To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on GP practices in the most deprived areas receiving more resources per patient than those in less deprived areas. (S5O-00585)
Official Report · Chamber
General Practitioner Practices (Resourcing)
Portfolio Question Time Health and Sport
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Shona Robison SNP 4
- John Mason SNP 2
- Johann Lamont Lab 1
- Donald Cameron Con 1
The record
8 contributionsTackling health inequalities is one of our primary care outcomes, as recently published in a joint memorandum with the British Medical Association. Adjusting the Scottish allocation formula, which weights general practice funding by various factors that affect workload—not least deprivation—is one way that could deliver that outcome.
We also need to look beyond the general practitioner contract to other interventions and ways of supporting general practice in areas of high deprivation. That is why the Government has committed to increasing the number of link workers who support general practice.
The BMA is in a difficult situation, because it supports GPs in rich areas and in poor areas. I wonder whether we should put more emphasis on deep-end practices in poorer areas, because they deal with much greater health needs and multimorbidity. GPs in such practices need to spend a lot more time with individual patients.
John Mason makes a fair point, but I am confident that we can get agreement with the BMA to ensure that there is solid recognition of deprivation in the allocation of resources to the practices that operate in our most deprived communities. Deprivation is one factor that increases demand on GP resources, so the Scottish allocation formula is weighted to help practices in deprived areas.
We are investing in projects such as the deep-end pioneer scheme to support GPs who work in very deprived areas. That is in addition to our investment in primary care more generally. An additional £500 million will be invested over the parliamentary session, which means that there will be a big shift in national health service front-line spending to our community and primary healthcare services.
The Scottish allocation formula has been reviewed and is under review, and we are commissioning a further review of GP pay and expenses. Alongside the renegotiation of the GP contract, that will help to address some of John Mason’s concerns.
I emphasise to the cabinet secretary the concern that the current formula for GPs in deprived areas has the unintended consequence that they have less time to meet, talk and work with needy patients. Doctors have said to me that, although link workers might be part of the process, they are concerned that the current funding approach means that, while GPs can give people drugs, they have less time to spend with people. In fact, such patients do not need tablets; they need somebody who properly understands their condition. Will the cabinet secretary make a commitment to look again at how that is taken forward? It is a genuinely bizarre situation when the doctors who are under most pressure are less well funded.
Johann Lamont has raised the issue a number of times in the chamber. I reassure her that, as part of our negotiations with the BMA, the Scottish allocation formula has been reviewed. We are commissioning a further review of GP pay and expenses because we need to understand more of the detail in order to look at the contractual agreements.
In addition, there is more general work that is geared towards addressing workload issues, which will help GPs who work in deprived communities, as well as GPs overall. As that will mean that GPs will be able to spend more time with patients who have complex issues, there will be a benefit for those who work in deprived communities, given that many of their patients have complex multimorbidity issues on which more time needs to be spent.
I recently met a link worker who is attached to a GP practice in East Ayrshire. They made clear the importance of ensuring that GPs are able, through link workers, to connect patients to local services, whether those are mental health or other services. I am convinced that the link worker role will make a tremendous difference in helping to ensure that patients get to the right place.
The cabinet secretary mentioned the financial commitments to primary care, but a lack of clarity remains about where that resource will be targeted. The chair of the Royal College of General Practitioners Scotland, Dr Miles Mack, said that it presents an
“opportunity to ... lessen the effects of the inverse care law, under which those most in need of healthcare have least access to it.”
Will the cabinet secretary today give details of where those sums of money will be targeted?
I reiterate that, in the next financial year, we will invest £72 million in improvements to primary care and GP services, against the backdrop of our commitment to invest an additional £500 million over the current session of Parliament. That is a huge shift in investment, which I hope that Donald Cameron welcomes.
As for where that money will be spent, we have set out our priorities, which include reducing workload, improving recruitment and retention, and building multidisciplinary teams that can work together to see and help patients, with a GP as the clinical expert who supports each team. That model has support from the BMA and, I believe, from the RCGP.
I am happy to continue to provide detail as we take the issues forward. Our work represents a big transformation in the way in which primary care is delivered, but it will very much benefit patients.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 25 Jan 2017 →- Alzheimer’s Disease (Link with Air Pollution) Questions · 10
- Health Inequalities (Pregnancy and Postnatal Period) Questions · 8
- Rural General Hospitals (Recruitment of Physicians and Surgeons) Questions · 12
- NHS Fife (Funding) Questions · 4
- Badminton (Participation of Young People) Questions · 6
- Health Advice (Accessibility to People with Hearing Loss and Deafness) Questions · 6
- General Practitioner Practices (Resourcing) Questions · 8
- Sport (Participation) Questions · 4
- Ninewells Hospital (Electrical Wiring) Questions · 6
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Supreme Court Judgment (Article 50) Statement · 32
- Draft Budget 2017-18 Debate · 153
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 16
- Celebrating Burns and the Scots Language Members’ business · 22
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.