Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Home Detention Curfew Licence (Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2016 [Draft]

Tuesday 22 November 2016 Justice Committee About 10:00–10:15 Subordinate legislation 43 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

43 contributions
Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Under agenda item 2, the committee will further consider the draft Home Detention Curfew Licence (Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2016, which is an affirmative Scottish statutory instrument.

I welcome the Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs, Annabelle Ewing, who will speak to the SSI. With the minister are Linda Pollock, who is deputy director of the community justice division of the Scottish Government; Quentin Fisher, who is also from the community justice division; and Craig McGuffie, who is from the Scottish Government’s directorate for legal services. I welcome them, too.

I thank the minister and her officials for providing the statistics that the committee requested last week and remind members that officials are permitted to give evidence under agenda item 2, but they may not participate in the formal debate on the order under agenda item 3.

I refer members to paper 1.

Does the minister want to make an opening statement?

Annabelle Ewing SNP The Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs · Cowdenbeath
link

Good morning. In the circumstances, I simply refer to the opening statement that I made last week.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Okay. Do members have any questions? We have additional information and time to look at the SSI.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

I, too, thank the minister for providing additional information.

I recognise that a relatively small number of people are affected, but I still have concerns that the broader principle sends out the wrong signal to both offenders and the wider public. At a time when we are looking to enhance community sentencing, there is a danger that breaching such sentences is not seen to have consequences, and that undermines the process. Can you give any further reassurance on that, minister?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

On the wider policy objectives, as I mentioned last week we are looking to remove exclusions from the possible granting of a home detention curfew—that granting is by no means automatic—to certain categories. We discussed that in detail last week. I refer to those who have, in effect, committed a new offence while out of prison and before the end of their sentence and those who have breached licence conditions, including HDC conditions, while out of prison.

We can see the potential scope from the figures that have been provided to the committee. The figures have been updated to 21 November 2016 to help the committee’s deliberations. We can see that the numbers involved are not substantial. It must also be pointed out that the possible individuals who could be brought within scope would be eligible for consideration, but that does not mean that they would be granted an HDC. It is important to put that on the record.

On the wider objectives, we seek to encourage rehabilitation, reintegration into communities, the building of family relationships again, and reintegration by facilitating individuals’ productive contributions to society while they are on an HDC with the ultimate objective, of course, of reducing reoffending. That is the key principle to note. I am sure that we all wish to see a reduction in reoffending.

Finally—I stressed this point quite considerably last week—the risk assessment that is carried out is robust and puts public safety at its very heart to ensure that, if HDC is granted, the decision takes into account public safety as a primary consideration, looking at such issues as possible reoffending and the likelihood of reintegration into society.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

I wonder whether the Scottish Prison Service, in making those decisions, might face pressure to go ahead and release people back into the community to help manage the prison population, rather than looking as rigorously as the minister suggests at the needs of the offender and the concerns that communities might have.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I do not accept that. With regard to longer-term prisoners, the assessments are carried out not simply by the SPS but by the Parole Board for Scotland. Would officials like to comment further on that suggestion that the SPS would factor in prisoner number management in its risk assessment?

Linda Pollock Scottish Government
link

As the minister said, for longer-term prison sentences, the Parole Board would agree the halfway point. It is also worth noting that criminal justice social work do part of the risk assessment in the community. The SPS takes its job very seriously and does risk assessments very thoroughly; the prison population is not a factor that would come into that, but the risk profile of the offender—whether there is a risk to the public and a risk of reoffending—is a factor. Criminal justice social work looks at the risk of the person returning to the community, in particular the house and the home that they would be returning to. The risk assessment that is undertaken is very thorough.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

Finally, I ask again about ministerial oversight. Mr McGuffie provided answers to the committee last week, but I am concerned at the suggestion that Scottish ministers would have a role and might be involved at an administrative level. Can the position be further clarified this week?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

The point that was made was that the Scottish Prison Service acts as the executive agency, with delegated authority. A framework agreement is in place between the Scottish Government and the SPS, which is on the SPS website; it gives a broadbrush explanation of how the direction of policy is to be implemented. With any authority that is delegated, control can ultimately be taken back; as a matter of practice, that is not the case. Again, I ask officials to clarify further details.

