I thank colleagues for the cross-party support that has allowed the debate on island health boards to take place. I look forward to hearing the contributions of those who participate, including the minister.
I was slightly surprised that no Scottish National Party MSP felt able to support my motion, even though it says nothing that is unduly controversial. In the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport’s recent response to me and my colleague, Tavish Scott, she reasonably accepted many of the same points. She acknowledged the
“unique nature of the islands”,
that NHS Orkney and NHS Shetland are
“very distinct communities”
and that the
“respective NHS services are experienced in the demands of serving those populations”.
As I set out why our island health boards deserve protection, I am encouraged by what appears to be a decent amount of common ground between me and the health secretary.
Nevertheless, the First Minister’s intention, as set out in her programme for government, to
“examine the number”
and
“structure ... of health boards”
has had alarm bells ringing in Orkney and Shetland. From my conversations with those who are directly employed in delivering health and care services in Orkney, as well as with the many members of the public who have been in touch with me in recent days, there can be no doubting the strength of feeling or the determination to resist any dilution of local control.
Some of those concerns will not be confined to the island communities that Tavish Scott and I represent, because all the evidence shows that large-scale structural changes inevitably distract attention from the day-to-day business of delivering services. Those changes can affect morale and organisations’ ability to recruit and retain staff, and the savings that are often used to justify them invariably prove elusive, if not illusory. Anyone who doubts that need only look at what has happened since the Government decided to create a single, centralised police force. Five years on, surely only Kenny MacAskill believes that that has been a success or that it has delivered what was promised.
A review of how health boards are performing is prudent. Given the crises in many areas of health and care provision, a review is perhaps overdue, but I caution against believing that structural reform is the answer to the maiden’s prayer. Certainly for rural and island areas, such reviews tend to signal a retrenchment of services and decision making into the centre. That matters, not least to those who rely on those key services. At NHS Orkney’s annual general meeting earlier this week, the local patient group voiced its opposition to NHS Orkney being subsumed within a larger board that serves a wider geographic area. Preserving NHS Orkney’s identity is important as that identity shapes the ethos, priorities and approach of the organisation.
Little wonder that there is such anxiety in the islands at what might be lost in any move to centralise services and decision making. Bringing together different boards with different identities—or even different priorities—offers no guarantee or much likelihood that island needs would be effectively heard, understood or—far less—met. Moreover, it would remove the ability to be nimble in responding to local needs, to develop services that best suit island circumstances in conjunction with communities and to enhance the skills of staff in ways that ensure both quality and breadth of provision.
This is not an isolationist approach. Island health boards already work collaboratively with counterparts on the mainland. NHS Grampian is the obvious example with respect to the northern isles, but there may be opportunities in the future to work with others in providing specialist treatment that it would be impractical to deliver in an island setting.
Here again, though, I sound a note of caution. If the Government plans to merge mainland health boards, it must take account of the impact on all patients. For example, recent problems that affected the oncology department at Aberdeen royal infirmary meant that some Orkney and Shetland cancer patients were offered treatment in Dundee and Glasgow. Although the treatment might have been exceptionally good, if they are to go outwith Aberdeen, isles patients face more complex travel arrangements and limited access to the support structure that CLAN Cancer Support and the Red Cross provide in the north-east.
Far from the services that are available in the islands being reduced, I want them to be increased. That ambition is shared by NHS Orkney, staff, patients and local communities, which see it as crucial to their efforts to attract and retain people and effectively serve their populations. The recent decision to locate a computed tomography scanner in Orkney is a case in point. I know from speaking to the staff involved that it has already made a big difference in terms of early diagnosis, allowing more effective treatment and improving and in some cases saving lives, which justifies the long, hard-fought campaign.
More is possible. Telehealth opens up opportunities to increase the availability of treatment in Orkney, as it reduces the need for patients to travel south or even to travel within Orkney. For those who live in the smaller isles, the option of a consultation in their local surgery, supported by their general practitioner or nurse, may appeal a great deal more than getting on a boat or a plane and travelling into Kirkwall, particularly during the winter months. Such an approach can therefore help to improve patient care, reduce travel and accommodation costs, unlock economies of scale and open up more interesting career paths for those who work in health and care services in our islands.
That point is important given the challenges that are faced in recruiting and retaining staff in remote and rural settings. The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh shone a light on that in its report last week. There are no easy solutions, but we need to do more to give those who are in training a taste of what island working has to offer. We need to develop a workforce that is comfortable across a range of general skills rather than training ever more specialists, and we must ensure that more isles students can access Scottish medical schools. Widening access needs to be about rurality and not just about poverty. At the same time, there is no escaping the fact that financial incentives will play a part in the equation as well.
Delivering good-quality health and care services in our islands to a population that is living longer but with more complex conditions presents enormous challenges, and meeting them is beyond the gift of any health minister. We also need decent transport links, for example, including reliable air services—I note that the Minister for Transport and the Islands is by Maureen Watt’s side, which is helpful—together with good mobile and broadband coverage, the need for which is routinely and compellingly raised by GPs and nurses throughout my constituency. Those factors and others fundamentally affect the way in which health and care services are delivered in Orkney and, in turn, that has a fundamental bearing on the economic wellbeing and sustainability of the islands that I represent.
My plea to the minister today is to ensure that the review—it would help to hear a little more about the timeframe and the process that are involved—protects island health boards and recognises their unique status and the risks that are inherent in submerging them in larger, less responsive or less accountable set-ups. Failure to do that would drive a coach and horses through the Government’s commitment to island proofing. More important, it would undermine the ability of health and care provision to be tailored to the specific needs of our island communities. That cannot and must not be allowed to happen.
12:54