Thank you for inviting me to give evidence. I will begin by saying a few words about the perhaps less debated of the two statutory instruments under consideration: the one that applies to second homes.
As the explanatory note describes, under the present legislation a council may grant a discount of between 10 and 50 per cent of normal council tax liability in respect of a second home. The draft Council Tax (Variation for Unoccupied Dwellings) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2016 seek to extend that flexibility to allow a council also to decide to grant no discount in respect of second homes—in other words, to charge the full council tax on second homes.
In that context, a second home is defined as a dwelling that is furnished and lived in for at least 25 days in any 12-month period but not as someone’s sole or main residence. That is distinct from, for example, dwellings that have been unoccupied for more than 12 months, to which separate legislation continues to apply unchanged. Importantly, the draft regulations do not seek to alter the treatment of properties where the owner or tenant is required by their job to live elsewhere—for example, members of the armed forces living in barracks.
More than 27,000 properties are defined as second homes in Scotland. If enacted, the draft regulations would give councils additional flexibility and autonomy to address local circumstances while raising an estimated £3 million.
The draft Council Tax (Substitution of Proportion) (Scotland) Order 2016 seeks to do one thing only: to increase the amounts of council tax payable for properties in bands E to H by 7.5 per cent, 12.5 per cent, 17.5 per cent and 22.5 per cent respectively. The change would affect just over a quarter of households in Scotland and have no impact on the 1.8 million or so properties that are in bands A to D.
The change is set out in article 2 of the draft order. It would make the council tax more proportionate. Indeed, the independent Resolution Foundation report in April this year stated that the proposals would increase the proportionality of council tax. The question that is being put to the committee and the Parliament in considering the draft order is whether we want council tax to be more proportionate by requiring people in band E to H properties to pay slightly more. If the new multipliers were implemented, with the present rates of council tax, charges for affected properties would still remain on average less than the equivalent in England or if there had been no council tax freeze. The measure will raise an additional £500 million over this parliamentary session.
The draft order is, of course, not the only change that the Scottish Government proposes. The committee has representations on other measures, some of which relate to regulations that amend the council tax reduction scheme and are presently under consideration by the Social Security Committee. Other changes are non-legislative or can be delivered within existing powers.
I note that the committee has taken evidence on a number of issues that are beyond the subject of the draft order, including a lively discussion last week on how the changes might be communicated to households. However, the resolution of many of those points will be achieved through dialogue and agreement between, in the main, the Scottish Government, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the local government revenue and benefits practitioner community.
The changes can be implemented in April 2017. Wider change, as some of the evidence to the committee confirms, cannot be delivered in that timeframe, for administrative or legislative reasons. For example, the powers under which the draft order is made do not extend to notification to taxpayers or funding to councils to implement the changes. However, the powers allow ministers to amend the proportions that determine the council tax that is charged on all dwellings in relation to the band E charge set by councils.
The key question to consider when assessing whether the draft order should be approved is whether we want to make council tax more proportionate by requiring people who are in properties in bands E to H to pay relatively more.