The big difference with legislatures where PLOs are not allowed to ask questions of cabinet secretaries is that those PLOs are expressly bound by the ministerial code to support the Government position and are in effect covered by collective responsibility. The old pre-2008 code, which was from a time when we had ministerial aides, made it clear that that was the case and that aides had to go further than the usual following of the whip. That code said:
“their position as Ministerial Parliamentary Aides means that they must support the Executive on key policy issues.”
That is why, before 2007, a ministerial parliamentary aide who wanted to take a different view in committee or in the chamber would resign from their position.
That provision was removed from the code. That was a significant step, because, first and foremost, PLOs are MSPs, which is why it would be wrong of the Parliament to come up with a situation in which a set of back-bench MSPs were not allowed to ask questions. We have had discussions with the Presiding Officer—at the deputy convener’s behest, I think—about making the process more transparent so that, if a PLO asks a question, people know that they are a PLO and can put any colouring on to the question that they want. That is helpful. It is about transparency, which is important because I have seen a few articles in the papers in which some journalist has said, “That was a softball question,” and so on. Such transparency shows that the system is working.
Government back benchers will always be accused of asking softball questions and Opposition members will be accused of asking highly politicised questions—that is the way of Parliament. We will see how the changes work out over the coming period, but I hope that they have got us to a position in which there is an increase in transparency so that, even if people think that a question from a PLO is a softball question, they know that the person is a PLO and there is no secrecy in the system.
One of our Parliament’s strengths is that, as it has grown over the years, we have grown more open and more transparent. I contrast that with other places that have perhaps closed in.