Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Consumer Confidence

Portfolio Question Time Economy, Jobs and Fair Work

Wednesday 29 March 2017 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 17 contributions · 7 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to the latest Fraser of Allander Institute Economic Commentary, which warns that indicators of Scottish consumer confidence are more negative than for the United Kingdom as whole. (S5O-00841)

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

The latest Fraser of Allander Institute Economic Commentary provides a timely update on the Scottish economy. The report shows that, as Brian Whittle said, consumer sentiment has weakened in Scotland, but it has also weakened in the United Kingdom since the European Union referendum. The findings highlight the risks to Scotland’s economic outlook following the EU referendum as heightened uncertainty and rising inflation are forecast to weigh on household incomes and consumption. By far the biggest threat to Scotland’s economy is a hard Brexit, which, according to the Fraser of Allander institute, threatens to cost our economy around £11 billion a year by 2030 and to cost the country 80,000 jobs over a decade.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Perhaps the cabinet secretary can explain why the Scottish economy is lagging behind the UK economy on a range of economic indicators. We have lower employment, higher inactivity, lower consumer confidence, lower annual pay growth, lower productivity and lower growth in gross domestic product. Why is Scotland falling behind under the party that claimed to be “stronger for Scotland”? I wonder whether something is distracting the Government from the day job.

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

The member will of course be aware of the impact of the price of oil on the Scottish economy and the fact that it would have a disproportionate effect on the Scottish economy as opposed to the wider UK economy. The member asked what my response is. My response is to go out and try to attract more jobs, because that is very important for the Scottish economy. I saw that 300 new jobs in digital solutions and risk management were announced today by Genpact for its new European centre in Glasgow following a contribution by Scottish Enterprise. It is extremely important that we try to attract more such jobs; indeed, that is part of my job title.

The member mentioned different economic indicators. There are other indicators that tell a different story. We in Scotland have the second-lowest level of youth unemployment in Europe; only Germany has a better outcome. We also have very good numbers on female employment, and the same unemployment rate, despite the oil impact, as the rest of the UK. That shows real progress.

The member mentioned confidence. Today’s edition of The Times mentions the Scottish technology industry survey, in which 78 per cent of respondents said that they were optimistic or very optimistic for this year. We should try, difficult though it might be, to accentuate the positive and see the things that we are doing well. Of course we should note the challenges, but we should try to do more of what we are doing well. That is the best response that we can have to the economic challenges that Brexit presents for us.

Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link

Being part of the UK has not done much for Scottish national self-confidence over generations. Can the cabinet secretary tell us what the impact of the alleged union dividend has been on Scotland, given that since 1900 we have had the lowest rate of population growth of any country on earth?

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

I would tell Kenneth Gibson that if I was able to identify a union dividend, but I am afraid that I cannot see a union dividend. More than that, there is the price of the union, if we think about the huge recession that we went through, which was caused by failures of the banking and financial system under the UK. Of course there were global elements to that, but there is no question but that the regulation of the banking system was inept and it was crucial that the UK looked after that.

The consequences of that recession for Scotland, by which I mean individuals and companies in Scotland, were huge. The UK has to accept its share of the responsibility, as I am accepting the Scottish Government’s share of the responsibility for the condition of the Scottish economy. After all, it was a Conservative MSP who said that the UK still holds all the major levers of the Scottish economy, so the UK has to take responsibility for that.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Is it not the truth that the same Fraser of Allander report noted that

“a second independence referendum is likely to act as a further headwind for many businesses and potential investors”?

Is it not also the truth that the UK market is worth four times that of Europe to the Scottish economy, so the impact of independence has the potential to be much greater than that of leaving the European Union?

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

It is true to say that the Fraser of Allander institute identifies and quantifies the effects of a hard Brexit as the loss of £11 billion a year by 2030 and of 80,000 jobs over a decade. It is interesting that Jackie Baillie decided not to mention that when the report that she cites, and the institute that she refers to, says that those will be the impacts. There has not been a word from Labour about those huge impacts on the Scottish economy.

