qualification, would be involved?

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

The system would be absolutely the same. I bow to your practical knowledge in the field—you are absolutely right.

Colin Smyth Lab South Scotland
link

Good morning. Under the current process, if someone requires further treatment over a longer period, doctors are required to issue short-term detention certificates—Alex Cole-Hamilton made that point. What are the disadvantages of maintaining that system?

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

A patient who is made subject to a short-term detention certificate is effectively brought into the Scottish system. To be transferred back to their home jurisdiction, they would have to go through the cross-border transfer process, which might involve a lengthier process than would otherwise be the case. However, as I have said, by allowing medical treatment to be provided under the absconding regulations, we are setting out a clear process for that treatment and the conditions under which it can be given, and when the patient is medically fit to return to their own country that can be done without any delay.

Colin Smyth Lab South Scotland
link

How many people are we talking about? There may be only a few such patients—I think that that is what the minister said—but you say that you require to change the system.

Ruth Wilson Scottish Government
link

No official statistics have been kept, but you will see from the evidence that has been submitted, and we know from own evidence gathering, that we are talking about limited numbers. We need to be clear that, at the moment, there is no provision for such medical treatment and that is what the regulations will introduce. People have been doing a workaround, which is why the issue of STDCs came into play. As Ailsa Garland pointed out, a consequence of putting such people on STDCs is that most will be in Scotland for a longer period.

Alison Johnstone Green Lothian
link

I have been listening to the discussion with interest, but I am still not entirely clear how the minister will ensure that the person authorised by a responsible medical officer to take someone into custody will have the appropriate experience and qualifications. I am also still not clear why we do not have a prescribed list. Furthermore, I am really concerned that one of our foremost mental health organisations has such reservations about the proposals. It has provided follow-up evidence to the committee in which it says that it remains concerned that the regulations do not include an appeals procedure and that they provide

“no access to a Mental Health Officer for people who will not be familiar with the law”.

I ask the minister to address those issues.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Ruth Wilson may want to take the question on someone being available to patients.

09:45

Ruth Wilson Scottish Government
link

All patients will have the right to an independent advocate. As part of that service, the advocate will ensure that the patient is aware of their rights. The treating clinician will also have a role in ensuring that the patient is aware of what is happening to them and what rights they have.

Alison Johnstone Green Lothian
link

Do you believe that there should not be a prescribed list? I am trying to understand your point. I cannot understand why you do not agree with what SAMH is asking for.

Ruth Wilson Scottish Government
link

There is an existing list of prescribed categories of people; we are simply adding a new line to allow an RMO to say who, in the circumstances, would be the best and most qualified person to take a patient into custody.

As Ailsa Garland said, we are equalling up what happens to those who are involved in mental disorder offences and who are likely to abscond during the transfer process with what already happens in civil cases.

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

You raise a couple of different issues. The first issue, which we have discussed, is the addition of RMOs to the list of people who are able to authorise people who they think are suitable to take an offender into custody.

SAMH has raised separate concerns. For example, with regard to the Finnish human rights case that we have discussed, SAMH feels that there is a lack of proper process. We are saying that there is a process set out in the regulations that we feel is sufficient. It allows someone to be returned fairly speedily to their home jurisdiction, which would probably be best for them in the circumstances, rather than having them remain in a country that is not their own.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Depriving somebody of their liberty is a huge step. For me, the issue is the reference to “any” person. A number of us have a problem with that, and the Government really needs to reflect on it. Do you recognise that that is a problem?

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

Two different issues are being amalgamated. The RMO issue is simply about adding to the list of people who can take an offender into custody for the purposes of returning them. That relates to absconding offenders in Scotland.

We are extending the existing regime for taking into custody and returning absconding persons to people from other EU member states, and we are allowing for medical treatment, which the 2003 act currently does not provide for.

While I have the floor, I should reiterate that we are using powers in the 2015 act to expand the regulation-making powers so that we can provide specifically for two different categories: first, we are extending the regime to people from the EU who abscond and, secondly, we are applying to all absconding persons the ability to be provided with medical treatment. That was fully debated as part of the bill process, and I submit that we are not doing anything particularly unusual in relation to the new powers that we have, as revised in relation to the 2003 act.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

The second element that I am concerned about is the fact that, for those who abscond to Scotland, there is no legal right to challenge treatment and no right of appeal. I have a fundamental problem with that.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

SAMH suggests that the regulations offer the possibility of deprivation of liberty for an unlimited period without appeal. We have no reason to expect that that would be the case. We have made clear from the outset our intention that the absconding regulations should be subject to specific conditions and that any treatment should be given only for a short period of time. We would hope that, in most cases, absconding persons will be returned to their original jurisdiction within a few days. We have consulted on the issue, and there was no clear consensus from respondents on what the relevant time period should be. That takes us back to your question about a short-term detention certificate.

