Yes, please, convener. Good morning, everyone. I very much welcome the opportunity to present and explain this Scottish statutory instrument to the committee. Its amendments form part of European law and they must be incorporated into member states’ domestic legislation by 16 May. Failure to transpose would expose Scotland and the United Kingdom to the risk of infraction.
In transposing the directive into law in Scotland, I have sought to achieve an appropriate balance between ensuring that our approach to creating woodland protects the environment and biodiversity, and creating an enabling approach to planting for businesses and communities.
As we are all aware, creating woodland and planting trees is a win-win for Scotland, particularly in helping to achieve our ambitious climate change targets, with trees soaking up about 10 million tonnes of CO2 a year.
The change that I understand is causing concern relates to increasing the threshold for environmental impact assessments for forestry projects outwith sensitive areas, and I want to reassure members by putting the change in its proper context and by making it clear that it is not happening in isolation. The SSI introduces another change that expands the definition of sensitive areas to include peaty soils. Because there is no threshold for afforestation in sensitive areas, all such schemes must be screened. Moreover, in national scenic areas, the threshold remains at 2 hectares.
The proposal to increase the threshold for an environmental impact assessment from 5 hectares to 20 hectares outwith sensitive areas is modest and proportionate, given the pressing need to increase woodland creation in Scotland. Although Wales and Northern Ireland are not proposing to change their threshold, members might wish to note that the corresponding legislation in England proposes an increase to 50 hectares for low-risk areas. I also point out that, since 2000, only five out of 800 schemes below 20 hectares have required an environmental statement following EIA screening. In other words, we are talking about a maximum area of 100 hectares over those 17 years.
The legislation will not result in a reversion to planting up the flow country. That cannot happen. The new regulation expands the definition of the sensitive areas where EIA is always required to include peaty soils, and it applies only to very small schemes. That suggests that there is little risk in increasing the threshold to 20 hectares. Raising the threshold will also enable better deployment of staff resources, which should be focused on encouraging more and larger schemes to come forward while ensuring that they are monitored to better address the environmental impact of genuinely difficult and potentially damaging schemes. It means that we will be better placed to manage and minimise the potential impact of planting.
The change in threshold will also send an important signal of the Government’s—and indeed Parliament’s—commitment to increasing planting and to diversity in woodland creation schemes. We know that concerns about the EIA process can deter potential applicants for modest, low-risk schemes. That particularly affects farmers, the very group whom all parties are encouraging to integrate more woodland into their enterprises. It might also affect crofters.
I reassure members that good protections against the risk of these small schemes causing environmental harm will remain. Legislation includes provision for exceptional cases, allowing Forestry Commission Scotland still to require an environmental statement or to take enforcement action on a small project of less than 20 hectares. The ability to take such enforcement action is an important safeguard. I also note that the vast majority of 5 hectare schemes are likely to cost more than £25,000 and that, in reality, very few planting schemes are undertaken without grant funding. The procedures for grant approval require all the appropriate checks against the UK forestry standard to ensure that environmental risk is mitigated. Mr Callaghan, who is an expert on that, can fully explain all those matters if members feel that that would be useful.
New guidance that will be developed on implementing the amended regulations will be clearer and will ensure that proper scrutiny is given to genuinely higher-risk schemes. Initial discussions on such guidance are already under way with Scottish Natural Heritage and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, which support the change, and we would welcome input from wider stakeholders such as Scottish Environment LINK. That work will complement the relevant workstreams in the Mackinnon report delivery plan. We can also do more to raise awareness of the guidance and our expectations of those who propose planting schemes to ensure that developers and communities are clear about their responsibilities in safeguarding and protecting the environment in which they propose to create woodland.
I hope that my remarks address the concerns that have been raised and will help to persuade committee members not to annul the SSI. Planting more of the right trees in the right places is something that I think we all support. We need to focus our effort where it is needed, and the proposed change will allow us to do just that. My colleagues and I are happy to answer any questions that you, convener, and committee members may have. Thank you for that opportunity.