Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Air Passenger Duty (Abolition)

Topical Question Time

Tuesday 15 March 2016 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 12 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Alison McInnes LD North East Scotland
link

To ask the Scottish Government what independent assessment has been carried out into the impact of abolishing air passenger duty (S4T-01363).

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

We will reduce the burden of air passenger duty in Scotland by 50 per cent, with the reduction beginning when a Scottish replacement tax is introduced in April 2018 and delivered in full by the end of the next session of the Scottish Parliament, which is expected to be in 2021. We will also abolish the tax entirely when resources allow.

We launched a public consultation on a Scottish replacement tax on Monday 14 March. The consultation seeks views on how the replacement tax should be structured and operated to help boost Scotland’s international connectivity and generate sustainable growth. In recognition of the important environmental issues that need to be considered, a consultation has also been launched on the initial findings and proposed scope and methodology of the strategic environmental assessment that we are undertaking.

Alison McInnes LD North East Scotland
link

My question was what independent assessment had been carried out. In 2013, my colleague Willie Rennie asked the same question and asked for the evidence. In the official written answer at that time, which I have, the Scottish Government referred us to the easyJet corporate website, to a report that had been commissioned by four airlines. Did I miss the news—is the Scottish Government now just a wholly owned subsidiary of the aviation industry?

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

If Alison McInnes had listened to my initial answer, she would know that I mentioned that we have gone out to consultation. In addition, we have a stakeholder group, which includes, for example, environmental groups and others. Of course, the industry will have an interest in the issue. In addition to the reports that she mentioned, there is the York Aviation report. Those reports are in the public domain, but it is important that we take on everyone’s views. We have sought to do that by establishing the stakeholder group, which will also consider responses to the initial findings of the strategic environmental assessment, and the further responses from consultees—that is, from anyone in the country who wants to respond. That is the responsible way to proceed and it will give us an idea of the feelings of those who would be most affected by the change.

Alison McInnes LD North East Scotland
link

The York Aviation report was also commissioned by the aviation industry—you could not make it up. Look at the stakeholder forum that the minister has referred to—I counted 15 airlines and airport representatives and just one environmental voice. Is that really the best balance that the minister can get?

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

No, there is more than one environmental voice. As well as Stop Climate Chaos Scotland, we have links with Scottish Environmental LINK, which also responded. We are taking the point very seriously. However, the proposal will have a profound effect on airlines and airports, and it is only natural that we want to take their views on how best to proceed. We have also undertaken a separate environmental assessment on the likely emissions.

We are moving forward in a responsible way. I do not hear from Alison McInnes a single word of support for a measure that will greatly increase economic activity in Scotland and provide benefits for passengers and for small businesses, tourist attractions and the general economy across the country. It is a positive move, and it would be nice if Alison McInnes could occasionally be positive about some of the things that the Scottish Government does.

Alison McInnes LD North East Scotland
link

Stop Climate Chaos Scotland has said that a cut in APD would lead to 60,000 more tonnes of CO2, which is on top of emission targets being missed for four years running and a 10 per cent cut in the climate change budget. Passenger numbers are already at record levels. Is a £250 million aviation tax break not the final nail in the coffin of the Scottish National Party’s green credentials?

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

The reference to £250 million is as accurate as some of the other statements that Alison McInnes has made. It is completely wrong.

What would have been the purpose of consulting and involving in the stakeholder group only those with whom we agreed? That is why Stop Climate Chaos is there.

We have to meet the emissions impact targets across the whole range of Government activity. It is also possible to introduce the replacement tax in a way that will have the effect of reducing emissions, not least by encouraging, if that is what is chosen to be done, long-haul routes at the expense of short-haul routes. That way, some of the most environmentally damaging short-haul routes can be cut out. This is a positive move, and it is being received very positively. We will of course take on board the views of all interest groups, including those with an environmental interest. That is why they are involved in the stakeholder group, and that is the right way to proceed.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

Given that Aberdeen airport is in my constituency and that the managing director of Aberdeen airport has been very open about the economic benefits that would be brought not just to the airport but to the wider north-east economy as a consequence of a reduction in air passenger duty, does the minister share my horror that a north-east representative in the shape of Alison McInnes is talking down the impact that the proposal could have on the economy of the region that she is supposed to represent?

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

Mark McDonald makes a good point. It would be interesting to hear a conversation between Alison McInnes and Carol Benzie, the chief executive of the airport, in which Alison McInnes tries to talk against something that, according to one study, would have led to around 0.7 million additional passengers passing through Scotland’s airports in 2015, rising to 0.9 million by 2020, as well as the direct, indirect and induced impact of a 50 per cent reduction in operational impact, and nearly 4,000 additional jobs and £200 million per annum in gross value added by 2020. Those are the beneficial effects of the measure.

As well as the Government having to address the issues of people who have concerns about the matter, it would be interesting to hear Alison McInnes—I do not know whether she is arguing for APD staying as it is or for increasing it even further, bearing in mind that it is already the most expensive tax of its type in the world—address the concerns of people who support the move.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I welcome the Government’s consultation, including on the impact on the environment. Will the Scottish Government talk to the Dutch Government? In 2008-09, the Dutch Government applied APD to accrue €280 million but scrapped it after 18 months because it was losing €1.3 billion and many jobs in the hospitality and tourism industry.

Keith Brown SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link

We are very conscious of that example, and we would, of course, be more than happy to receive a submission from Chic Brodie on that particular point, which we have noted.

I think that, in the previous United Kingdom Parliament, the UK Government afforded Northern Ireland the opportunity to reduce APD to zero for transatlantic flights. That is interesting. I also think that the Liberal Democrats supported that. The question is why the Liberal Democrats would support that for other parts of the United Kingdom but not for Scotland.

I entirely agree with Chic Brodie that other places, including the Republic of Ireland, have found it very beneficial to avoid doing what the UK seems to have wanted to do in relation to Scotland, which is to give the country the highest tax of its type in the world and therefore an inhibition on economic activity.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  3. Air Passenger Duty (Abolition) Questions · 12
  4. High-speed Broadband (Access) Questions · 14
  5. Energy Strategy Statement · 27
  6. Forth Road Bridge Inquiry Debate · 75
  7. Standing Orders Rule Changes (Legislation) Debate · 5
  8. Standing Orders Rule Changes (Admissibility of Petitions and Minor Changes) Debate · 5
  9. Reimbursement of Members’ Expenses Scheme Debate · 2
  10. Decision Time Decision time · 4
  11. Hamilton Academical Football Club (Community Ethos) Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.