Linda Pollock Scottish Government
link

What the minister says is correct. Delegated authority is given to the chief executive of the SPS; that is published in the framework agreement, which members can find online. It states all the areas in which the SPS has delegated authority. In instances such as those that we are discussing, as we have just gone through, the SPS people look at the risk assessment; they work with the offenders daily, and it is right and proper that they make the recommendation and the decision.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

Do you envisage any scenario in which the cabinet secretary or a minister would be involved in an individual decision?

Linda Pollock Scottish Government
link

The power has been delegated to the chief executive of the Prison Service. The chief executive is accountable to ministers, who are accountable to the Parliament, but the day-to-day management and operation of the prisons is done through the Prison Service.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

To be absolutely clear for the record, the position that was set out last week—that ministers would be involved at an administrative level—is incorrect.

Linda Pollock Scottish Government
link

This is just restating what was said last week.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I thank the minister for bringing the statistics to the committee. I was heartened to see that only 6 per cent of recalls from HDCs are due to reoffending. Does the minister agree that that proves the validity of the system, and that the system works?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Yes. The latest reoffending statistics for this year thus far show that we are at a 17-year low in reoffending; that indeed shows that policies concerning, inter alia, HDC make a difference and facilitate rehabilitation and reduced reoffending. I am sure that we all wish to see a reduction in reoffending; electronic monitoring in the form of HDC allows us to do that.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I must say that I have some reservations, minister. Six per cent is a percentage but we are talking about individuals who have committed crime and are out on licence, who have a home detention curfew and have breached licence conditions but who are seen to be again given another chance. Where does it leave victims and all the people who have seen the original sentence being imposed only for automatic early release to kick in when, despite the condition being breached, or even another crime being committed, the offender is still at liberty?

My position is that the original statutory exemptions were there for good purpose. They provide a very strong deterrent and reinforce the seriousness of breaching the conditions. If we had wanted to look at this—and we want to encourage community disposals where they are appropriate—that should have happened as part of a wider debate on community justice. For that reason, I am not too happy about the proposal.

Does anyone else have any comments?

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Minister, I note from memory that reoffending by released prisoners, which I believe is calculated as another offence being committed within two years of a prisoner’s release, is of the order of about half or thereabouts. Do you have that figure to hand? In that context, a figure of 6 per cent—albeit that it covers a different timeframe than the two years—stands very good comparison with the population released from prison as a whole. Furthermore, I think that the reoffending rates for those who receive community sentences are also substantially ahead, so one could almost argue that if only every other way in which we dispose of prisoners were as successful as this one, we would be very happy indeed. Is that correct?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I agree that the stats on HDC show that there is a relatively low level of reoffending. That is to be welcomed and it is indicative of the fact that HDC is an important tool that is open to community justice partners to facilitate reintegration into the community and—I return to this point—reduce reoffending.

I will pick up on an issue that the convener raised. I think that I made this point at last week’s meeting. The working group included Scottish Women’s Aid, which was an active participant in the deliberations and signed up to the final report, which included inter alia the recommendation that those hitherto excluded categories of individuals should now be included in the possible grant of HDC. I state again that HDC is by no means automatic; it is subject to a robust risk assessment on the grounds that I have explained.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

Supplementary to what the minister has said, a concern was raised about the scope and breadth of the examination of the issue. My understanding is that the working group comprised the Scottish Prison Service, the police, independent researchers, social work practitioners and a representative of Scottish Women’s Aid. It encompassed 16 months of work and international evidence was also looked at. To me, that seems like a robust and extremely thorough examination of the issue prior to the working group making a proposal.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I think that I made the point last week that there had been substantial engagement. The final report was informed not only by the statistics that were made available to the working group, but by international evidence, other academic research, the engagement that Ben Macpherson spoke about—at both national and local level—and the expertise and knowledge that the individuals concerned brought to their 16-month deliberation.

For the sake of completeness, in addition to the members that Ben Macpherson mentioned, in the working group’s lifetime its membership included a representative from the Judicial Institute for Scotland, the head of the parole unit, and representatives from the violence reduction unit and the national offender management unit. Also included were the Police Scotland specialist crime division and the centre for youth and criminal justice. There was, therefore, available to the working group a panel of experts in their field and front-line practitioners. That illustrates Ben Macpherson’s point that this was an extensive look at the issue.

