Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Wild Animals in Travelling Circuses (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

Tuesday 6 June 2017 Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee About 10:00–12:00 Bill scrutiny 235 contributions · 16 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

235 contributions · showing 201–235
Martin Burton Association of Circus Proprietors of Great Britain
link

I seat 1,000 people and charge £15, but I would still close down very quickly if you fined me £5,000.

Emma Harper SNP South Scotland
link

I want to go back to wild animals. You are talking about herbivores versus carnivores, and herbivores are more easily domesticated. Are we really worried about big cats because they are carnivores? Are you suggesting that they are domesticated? I have seen video evidence in which the lions seem to be a bit perturbed and unwilling to participate. If you engage in training or taming them, do you use positive or negative reinforcement to engage them in a behaviour that you want them to engage in?

Martin Burton Association of Circus Proprietors of Great Britain
link

Anthony Beckwith is best qualified to answer your question. I have a question, though. Do you know when that video evidence was filmed? Things have changed. I was part of Mike Radford’s review for the UK Government and we refused to accept video evidence. What we often see, and what we have seen as part of the committee’s process, is talk of dressing up animals, which certainly used to happen. People used to goad lions with wooden chairs, and there would be cracking of whips and the lion would smash the chair to bits. We also used to put children up chimneys to clean them. The world has moved on.

I visit circuses two or three times a week and I cannot tell you the last time I saw an animal dressed up. Forty years ago, people would put a poodle in a dress and even get it to push a pram, but that is not what happens now. We must not forget that the public pay good money to see a circus and they choose not to see that sort of thing. They choose not to see an animal act in which the animal is annoyed; nowadays, instead of a male with a ripped shirt cracking a whip at a lion, they would rather see a female cuddling and kissing the lion. I am afraid that many people do not understand, when they look at video evidence from films that were made 40 or 50 years ago, that we have moved on.

Emma Harper SNP South Scotland
link

I do not think that the evidence was from 40 or 50 years ago, but I accept the point that some of the evidence that might be on YouTube—

Martin Burton Association of Circus Proprietors of Great Britain
link

The caveat is that I am talking about English training. There are still parts of the world where not everybody has moved into the 21st century.

Anthony Beckwith An Evening with Lions and Tigers
link

As I mentioned earlier, our show is about education. It is a training display in which we demonstrate the training methods that are used. Emma Harper talked about negative and positive reinforcement. Those words are often misused. People think that negative reinforcement is something bad—for example scolding or hitting an animal—and that positive reinforcement is about praising and rewarding it, but that is not the case. In optimum conditions, positive and negative reinforcement mean the addition and removal of stimuli. Offering an animal a reward or stimulus is positive reinforcement, and taking it away is negative reinforcement.

There is also positive and negative punishment. Positive punishment would be abuse of an animal, and hitting it and scolding it, which we do not do. We use the addition and removal of praise and reward.

We have filmed all our training and it is available on our Facebook page, so you can see how it is done. No whips, chairs or pistols are involved, as there would have been in the old days. We use bamboo garden canes with bits of horse or chicken meat on the end, and the animals are encouraged to follow the sticks. They are not chased—we do not run after the animals. We get the animals to follow us. To get a big cat to lie down, we put a stick in front of it and pull it across the floor. Just like a house cat would, it goes after the stick. We then get another stick and give it a bit of meat. It is the same when we get them to jump. It is always about encouraging the animals to follow us; there is no fear or dominance involved. It is a working relationship. As Martin Burton said, the approach is not to fight the animal or have a stand-off with it. Part of our act includes the male lion licking Thomas’s face, which the lion does of his own free will. Thomas does not force the lion’s jaw open and put his head in its mouth, which might have happened 60 or 70 years ago. It is very different now—it is a display of the relationship that man and animal can have, rather than a display of dominance over an animal, as it would have been a long time ago.

Alexander Burnett Con Aberdeenshire West
link

I refer to my entry in the register of members’ interests.

My question is for Martin Burton. You said that there have been no wild animals in circuses in Scotland in the past 12 months and only two in the previous five years. What economic impact will the bill have?

Martin Burton Association of Circus Proprietors of Great Britain
link

As other witnesses have told the committee, the danger is that the definitions are not clear. Clearly, the economic impact on circuses with wild animals that already do not come to Scotland will be zero. However, the economic impact on animal displays in shopping centres, on hawk and wild bird displays at outdoor shows, on Santa displays that use reindeer and, eventually, on zoos will be massive. That is the direction that the legislation is going in—it will eventually close your zoos.