Because there is a range of variables, for example whether the person is well enough to travel and what transport arrangements have been put in place, each case would be different, and there would have to be a clinical decision on what was best for the particular person. That will be supported by guidance to determine the best course of action. That is why we are saying that it would be inappropriate for the regulations to specify a time limit.

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

To clarify, we are talking about absconding people who are subject to measures equivalent to Scottish detention measures in their home jurisdictions. It is not that we are taking them into custody as an initial measure. They are already subject to measures in their own country, they have come to Scotland and it has been established that they have absconded. They are taken into custody for the purposes of return. So it is not—

Ailsa Garland Scottish Government
link

Thank you.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

I accept that the matter is extremely complicated, especially as most of us were not involved in the passage of the 2015 act. If the committee wishes, we could have an informal briefing to set out the issues in more detail and perhaps to answer more questions.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Thank you for the offer. We will consider that.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

I would prefer to do that and to take the proposals away, rather than see the motion go down. That would not help anybody with the act.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Do you want to take the motion away?

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

I have heard what only a very few members feel about the regulations.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

We are about to move to the debate on the SSI. We can have the discussion, and it is up to you whether you then withdraw the motion.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Well, if you want to have the discussion.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Thank you. Item 2 is the formal debate on the affirmative SSI on which we have just taken evidence. I remind the committee that members should not put questions to the minister during this formal debate, and officials must not speak in the debate either.

Motion moved,

That the Health and Sport Committee recommends that the Mental Health (Absconding) (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Scotland) Regulations 2017 draft be approved.—Maureen Watt

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

I am grateful for the clarity that the minister and her officials have sought to bring, yet it has not given me satisfaction that the concerns that have been outlined by fellow committee members and by SAMH in its briefing to us have been met. I do not think that an informal briefing on the technical aspects of the 2015 act would assuage that. I do not think that what is being asked of the Government by way of taking the regulations away and redrafting them is particularly onerous. I do not think that that will jeopardise the thrust or spirit of what the Scottish Government is trying to do.

If anything, what has been suggested will improve the instrument and will offer protection for both staff and patients regarding the observance of human rights, rather than leaving us open to future litigation at a European level.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

I am speaking about this subject with a background of professional knowledge. I hear the concerns that some of my fellow committee members have, but I would offer them the reassurance about professional judgment being used in all areas and about the patient being at the centre of all care in mental health. That is how all healthcare professionals practise. The proposals are not as big a change to legislation as people might feel them to be. In practice, the proposals are about expediting patient care and, potentially, providing better safeguards, if people are currently practising outwith the guidance.

Alison Johnstone Green Lothian
link

I cannot help but think that the regulations could be improved. The committee has raised concerns about the fact that the RMO would be able to authorise anyone to take an absconded person into custody, so clarity around the prescribed list would be helpful. We have also heard concerns about safeguarding people’s rights, the fact that no appeals procedure is outlined, the lack of access to a mental health officer and the fact that there is no mention of independent advocacy. Members have also raised concerns about the issuing of short-term detention certificates. I feel that the regulations could be brought back to the committee in an improved form.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

I want to touch on what Alison Johnstone said. To date, we have worked hard to ensure that all legislation is built using a rights-based approach, but the regulations do not feel right in that regard. The convener raised two points, on challenging treatment and the right to appeal. We would all appreciate it if the SSI was rewritten to take those two points into account.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Minister, in reflecting on what the committee has said, do you still wish to pursue the motion?

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

Alex Cole-Hamilton perhaps wants the whole 2015 act to be revisited, but we are not in a position to do that. The subordinate legislation is bringing the act into play. As my officials and I have said, it is absolutely rights-based legislation. Further details will be set out in the code of practice—

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

Minister, we are very short of time, so I really need you to decide whether you want to withdraw your motion or pursue it.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

I will press the motion.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

The question is, that motion S5M-05753 be agreed to. Are we agreed?

Members: No.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

There will be a division.

For

Haughey, Clare (Rutherglen) (SNP)

Todd, Maree (Highlands and Islands) (SNP)

Against

Briggs, Miles (Lothian) (Con)

Cameron, Donald (Highlands and Islands) (Con)

Cole-Hamilton, Alex (Edinburgh Western) (LD)

Findlay, Neil (Lothian) (Lab)

Johnstone, Alison (Lothian) (Green)

Smyth, Colin (South Scotland) (Lab)

Abstentions

Arthur, Tom (Renfrewshire South) (SNP)

Gilruth, Jenny (Mid Fife and Glenrothes) (SNP)

McKee, Ivan (Glasgow Provan) (SNP)

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

The result of the division is: For 2, Against 6, Abstentions 3.

Motion disagreed to.

Neil Findlay Lab The Convener · Lothian
link

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the officials accompanying the minister to change.

09:58 Meeting suspended.

09:59 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 72
  2. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  3. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  4. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
  5. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
  6. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
  7. 09:45 Integration Authorities’ Engagement with Stakeholders and Draft Budget 2017-18 Committee business · 99
  8. 11:15 NHS Governance Committee business · 120

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.