10:15

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

I want to follow up Stewart Stevenson’s comments. I suspect that what we are doing here is managing risk and 6 per cent does not necessarily seem to be the threshold of success. I am sure that everybody who is involved would look to bring that figure down if they could. Nevertheless, if we were to demand a figure approximating 0 per cent, we would be asking for a guarantee that would be unrealistic in most of the other endeavours that we embark on.

I suppose that, as a Government, you will be looking at how the proposal operates in practice and if the 6 per cent figure were to be nudged upwards with a change in the process over time, I presume that you would look at why that was happening and potentially make alterations accordingly. Is that a fair assessment?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I think so, yes. The member makes a fair point. We cannot guarantee 0 per cent even though we would like to. In every human endeavour, it is always difficult to guarantee a 100 per cent success rate. However, the figures show that the risk is being managed well in relative terms.

Officials look at the statistics regularly. Last week, Mr Finnie raised an important point that was also raised by the working group. How can we better support individuals who are in those circumstances to facilitate compliance? There will be a demonstration pilot project on the current plans for that very issue early next year. That is an important element of how we are seeking to improve the rates further as the member would like.

Fulton MacGregor SNP Coatbridge and Chryston
link

As an ex criminal justice social worker, it would be remiss of me not to challenge some of the perceptions about HDC being an easy option for offenders. It is a robust system and a crucial part of the process of moving offenders from prison back into the community, as the minister has said.

Members might like to know that research clearly indicates that, when prisoners come straight out of prison into the community, reoffending rates are much higher. That is a comment for the record, convener.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

There are no further comments or questions for the minister. Minister, do you want to make a closing statement?

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

In that case, we move to the next item, which is formal consideration of motion S5M-02127.

Motion moved,

That the Justice Committee recommends that the Home Detention Curfew Licence (Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2016 draft be approved.—Annabelle Ewing.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I remind members that the 1991 white paper on criminal justice that the Tories introduced contained the memorable quote that prison is

“an expensive way to make bad people worse.”

We should support anything that gets people out of prison and keeps them out.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you for that contribution. By way of riposte, I repeat that, given the report that we have seen, it is regrettable that the proposal, which has been brought to Parliament under the affirmative procedure, has not been the subject of a parliamentary debate on the wider issue of community justice.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am conscious that there has been no attempt to curtail any debate. We have heard a range of views here, so it is not the case that there has been no debate. The Scottish Green Party strongly welcomes the proposal; as the minister says, it is an option and it is about reintegration.

I would be concerned if unintended offence were to be taken by the wide range of participants who are behind the report. I suspect that a small minority of people might see the proposal as controversial. However, when an organisation such as Scottish Women’s Aid, which has victims’ interests at the forefront of all its deliberations, shares a collective view on the proposal with front-line practitioners, for me that makes a compelling case, and I will certainly lend my support to the proposal.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I agree entirely with Mr Finnie’s comments. It is important to put on the record that individuals from various spheres have put an awful lot of their time into this; that includes those from important victims organisations such as Scottish Women’s Aid, and I think that their opinions should be listened to.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you, minister. The question is, that motion S5M-02127, in the name of Annabelle Ewing, be agreed to. Are we agreed?

Members: No.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

There will be a division.

For

Baker, Claire (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Lab)

Evans, Mairi (Angus North and Mearns) (SNP)

Finnie, John (Highlands and Islands) (Green)

MacGregor, Fulton (Coatbridge and Chryston) (SNP)

Mackay, Rona (Strathkelvin and Bearsden) (SNP)

Macpherson, Ben (Edinburgh Northern and Leith) (SNP)

McArthur, Liam (Orkney Islands) (LD)

Stevenson, Stewart (Banffshire and Buchan Coast) (SNP)

Against

Mitchell, Margaret (Central Scotland) (Con)

Mundell, Oliver (Dumfriesshire) (Con)

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The result of the division is: For 8, Against 2, Abstentions 0.

Motion agreed to,

That the Justice Committee recommends that the Home Detention Curfew Licence (Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2016 draft be approved.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

As there was a division on the motion, are members content for me, as convener, to clear our final report, or would they prefer to see the report before it is cleared?

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you.

I suspend the meeting for a change of witnesses.

10:21 Meeting suspended.

10:22 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 10:00 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 43
  4. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8
  5. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
  7. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  8. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  9. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  10. 10:30 Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service Committee business · 198

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.