I should forewarn the chamber that there are a lot of amendments in this group and that I therefore have a lot to say.
I start with Jim Hume’s amendment 81, which would make the regulations defining “new entrants” and “persons progressing in farming” for the purposes of the relinquishment and assignation provisions subject to the affirmative procedure. I cannot support the amendment.
First, I do not think that it is necessary to increase the level of parliamentary scrutiny in this instance. It is our full intention to consult widely with stakeholders to arrive at sensible and fair definitions for “new entrants” and “persons progressing in farming”. Secondly, elsewhere in the bill—in section 74 on modern limited duration tenancies—there is another regulation-making power for defining new entrants for the purposes of that section, and that is subject to the negative procedure. The definition of new entrant is likely to be the same for both sections of the bill, so it is only logical that the level of parliamentary scrutiny should be the same for both. I therefore invite members to reject amendment 81.
Government amendments 82 and 83 ensure that, in circumstances where the tenant farming commissioner appoints and pays for a valuer as part of the relinquishing and assignation process, the commissioner can then recover those costs from the tenants.
Government amendments 84 to 90 all relate to the valuation calculation that is used in the relinquishing and assignation process. Those refinements are being made following further discussions with stakeholders to ensure that the provisions are as clear and workable as possible. Currently, the bill requires the valuer to take into account the existence of what is known as a special buyer—a person who would be willing to buy the land at a premium, because they have a particular interest in the land. However, the premium should already be factored into the holding’s market value, so it would be difficult to calculate separately. Amendment 84 means that the valuer is no longer required to take into account the existence of a special buyer.
The bill also requires the valuer to take into account any sporting interests contained in the lease. That is right and proper, but there may be other rights that have an impact on the value, such as mineral rights. Amendment 85 removes the reference to sporting rights to make sure that they are not given preference over other rights in the lease for the purposes of the valuation. It ensures that all relevant leases affecting the land are considered in the valuation process.
Amendment 86 makes it clear that the valuer is not to take into account whether the tenant has a successor that they could hypothetically have passed their tenancy on to if they were not using the section 89A process.
Amendments 87 and 89 are technical drafting changes. They make the wording in new sections 32I and 32K consistent.
I turn now to amendments 88 and 90. The bill currently says that the valuer should not take into account any increase or decrease in the value of the land that results from using the land for a purpose that is
“not an agricultural purpose or the carrying out of conservation activities”.
However, even if a use is agricultural or conservational, it might not actually be permitted under the lease, so amendments 88 and 90 make it clear that the valuer should take into account factors that impact the value of the land only if they are uses that are permitted under the lease.
Sarah Boyack emphasised at stage 2 how important it is that we make sure that the new relinquishing and assignation process works as effectively as possible. I absolutely agree, and the amendments that I have just outlined are part of ensuring that that is the case.
16:45
Of course, this is a brand new process, not just for tenants and landlords but also for agricultural valuers. With that in mind, I brought forward amendment 140, which introduces a regulation-making power that will mean that we have the flexibility to adjust the valuation provisions to make sure that they work as well as possible for the sector.
The regulations would be subject to affirmative procedure, so that the Parliament will have the opportunity to consider them fully. Equally important, we will be keen to hear the views of stakeholders from across the sector in that process. After all, they are the people who will use that new process. Throughout the bill’s passage, we have been keen to engage extensively with stakeholders on the new process, and amendment 140 demonstrates our continued commitment to that.
Alex Fergusson’s amendments 127 and 128 propose replacing the relinquishment and assignation provisions that are currently contained in section 89A with a new process. I find it ironic that, during stage 2, Alex Fergusson said that the relinquishment and assignation provisions had not received sufficient scrutiny—despite the fact that they were developed over a period of several months and involved extensive discussions with stakeholders as well as updates to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee—yet at stage 3 he brings forward substantial new provisions that have not been subject to any wider scrutiny or consultation.
The committee, including Alex Fergusson, has consistently reminded us of the need to give the bill’s provisions the scrutiny and due diligence that they merit—Alex Fergusson has reminded us of that again today. We have taken that very seriously in the preparation of the bill. When we have made notable changes during the passage of the bill, they have been developed following engagement with, and feedback from, stakeholders and the committee.
