To ask the First Minister when she will next meet the Secretary of State for Scotland. (S4F-03299)
Official Report · Chamber
Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 6
- Ruth Davidson Con 3
- Tricia Marwick 1
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 1
- Cara Hilton Lab 1
- James Dornan SNP 1
The record
13 contributionsTonight.
Many of the income tax decisions that were announced in the budget yesterday will not apply to Scotland’s workers. Such decisions will be for this Parliament to make, and they require serious analysis and proper thought. Last year, the Scottish Conservatives brought together an independent commission of experts to study that issue in detail, and their recommendations were published in January.
The First Minister has at her disposal a team of economic advisers, as well as an army of civil servants. What detailed analysis has she published about how we can use the new tax powers to strengthen Scotland’s economy?
As I said to Kezia Dugdale, we will set out our proposals on income tax early next week. When we do that, we will set out the analysis that backs up the decisions that we will take on income tax.
It is interesting that Ruth Davidson says that she appointed a commission to look into how we can best use new income tax powers for Scotland. From what she has said, it seems that she does not propose to use those powers at all and that she will simply mimic George Osborne. That is the wrong choice for Scotland.
It is obvious that no analysis or evidence base has been put forward. Incredibly, if we run through the minutes of meetings of the First Minister’s Council of Economic Advisers from any point in the past year, we see that the new tax powers do not even merit discussion. That was evident yesterday, when we saw the Deputy First Minister on the television looking like a rabbit in the headlights as he talked about how those powers will be used.
I do not want to see a sign at the border that says “Higher taxes here”. I think that that is the wrong choice for Scotland, and I am not the only one who thinks that. In this morning’s press, Jack Perry, the former chief executive of Scottish Enterprise, wrote:
“a further tax grab ... will only weaken our tax base and depress the economy. That will do nothing to help support schools, hospitals and an ageing population.”
Mr Perry ran Scotland’s main enterprise body for five and a half years. He is not a politician. I ask the First Minister: why is he wrong?
As I have said repeatedly, I will set out my proposals on income tax. It is interesting that Ruth Davidson is not proposing to use the income tax powers. Over the past year, how many times has she stood over there and said to me, “The time is soon when we will all have to decide how we will use the income tax powers”? Yet, as she confirmed at her conference, she is not proposing a single iota of difference from George Osborne’s tax proposals.
Ruth Davidson led the troops up to the top of the hill, promising a 30p tax band but, when she got them there, she said that she was going to march them straight back down again. She is going to mimic George Osborne; I am going to take the decisions that are right for Scotland.
If Ruth Davidson wants to talk about differences between Scotland and England, I will give her some. If someone is a taxpayer in Scotland, their children do not pay for a university education, unlike in England. If someone is a taxpayer in Scotland, they do not pay for personal care for their elderly parents, unlike in England. If someone is a taxpayer in Scotland, they get medicines free when they are sick, unlike in England.
Those are some of the benefits that taxpayers in Scotland get—unlike those in England—but which Ruth Davidson wants to take away. Perhaps she will answer this: how much do the Tories think that people should pay for a university education and how much would she have the prescription charge return to? Let us have some answers from her before she has the nerve to stand here and lecture anyone else.
We have some constituency questions.
link
Earlier today, I received notification that Z Hinchliffe & Sons, which is a textile company with a factory in Dalry in my constituency, began this morning to issue 90-day redundancy notices to its 86 employees, although the factory has been in full operation throughout an initial 30-day consultation period. The company claims to be in negotiations with a potential buyer but has refused to name that buyer or allow Scottish Enterprise to help find another. The management, which is based in Huddersfield, has also refused to let the partnership action for continuing employment team into the factory to speak to the workers. Given those circumstances, what pressure can be put on Z Hinchliffe to ensure that the workforce is given the assistance that it needs and deserves at this difficult time?
I am aware of the developing situation at Z Hinchliffe in Dalry and I was concerned when I learned about it. This is an anxious time for the company’s employees, their families and the local community. Fergus Ewing will be engaging directly with the business and I assure Kenny Gibson that we will do everything that we can to ensure that the workforce is given the assistance that it needs and deserves at this difficult time. I undertake today to ensure that Fergus Ewing keeps the member fully updated about those discussions.
The First Minister will be aware that Longannet power station in my constituency will close at the end of the month, with the loss of 236 jobs locally and more than 1,000 jobs across central Scotland in the supply chain. A £9 million economic recovery plan has been drawn up by Fife Council, Clackmannanshire Council and Falkirk Council. The plan is vital to the long-term economic regeneration of the area, as it will enable recovery from what will be a devastating blow to Kincardine and surrounding communities.
I was disappointed to hear this week from Fife Council leader David Ross that the plan is not going to be funded by the Scottish Government. Will the First Minister please reconsider that decision before Longannet closes on 31 March, to ensure that the communities that I represent have a fighting chance of recovery?
We established the multiagency, multipartner task force to consider such issues when the decision about Longannet’s future was announced. We continue to engage with Fife Council about proposals to support economic regeneration and recovery in the area. We have also been working through the task force and our PACE organisation to help individuals into alternative employment, and I understand that many of the individuals who were employed in Longannet have been able to move into alternative employment. We will continue to engage with the local council through the task force, and with members who represent the area, to ensure that we are doing everything possible and appropriate to help individuals and the local economy.
The First Minister will be aware of the announcement by ClydeUnion Pumps, which is part of the SPX group and is based in my constituency, that consultations have begun with unions on the prospect of the company making 114 workers redundant. If that comes to pass, it will mean that more than one third of the workforce has gone in the past 12 months, after the loss of 90 jobs last year.
Given the company’s importance to my constituency—for example, my mother and my brother worked in it—and the fact that, starting as Weir Pumps, the plant has stood on Newlands Road since 1886, will the First Minister tell me what the Scottish Government can do to help the workers who are threatened with redundancy and to help the company through the temporary downturn in the oil and gas industry?
I am acutely aware of the situation and of the impact that it will have on those who work there, their families and the local area. Indeed, as the MSP for the neighbouring constituency, I know the importance of the employer and how long-standing its presence has been in the south side of Glasgow.
I can tell James Dornan that Scottish Enterprise met the company yesterday to explore all possible options for supporting the business and retaining its highly skilled employees. Our PACE team has also been in contact with the company and is offering support for affected employees. It will remain in contact with the company and employees throughout the consultation period. We will do everything possible to ensure that all options are explored and that the workforce is given all the support that it expects and deserves at this time.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 17 Mar 2016 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Council Tax Bands (Inverclyde) Questions · 4
- Living Wage (Care Workers in Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Fracking (Central Scotland) Questions · 4
- A9 Dualling (Progress) Questions · 4
- Steel Industry (Support) Questions · 6
- Speech and Language Therapy Questions · 4
- Small Businesses (Jobs) Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Royal Alexandra Hospital (Children’s Ward) Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 24
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Commission on Widening Access (Response) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- United Kingdom Budget (Response) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Cancer Patients (Access to Diagnostic Tests) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Film Studio First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Food Members’ business · 31
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Private Housing (Tenancies) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 230
- Private Housing (Tenancies) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 47
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.