I thank the member for North East Scotland, Mike Rumbles, for raising the matter. I hope that my cold does not affect members’ ability to understand me.
The motion follows on from the parliamentary question on the same subject that the Minister for Local Government and Housing and I answered last week. It would be inappropriate for me, as the Minister for Business, Innovation and Energy and someone who is involved in the consenting process, to express a view on the proposals for an overhead line, which might come before the Scottish ministers for determination in the future. However, as Mike Rumbles outlined, it is now in the public domain that the proposals that the motion refers to were recently reviewed by National Grid under its annual network options assessment and that it has been recommended that the transmission company should not proceed further with developing its proposals at this time.
Mike Rumbles has asked Parliament to note the motion that the National Assembly for Wales passed on 18 January, which Liam Kerr and other members picked up. I confirm that, as Mr Rumbles indicated, the Scottish planning policy that was published in 2014 already states that consideration should be given to underground grid connections where possible. However, I have noted the point that he and other members, such as Mr Lochhead and Mr Kerr, made and I undertake to reflect on it. I can make no promises at this point, but I will listen to the views that have been expressed.
The Scottish planning policy is clear that international, national and locally designated areas and sites for landscape and nature conservation should be identified and afforded the appropriate level of protection in development plans. Rhoda Grant made fair points on the impact of undergrounding on archaeology and natural heritage, and that has to be taken into account in the process.
For national designations, the policy states:
“Development that affects a National Park, National Scenic Area, Site of Special Scientific Interest or a National Nature Reserve should only be permitted where:
the objectives of designation and the overall integrity of the area will not be compromised; or
any significant adverse effects on the qualities for which the area has been designated are clearly outweighed by social, environmental or economic benefits of national importance.”
I appreciate that a lot comes down to semantics and interpretation of language, but I reassure members that there is at least protection to prevent unacceptable damage.
Our national planning framework, NPF3, identifies a high-voltage electricity transmission network as a national development. That is vital to meeting our ambitious targets for renewable electricity generation, tackling climate change and achieving energy security—basically, keeping the lights on. However, the design and construction of network infrastructure are the responsibility of the network owners—Scottish and Southern Electricity Networks and SP Energy Networks—in conjunction with the system operator, which is National Grid. As electricity network costs are recovered from existing and future electricity bill payers, it is the role of the regulator—the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets—to scrutinise and approve network investment plans in order to protect consumers’ interests.
Having said that, I note the concerns that Mike Rumbles, Richard Lochhead, Alexander Burnett and others have expressed about the degree of community consultation. I reassure members that we greatly value community consultation and expect full commitment to it.
The Scottish ministers require any application for electricity infrastructure from transmission companies to provide detailed evidence of community consultation, and I expect that consultation to be meaningful. The application must also demonstrate how consultation has informed the applicant’s preferred options and clearly explain what mitigation measures it has identified to address local community concerns. I will pay heed to such matters in my deliberations.
I note the fair points that Mr Lochhead made about taking into account the wider impact of other connecting infrastructure at Blackhillock, and other sites across Scotland, from substations of the proposed scale. I will ask officials to brief me on sites of that nature so that I can consider the points of detail for policy on them.
I thank Mr Rumbles for providing me with an opportunity to outline how Scottish Government policy already supports and protects areas with national designations; to provide an overview of the planning and regulation of electricity networks; and to highlight the importance of the Scottish Government’s commitment to involving local communities in decision making.
We understand that—whether in response to Mr Rumbles or because of other drivers—the transmission company had envisaged submitting an application in relation to the proposals that the motion refers to no earlier than 2019. As National Grid has now indicated, the development of the proposals is not optimal at this point. My officials will continue to engage with the network companies to discuss all engineering options, including overhead lines, undergrounding, subsea cables—a number of members referred to them and they are of particular interest—and ancillary technologies.
I take on board the points that Rhoda Grant made about subsea cables and reassure her about our intentions around island communities. I expect that to be on the agenda at the convention of the Highlands and Islands this coming week. Energy strategy and issues to do with interconnection for the islands have been hot topics in our engagement with the island authorities and the United Kingdom Government.
I take Rhoda Grant’s point about environmental impacts. The process is not always straightforward, and we look carefully at the environmental impact of subsea cables that are laid, but they generally provide what is deemed to be a pretty good solution to problems of connecting such infrastructure.
Members might wish to arrange meetings with National Grid, and I can ask my officials to provide relevant contact details if they are needed. I appreciate that some colleagues have access to National Grid already.
I thank Mike Rumbles for bringing this important issue to the chamber. I reassure members that we will always take into account communities’ views on such matters, and I will look to work with members across the chamber to ensure that our policy is always as supportive as it can be of communities’ concerns.
Meeting closed at 17:39.