Those issues aside, I believe that the amendments proposed by Alex Fergusson are flawed in several ways. First, his proposals specify that the process can be used only by a tenant who is seeking to retire from farming. The process in the bill is aimed at supporting tenants to retire, and in practice I anticipate that the great majority of tenants who use the process will be retiring from farming, not least because of the tax implications. However, I do not believe that it would be possible to define a tenant who was “seeking to retire” in a way that was meaningful, fair and enforceable. Also, I do not believe that it would be right to exclude tenants who want to downsize as a step on the road to retirement from being able to relinquish or assign their tenancies.
Secondly, Alex Fergusson’s amendments would let the landlord announce that he wants to buy out the tenant’s interest in the lease after the tenant has already lined up an assignee. Why would a potential assignee go through the whole process of entering into negotiations with the tenant for the lease—securing finance, valuing the tenant’s interest and making an offer—if they knew the landlord would trump them if they subsequently offered to buy the tenant out at exactly the same price?
It gets worse than that. Under Alex Fergusson’s amendments, the landlord could say that he wants to buy out the tenant, block the assignation and change his mind months later. The tenant would then be able to assign the tenancy, but by that point the assignee that they had lined up would probably no longer be interested, or might not be in a position to take on the tenancy. Indeed, they might no longer be eligible if they do not meet the definition of a new entrant or progressing farmer by that point.
Under Alex Fergusson’s amendments, the tenant could assign the tenancy only to the assignee that they originally proposed at the very beginning of the process so, if the original assignee is no longer a possibility, the tenant cannot assign. In addition, there is nothing to prevent a tenant from colluding with an assignee to assign for an inflated price that the landlord could never afford, because there is nothing in Mr Fergusson’s amendment that would require the assignee to pay the price if they ever got to that point in the process.
Thirdly, if the tenant is able to successfully assign, the assignee gets a tenancy that they can rely on for only 25 years. That is because Alex Fergusson’s process lets the landlord issue the new tenant with an incontestable notice to quit, for any reason, 25 years after the tenancy is assigned.
The relinquishment and assignation provisions in the bill were carefully developed, and we have continued to engage with stakeholders on refining them throughout the bill’s parliamentary passage. Indeed, the Government’s amendments in this group reflect further feedback that we took on board from stakeholders from across the sector.
Our overarching objectives, which I think everyone in the chamber will share, are to create secure routes into retirement for existing tenants, and accessible routes into farming for newer tenants. For the reasons I have outlined, I do not believe that the process that Alex Fergusson proposes would achieve that, so I invite Parliament to reject amendments 127 and 128.
I am mystified as to why Jim Hume has brought forward amendments 129 and 130. We all know how important it is to get the law on partnerships right, as shown in the case of Salvesen v Riddell. That is something that takes a lot of time. In the supplementary delegated powers memorandum for the bill, we said that we do not think that it would be feasible for tenants in certain partnerships to use the process outlined in part 3A. However, it is crucial that we consider the issue very carefully to ensure that we do not discriminate against any group and that we are ECHR-compliant.
Although part 3A of the 1991 act applies to partnerships just now, new section 74A of the Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Act 2003 provides the power to make regulations so that ministers have the flexibility to do whatever may be necessary to get things right in the future. Jim Hume’s amendments would tie ministers’ hands before we knew what provisions we might need to make and what solutions are available.
We are acutely aware of the difficulties that are faced by people in limited partnerships. Of course, we would have supported Jim Hume if he had made proposals to help those in limited partnerships to move actively into new and more stable arrangements, but he has not done that, so we cannot support his amendments 129 or 130.
Finally in this group, I turn to the Government’s amendment 91. Section 55(4) of the Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Act 2003 lets a tenant offer to give up their tenancy before the end date in exchange for compensation from their landlord. As part of the relinquishment and assignation process that is created by section 89A of the bill, tenants under 1991 act tenancies can no longer use section 55(4) of the 2003 act, because the new process replaces it. However, the bill removes the section 55(4) right from tenants of limited duration tenancies and modern limited duration tenancies, even though they are not eligible to use the new process.
Amendment 91 simply corrects that, with the effect that tenants with MLDTs or LDTs will still be able to offer to terminate their leases early in exchange for compensation from their landlord under section 55 of the 2003 act.