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

I would like to pick up on that point. There is a gentleman who owns camels, and he is great with them—he looks after them extremely well. He travels around county shows, including shows in Scotland. He leaves home with his camels inside a big truck, pulling his living wagon behind him. He also does pig racing. His staff come along with the wagon with the pigs in it, pulling a living wagon behind them, and they have another living wagon that is pulled by a car. He travels in England from one county show to another, throughout the summer months. He gets to the show the night before it opens, because he has to sort out all his camels and make sure that everything is all right. He pulls from the side of his truck a big tent awning that is supported by posts. If the weather is bad, everything is enclosed. He takes his camels out and he ties them to the side of his lorry. He builds the pig fence, and the pigs come out and go into that area.

During the show, that gentleman does camel polo. You can play polo on a camel in a ring—the ring is obviously bigger than a circus ring. He does pig racing in a straight line. He does camel rides in a ring, and camel racing in a straight line. He stays at one show for a couple of days, when he moves to the next one. He might stop on the way if there is a week between the shows. That is what he does during the summer months. Why is that so different from what the circuses do? How can you justify saying that that is not a circus, given that you are saying that a circus is something that uses a tent and has performances in a ring to entertain the public.

Graeme Dey SNP The Convener · Angus South
link

Your analogy would be dependent on which type of camel was being used, given the evidence that we had earlier.

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

I am sorry, but I cannot hear you.

Graeme Dey SNP The Convener · Angus South
link

In terms of definition, the bill is concerned with wild animals in circuses. Going back to the earlier evidence that Mr Beckwith gave us, whether the legislation applied to those camels would depend on the type of camels that they were.

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

He uses the same camels that the circuses use—Bactrian camels.

Anthony Beckwith An Evening with Lions and Tigers
link

All camels in captivity are the domesticated type; there are few wild camels left. The dromedary camel is completely extinct in the wild, and there is only a small population of Bactrian camels left in the wild—it is an endangered species. There is a feral group of camels in Australia, but they are bred from domestic lines. Certainly, all the camels in captivity are domesticated.

Graeme Dey SNP The Convener · Angus South
link

I recognise the point that Rona Brown is making but, according to that evidence, those camels would not be covered, because they are not wild animals.

Carol MacManus Circus Mondao
link

So can I come here with my wild animals in my circus, once the bill is in force? Are my two camels wild animals?

Graeme Dey SNP The Convener · Angus South
link

It would depend on the definition.

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

Is it just the word “circus” that we have a problem with?

Graeme Dey SNP The Convener · Angus South
link

No. The bill concerns wild animals in travelling circuses. My point concerns clear definitions. I understand the point that you are trying to make, but the camels that you are talking about would not be covered, because they are not wild animals.

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

But then neither are the animals in Peter Jolly’s circus or Carol MacManus’s circus.

Martin Burton Association of Circus Proprietors of Great Britain
link

The bill refers to animals that are domesticated in the UK, which does not include camels.

Anthony Beckwith An Evening with Lions and Tigers
link

The definition of “wild animal” that I gave is the scientific definition, but the definition in the bill is an animal that is not usually domesticated in the UK. Those two definitions are completely different. There are animals that are farmed in the UK quite extensively that come under the taxonomy of “wild animal”, such as ostriches, crocodiles and so on—

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

Wild buffalo.

Anthony Beckwith An Evening with Lions and Tigers
link

Yes, and the American bison. There are domesticated animals that we would class as wild for the purposes of the bill but which actually are not wild, and there are other animals that are wild but which would not be covered by the definition in the bill, because they are farmed in this country quite extensively. I think that between 10,000 and 15,000 ostriches are farmed in the UK every year but they are classed as wild animals. They are not domesticated, but they are farmed in the UK.

12:00

Richard Lyle SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I have two questions, the first of which is for Martin Burton. I was at Blair Drummond safari park on Sunday with my grandkids. It was excellent, apart from some showers. We went in to see a seal show. Two seals came out, performed tricks and clapped their fins to get people clapping. I have been at the penguin parade at Edinburgh zoo. Could the bill be the start of all those things being done away with because people—

Martin Burton Association of Circus Proprietors of Great Britain
link

Well—

Richard Lyle SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Let me finish, Martin.