On the recession that we have just come through, it was the Scottish Government’s actions in investing in public infrastructure works that helped to mitigate the worst effects and helped us to recover more quickly. [Interruption.]

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

Those actions are important to sustaining the economy and it would be useful if members could acknowledge that. It would also be useful if the Labour Party could acknowledge the serious effect of Brexit—£11 billion a year and 80,000 jobs—which it has failed to do on many occasions up to now.

Dean Lockhart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The cabinet secretary asked about the union dividend. I point him to the Scottish Government’s own Government expenditure and revenue Scotland numbers that last year showed a £15 billion union dividend.

The Fraser of Allander institute highlights that, since the SNP came to power, Scotland’s economy has grown by an average of 0.7 per cent per year during the past 10 years. That is less than a third of Scotland’s long-term economic growth. That underperformance is nothing to do with oil and nothing to do with Brexit. Does the cabinet secretary think that such underperformance over 10 years of SNP Government is acceptable?

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

I can imagine businesses outwith the chamber listening to someone who is talking about economics say that the rate of growth in Scotland has got nothing to do with oil. They must wonder how we even start to respond to a point like that.

It is quite obvious to me that there is not the basic understanding of the Scottish economy implicit in the question. It is also true that I did not raise the issue of the union dividend; somebody else raised it and I responded to that point in the way that I did.

It is important to make sure that we do the right things through the economy. Martin Gilbert of Aberdeen Asset Management said that we should look through the fog to see where the opportunities are.

I will just mention the 300 new jobs that are coming to Glasgow, which received not a word of joy or congratulations from any of the Opposition parties. They have also not said a word about the increased confidence in the Scottish technology industry survey. Those are important for Scotland. As I have said many times, we have to recognise the challenges of productivity, internationalisation and exports. I recognise those challenges and am trying to take action to address them. Surely some of the Opposition parties could acknowledge the strengths of the Scottish economy, even if it is just to encourage them, so that we can all get the benefit of increased economy activity in Scotland.

Mike Rumbles LD North East Scotland
link

The minister said that he could not identify any union dividend. Could he identify a union dividend—in his case in the Royal Marines and, in my case, the Army—for the protection of the whole of the United Kingdom together? Does he accept that there is a union dividend in our approach to defence?

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

It is sort of related, cabinet secretary. Briefly, please.

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

Once again, I just cannot understand the lack of information or experience. If we look at the defence footprint of Scotland in recent years—

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

Well, maybe Mr Rumbles does not think that it is relevant. We have seen regiments on front-line service being merged, people being handed their P45 when they are on active service, basing cuts, and reducing numbers in Scotland. The member would know that if he talked to the local authorities that are trying to wrestle with the latest round of basing cuts, such as those at Fort George, or Glencorse, a barracks that has had millions of pounds of investment but is going to be closed.

The lack of knowledge in Mike Rumbles’s question shows that he has no understanding of defence activities in Scotland. Before he asks another question like that, perhaps he should do a bit of homework.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Independence Referendum (Assessment of Support) Questions · 12
  2. Local Government Budgets (South Scotland) Questions · 10
  3. Glasgow City Council (Budget Allocations Assessment) Questions · 6
  4. Digital Strategy Questions · 4
  5. Digital Scotland (Investment) Questions · 6
  6. Coatbridge and Chryston (Jobs and Economy) Questions · 6
  7. Music Industry (Economic Contribution) Questions · 6
  8. Economic Support (Dingwall) Questions · 4
  9. Consumer Confidence Questions · 17
  10. Scottish Investment Bank (Meetings) Questions · 5
  11. Education Debate · 45
  12. SinoFortone and China Railway No 3 Engineering Group Memorandum of Understanding Debate · 57
  13. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  14. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 1
  15. Decision Time Decision time · 14
  16. Rotary Clubs (Champions of Change Awards) Members’ business · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.