As in the statement on the programme for government on Tuesday, there was not a word there on either why or how the change would improve safety, and I think that I know why.
Since the Scottish Government first outlined its plans, I have received a series of emails from some of the 300 serving British Transport Police officers in Scotland. Let me tell the First Minister what some of them say. This came from an officer with nine years’ experience:
“If this goes ahead the effect on policing services would be horrific. We are a specialist force for a reason. Cross-border crimes would potentially become unmanageable.”
Another police officer with 17 years’ experience said:
“Like many others imposed on us, this is a ludicrous idea with no consultation to those actually doing the job at hand.”
Another with 24 years’ service said:
“I cannot understand why this decision can possibly be made without full consultation with the travelling public ... or even Police Scotland.”
Added to that, the British Transport Police Federation said this week that the change could leave the whole network “unguarded”.
Why is the federation wrong, and why are serving police officers who keep us safe on the railways wrong, too?