Could it be the start of all those things being done away with because people are concerned about animal welfare? I am for animal welfare. The fact that I am the convener of the cross-party group on the Scottish Showmen’s Guild does not mean that I am on your side, guys. I am on the side of what is best for animals.

Martin Burton Association of Circus Proprietors of Great Britain
link

I said at the outset that I am an animal welfarist, too. However, once we start banning things, particularly on ethical grounds, it will clearly spread. If it is not ethically right to have a wild animal in a circus, it is not ethically right to have a wild animal appear at a gala, at a county show, in a shopping centre or in a zoo. That is clearly and logically the only way that an ethical ban can go. You cannot choose your ethics. You will say either that it is ethical or that it is not ethical.

Richard Lyle SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

My last question is for Rona Brown. Over the past number of years, as the convener of the cross-party group on the Scottish Showmen’s Guild, I have come across showmen. You are not Gypsy Travellers; you have your own ethnicity. Do you see the bill as an infringement of your ethnicity and your right to work?

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

Yes, I do. There are several laws that would cover that, such as the right to travel under European Union law, of which it would fall foul.

Incidentally, Peter Jolly Sr is a member of the Showmen’s Guild and has been ever since he started.

The bill would be an infringement of rights, particularly for smaller circuses such as Carol MacManus’s, which is a family circus, and Martin Burton’s. It is like you are saying that it is unethical just because you can. Why ban the use of wild animals in circuses just because you can and without reason, when the circuses are not doing anything wrong? We know right from wrong. We know that it is wrong to beat animals. Why have a ban if the circuses are not doing that or leaving animals out in the cold? If they are doing those things, yes, you should say that they cannot come here and are banned. However, if they are not, it would be an infringement of the workers’ rights.

What will a family like the Jollys do? They do not outsource or buy in acts—not the aerial acts or anything. The whole family does the show; nobody gets hired in. They did outsource once, but it was only once. Everything revolves around the animals. They all take turns with training. They have a little educated pony. The children come in and the ringmaster asks how old they are. He asks their name and asks the pony how old it thinks they are. The pony goes tap, tap, tap with its hoof. That is training. The public love it. They love it when the camels come in. They absolutely love to see the fox on the back of the donkey.

Rona Brown Circus Guild of Great Britain
link

Foxes are indigenous to the UK, but according to DEFRA they are still wild animals and have to be licensed. There is also a macaw—a type of parrot—that talks and does things, and the Jollys also do educational talks in the zoo after the show. When the show finishes, people go out and look at how the animals live and are fed. The Jollys do not talk about elephants in Africa or Asia or whatever people talk about in Deep Sea World or Sea Life; they talk about a little zebu that they have, where it comes from, what it does, how it came to be at the circus and what its background is. The same goes for the fox, the camel and the zebras. That is what these people do. In my opinion, it would be grossly unfair to class all circuses in the same way.

Graeme Dey SNP The Convener · Angus South
link

Just to wrap this up, I note that Ms Brown mentioned zebras. Given what Carol MacManus told us about her two zebras and the behaviour that they exhibited, can wild animals become domesticated over a period of time?

Carol MacManus Circus Mondao
link

Why not? Three months ago, I took on a young horse. We had to castrate him because he was quite wild; I cracked my ribs unloading him, and another time he kicked someone in the face. We have never had that with our zebras. Which, then, is the wilder—the wild horse that is actually domesticated or the wild zebra that appears to be more domesticated than the horse?

Graeme Dey SNP The Convener · Angus South
link

On that thoughtful note, I conclude the session by thanking the witnesses from this and our other panels. You have given us a lot of questions to take away with us, and the evidence has been very useful from our point of view. Thank you for your time.

At its next meeting on 13 June, the committee will take further evidence from stakeholders on the Wild Animals in Travelling Circuses (Scotland) Bill, as well as evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform on the draft Prohibited Procedures on Protected Animals (Exemptions) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2017, after which we will consider motion S5M-05754.

As agreed, we move into private session. I ask that the public gallery be cleared as the public part of the meeting is closed.

12:07 Meeting continued in private until 12:55.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:45 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 44
  3. 10:00 Wild Animals in Travelling Circuses (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 235

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.